COMPARISON OF GRAMMAR INTERVENTION PBLAND PBL IN JUNIOR MIDDLE SCHOOL ENGLISH READING

Ke Xu, Mohd Ridzuan Darun, Tingting GaoInternational Journal of Social Science and Business Management 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates whether integrating explicit grammar instruction into Problem-Based Learning (PBL) improves English reading comprehension for junior high school students. The findings suggest that Grammar Intervention PBL (GIPBL) leads to significantly better reading comprehension scores and higher student satisfaction compared to traditional PBL.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

English reading comprehension is a critical skill for academic success, yet many junior high school students struggle with it. While Problem-Based Learning (PBL) is a popular pedagogical approach, some researchers argue it may neglect fundamental language skills like grammar, which can hinder comprehension. This is particularly relevant in China, where educational reforms emphasize PBL but teachers sometimes misinterpret it as excluding direct grammar instruction. This study addresses the gap by exploring whether a modified PBL approach, incorporating targeted grammar intervention (GIPBL), is more effective than standard PBL for improving English reading comprehension in junior high students, who may require more scaffolding than older learners.

Methods

The researchers employed a quasi-experimental design with a control group and an experimental group. 120 eighth-grade students from two parallel classes at a foreign language school in China participated. The control group received standard Problem-Based Learning (PBL), while the experimental group received Grammar Intervention PBL (GIPBL). Both groups focused on English reading.

The study utilized a mixed-methods approach:

  • Pre- and Post-tests: A reading test was administered before and after the intervention to measure changes in comprehension.
  • Satisfaction Questionnaire: A Likert-scale questionnaire assessed students' satisfaction with the teaching methods.
  • Demographic Data Form: Collected basic student information.

The GIPBL intervention involved:

  • Content: Integrating grammar instruction (sentence structure, tense, voice, etc.) alongside reading comprehension skills (summarizing, inferring).
  • Activity: Teachers provided minimal lectures on complex sentence structures, grammar barriers, and new vocabulary, followed by student group discussions and problem-solving.
  • Time Allocation: A small portion of class time (15 minutes) was dedicated to grammar.
  • Assessment: Modified to include subjective questions beyond multiple-choice to better gauge comprehension.

Datasets

The study did not introduce new datasets or benchmarks. Data was collected from 120 junior high school students in China using:

  • A demographic data form.
  • A reading test (pre- and post-intervention).
  • A satisfaction questionnaire.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Grammar is not the enemy of PBL: Contrary to some interpretations, integrating grammar instruction within a PBL framework can enhance, rather than detract from, its effectiveness.
  • Scaffolding is crucial for younger learners: Junior high students, unlike tertiary learners for whom PBL was originally developed, may benefit significantly from explicit scaffolding, especially in areas like grammar, to overcome comprehension barriers.
  • Student satisfaction aligns with effectiveness: Higher reading comprehension scores in GIPBL were mirrored by greater student satisfaction, suggesting that when students feel more supported and understand better, they are more engaged.
  • Beyond rote learning: The study highlights that effective reading comprehension involves more than just identifying answers; it requires understanding underlying meaning and context, which GIPBL appears to foster more effectively.

Key Results

  • Reading Comprehension: The GIPBL group showed significantly higher post-test reading comprehension scores (9.63±0.55) compared to the PBL group (6.87±1.06) (p<0.001). The learning progress (change in scores) was also significantly greater for the GIPBL group (12.31±1.72 points) than the PBL group (10.11±1.6 points) (F=23.55, p<0.001).
  • Student Satisfaction: While both groups reported high satisfaction, the GIPBL group expressed significantly higher levels of satisfaction with the instructional strategies, reporting more interaction, deeper learning, and better preparation for exams.
  • Acceptance of GIPBL: 82% of students in the GIPBL group found it to be a more acceptable and effective teaching method.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Sample Size: The study involved a limited sample size (120 students), which may affect the generalizability of the findings.
  • Study Duration: The intervention period was relatively short (three weeks), and a longer duration might yield more robust results.
  • Tutor's Influence: The tutor's intention could have influenced student satisfaction.

Future work could involve:

  • Further investigation into the effectiveness of GIPBL with larger and more diverse student populations.
  • Exploring the long-term impact of GIPBL on reading comprehension and other language skills.
  • Investigating how to best implement GIPBL across different English language learning contexts.

Summary updated

Abstract

&#x0D; &#x0D; &#x0D; &#x0D; This paper compares the effectiveness of grammar intervention problem-based learning (GIPBL) and problem-based learning (PBL). PBLis a constructivism-based popular teaching pedagogy previously used in medical education, then widely applied in other fields of education, including junior high school English reading teaching. However, researchers of Scaffolding learning theory argue that grammar intervention PBL (GIPBL) is more suitable for Junior high students in English reading courses. To compare the effect of GIPBL and PBL on satisfaction and learning process in junior high school Grade 3 students, this study does a quasi-experimental study in Jiangyou Foreign Language Experimental School in Sichuan Province, China. The participants include 120 students of grade 8 in two different classes in Junior High School. Experimental and control groups are designed.The practical class is taught in GIPBL,and the control class is taught in PBL. Both classes are about learning English reading, an integral part of the English course.Pretest and post-test were applied. The instruments were a demographic questionnaire,reading test and satisfaction questionnaire. The result shows that students' reading comprehension scores in GIPBL are better than those of the control group. GIPBL broadens the implementation of PBL in practice. There was more satisfaction with GIPBL. 82% of students thought GIPBL was a more acceptable and effective teaching method. The result shows that Grammar Intervention PBL suits junior and middle school students in English reading courses.&#x0D; &#x0D; &#x0D; &#x0D;
BibTeX
@article{xu2024comparison,
  author = {Ke Xu and Mohd Ridzuan Darun and Tingting Gao},
  title = {{COMPARISON OF GRAMMAR INTERVENTION PBLAND PBL IN JUNIOR MIDDLE SCHOOL ENGLISH READING}},
  journal = {International Journal of Social Science and Business Management},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.59021/ijssbm.v2i01.83},
}
Figure