Comparison of health outcomes between traumatic spinal cord and cauda equina injuries

Xenia Zubenko, Susan Liew, Sandra Reeder, Belinda J. GabbeResearch Square 2025 · DOI

Abstract

Study design: Registry-based cohort study.
Objectives: To compare the outcomes of people who have a traumatic spinal cord injury (SCI) or cauda equina injury (CEI).
Setting: Victorian State Trauma System (VSTS), Australia.
Methods: People from the Victorian State Trauma Registry (VSTR) with a diagnosis of traumatic SCI below T4 or CEI, with a date of injury from 2010 to December 2022, were included. Participants were divided into two groups: upper motor neuron (UMN) and lower motor neuron (LMN) injury groups. Demographic, injury event, and hospital stay details were extracted. Follow-up was conducted by the registry up to 24 months post-injury, including the World Health Organization Disability Assessment Schedule (WHODAS), EuroQol EQ-5D scale, and return to work.
Results: Of the 1,156 participants, 1,113 were categorized as UMN and 43 as LMN. Demographics were similar between groups. Mixed-effect regression modeling of EQ-5D outcomes showed little improvement over time for both groups. Return to work rates were higher for the LMN group (72% vs. 57% at 24 months). At 24 months, significant disability (WHODAS ≥ 10) was reported by 63% of the UMN group and 65% of the LMN group.
Conclusion: Patient demographics were similar across groups. Quality of life outcomes remained persistently poor for both groups, showing minimal improvement over the 24-month follow-up period.

Introduction

Spinal injuries are traditionally categorized by their vertebral location. However, a more critical biological distinction exists between the central nervous system (Upper Motor Neuron/UMN) and the peripheral nervous system (Lower Motor Neuron/LMN). UMN injuries occur within the spinal cord (typically above L1/L2), whereas LMN injuries involve the cauda equina—the bundle of nerve roots at the base of the spine.

While peripheral nerves (LMN) possess a theoretically higher potential for regeneration compared to the central nervous system (UMN), clinical evidence regarding whether this translates into superior real-world outcomes is inconsistent. This study utilizes a large population-based registry to investigate whether these biological differences result in distinct long-term recovery trajectories in terms of quality of life (QoL), disability, and employment.

Methods

This registry-based cohort study utilized data from the Victorian State Trauma Registry (VSTR) in Australia, covering injuries occurring between 2010 and 2022.

Participant Classification

Participants were categorized into two groups:

  • UMN Group: Injuries located from T4 to L1, including the conus medullaris.
  • LMN Group: Injuries at L2 and below, or specific cauda equina diagnoses.

Data Collection and Follow-up

The study tracked outcomes at 6, 12, and 24 months post-injury. Key metrics included the EQ-5D for generic health status, the WHODAS 2.0 for functional disability, and Return to Work (RTW) rates. Data from the VSTR was supplemented by the Victorian Registry of Deaths, Births, and Marriages to track post-discharge mortality.

Flowchart of patient inclusion and follow-up through 24 months.

Results

The final cohort consisted of 1,156 participants, with a significant imbalance between the UMN (n=1,113) and LMN (n=43) groups.

Recovery Plateaus

A primary finding was the lack of significant improvement in quality-of-life scores between the 6-month and 24-month follow-up points. For both groups, the level of disability reported early in recovery tended to persist, suggesting a functional plateau. High levels of pain and discomfort were reported across both groups, remaining a primary barrier to recovery.

Injury Etiology

UMN injuries were primarily associated with high-energy road trauma. Conversely, LMN injuries were more frequently caused by "low falls" (from standing height), particularly among older populations.

Employment and Disability

Despite reporting similar levels of pain and disability on standardized scales, the LMN group demonstrated significantly better employment outcomes. At 24 months, 72% of the LMN group had returned to work, compared to 57% of the UMN group. However, high levels of disability remained prevalent; 65% of LMN patients and 63% of UMN patients reported a WHODAS score ≥ 10 at the two-year mark.

Discussion

The findings suggest that while LMN injuries may allow for better return-to-work rates, the overall burden of disability and impact on quality of life are remarkably similar to UMN injuries. The "employment paradox"—where LMN patients return to work more frequently despite similar disability scores—may indicate that standard metrics like EQ-5D and WHODAS miss subtle functional differences or that LMN injuries preserve specific physical requirements necessary for employment.

Limitations

The study's primary limitation is the small sample size of the LMN group relative to the UMN group, which constrained statistical power. Additionally, the use of a fixed vertebral level (L2) for classification may lead to miscategorization due to individual anatomical variation. Finally, generic tools like the EQ-5D may lack the sensitivity to capture specific complications such as bowel, bladder, and sexual dysfunction.

Conclusion

In summary, while biological differences exist between UMN and LMN injuries, long-term health outcomes and quality of life remain poor for both groups. Future research should focus on more consistent definitions of these injury types and the development of more sensitive metrics to capture the full spectrum of secondary complications.

Summary updated

Abstract

<title>Abstract</title> <bold>Study design:</bold> Registry-based cohort. study <bold>Objectives:</bold> To compare the outcomes of people who have a traumatic spinal cord injury (SCI) or cauda equina injury (CEI). <bold>Setting:</bold> Victorian State Trauma System (VSTS), Australia. <bold>Methods:</bold> People from the Victorian State Trauma Registry (VSTR) with a diagnosis of traumatic SCI below T4 or CEI, with a date of injury from 2010 to December 2022, were included. Participants were divided into two groups; upper motor neuron (UMN) and lower motor neuron (LMN) injury groups. Demographic, injury event, and hospital stay details were extracted. Follow-up was conducted by the registry up to 24-months post injury, and included the World Health Organization Disability Assessment Schedule (WHODAS), EuroQol EQ-5D scale, and return to work. <bold>Results:</bold> Of the 1,156 participants, 1,113 were categorised as UMN, and 43 as LMN. Within both groups, the demographics were similar. Mixed effect regression modelling of the EQ-5D outcomes over time showed little improvement for both groups. The return to work rate was higher for the LMN injury group at all follow-up time points, with 57% of the UMN injury group returning to work at 24 months post-injury compared to 72% of the LMN injury group. At 24 months post-injury, 63% of people in the UMN injury group reported a WHODAS score equal or greater to ten, compared to 65% in the LMN injury group. <bold>Conclusion:</bold> In conclusion, the patient demographics within the two groups were similar. Overall quality of life outcomes remained similarly poor over time for both groups, with little improvement.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zubenko2025comparison,
  author = {Xenia Zubenko and Susan Liew and Sandra Reeder and Belinda J. Gabbe},
  title = {{Comparison of health outcomes between traumatic spinal cord and cauda equina injuries}},
  booktitle = {Research Square},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.21203/rs.3.rs-6953477/v1},
}
Figure