Abstract
Background: Accurate assessment of coronary artery disease is essential for guiding clinical decision-making, particularly in cases involving complex coronary lesions. Fractional Flow Reserve (FFR) remains the reference standard for lesion-specific ischemia evaluation; however, it is invasive and requires pharmacologically induced hyperemia. Emerging non-invasive alternatives, including Quantitative Flow Ratio (QFR) derived from coronary angiography (CAG) and Ultrasonic Flow Ratio (UFR) derived from intravascular ultrasound (IVUS), offer promising diagnostic value. This study aimed to compare the diagnostic performance of UFR and QFR against FFR in the assessment of complex coronary lesions.
Methods: In this retrospective, multicenter study, 217 patients (220 vessels) with coronary artery lesions who underwent both IVUS and FFR measurement were included. UFR was derived from IVUS imaging using a deep learning model for vessel boundary identification and computational fluid dynamics (CFD) for pressure drop calculation. QFR was computed using standard coronary angiography data. Correlation coefficients, agreement analyses, and diagnostic metrics were employed to evaluate performance against FFR.
Results: UFR demonstrated a stronger correlation with FFR (r = 0.79, p < 0.001) compared to QFR (r = 0.68, p < 0.001). UFR exhibited superior diagnostic performance, with an area under the ROC curve (AUC) of 0.91, exceeding that of QFR (AUC = 0.86). In subsets of complex lesions—specifically diffuse, bifurcation, and heavily calcified lesions—UFR consistently outperformed QFR, particularly in bifurcation and calcified lesions where QFR accuracy was significantly reduced (72.5% vs. 86.8%, p = 0.001).
Conclusion: UFR provides enhanced diagnostic accuracy compared to QFR for complex coronary lesions and represents a reliable alternative to FFR, particularly in challenging anatomical scenarios. Clinical integration of UFR may reduce reliance on invasive FFR measurements while preserving diagnostic precision.
Introduction
To determine whether a coronary artery stenosis requires intervention, clinicians must assess its functional significance—whether the blockage actually restricts blood flow—rather than relying solely on visual anatomical assessment. While Fractional Flow Reserve (FFR) is the established gold standard, its invasive nature, cost, and the need for hyperemic agents present significant barriers to routine use.
Non-invasive alternatives like Quantitative Flow Ratio (QFR) use 2D X-ray angiography to reconstruct 3D models and simulate flow. However, QFR often struggles with "complex" lesions, such as those that are heavily calcified, involve vessel branching (bifurcations), or are excessively long (diffuse). In these cases, 2D imaging suffers from vessel overlap and poor edge visibility. This study investigates Ultrasonic Flow Ratio (UFR), which utilizes high-resolution Intravascular Ultrasound (IVUS) to provide a cross-sectional view from within the vessel, potentially overcoming the limitations of angiography-based methods.
Methods
This retrospective, multicenter study analyzed data from 217 patients (220 vessels) across three major clinical centers. The methodology compared three distinct modalities:
- FFR (Reference Standard): Invasive pressure-wire measurements obtained during hyperemia.
- QFR (Angiography-based): 3D reconstruction derived from two angiographic views at different angles, utilizing a contrast flow model to estimate blood velocity.
- UFR (IVUS-based): A novel approach using the RefineNet10 deep learning model to automatically segment vessel boundaries from IVUS pullbacks. This is followed by 3D reconstruction and the application of Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) to calculate pressure drops based on the physical geometry of the lumen and plaque.
Lesion complexity was defined by a length ≥20 mm, involvement of a bifurcation, or heavy calcification (calcium arc >270°). Notably, 75.9% of the vessels in this cohort were classified as complex.
Results and Discussion
Diagnostic Accuracy and Correlation
UFR showed a significantly stronger correlation with the invasive FFR (r = 0.79) than QFR (r = 0.68). In terms of overall diagnostic accuracy, UFR achieved an Area Under the Curve (AUC) of 0.91, outperforming QFR’s 0.86. UFR also demonstrated higher sensitivity (80.2% vs. 68.1%) and specificity (90.4% vs. 87.5%) in identifying hemodynamically significant blockages.
Performance in Complex Lesions
The most significant finding was the stability of UFR in the presence of anatomical complexity. While QFR’s accuracy dropped from 92.5% in simple lesions to 72.5% in complex cases, UFR maintained a consistent accuracy of approximately 85-86% regardless of complexity. This suggests that the cross-sectional "map" provided by IVUS allows UFR to account for irregular plaque shapes and calcium shadows that typically confound 2D X-ray interpretations.
The "Grey Zone" Challenge
In cases where FFR values fall between 0.75 and 0.85—the clinical "grey zone" where treatment decisions are most difficult—UFR maintained a higher diagnostic AUC (0.77) compared to QFR (0.70). This indicates that UFR may serve as a more reliable tie-breaker for ambiguous clinical scenarios.
Conclusion
UFR represents a significant advancement in the non-invasive assessment of coronary artery disease. By providing superior diagnostic accuracy in complex lesions—specifically those involving bifurcations and heavy calcification—UFR offers a robust alternative to invasive FFR. While further prospective trials are needed to confirm long-term patient outcomes, the integration of UFR into clinical workflows could reduce the need for invasive pressure wires without compromising diagnostic precision.
Summary updated