Comparison of Flood Resilience Between Low-Carbon and Traditional Communities: A Case Study of Kunming, China

Zheng Zhang, Dan Zhou, Ling Zhu, Zhiqiang Xie, Wei Cheng, Q. Yang, Junxiao Wang, Zhiyong Yuan, Yifei Liu, Yang Li, Ping Wen, Shihan Bai, Sidong ZhaoLand 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates the relationship between flood resilience (UFR) and low-carbon development (ULC) in traditional and newly built low-carbon communities in Kunming, China. It finds that while traditional communities currently exhibit higher flood resilience, both community types show a strong coupling between UFR and ULC, suggesting that low-carbon development has the potential to significantly enhance flood resilience over time.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

As global climate change intensifies, urban areas face increasing risks from extreme weather events like floods. China's "dual carbon" strategy aims to reduce emissions and promote low-carbon development, with the expectation that this will also bolster urban flood resilience. However, the actual effectiveness of low-carbon communities in enhancing flood resilience remains unclear. This gap in understanding hinders effective disaster prevention and urban planning. This paper addresses this by comparing the flood resilience and low-carbon development levels of established traditional communities with newer, purpose-built low-carbon communities in Kunming, aiming to quantify their differences and explore the synergistic relationship between these two critical aspects of urban sustainability.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-faceted approach:

  • Evaluation Index Systems: They developed distinct index systems for flood resilience (UFR) and low-carbon development (ULC), drawing on national and local Chinese standards and incorporating insights from existing literature. These systems cover dimensions like natural environment, infrastructure, carbon emissions, and transportation.
  • Weight Determination: To minimize subjectivity, they used a combined CRITIC-entropy weight method to assign importance to each indicator within the evaluation systems.
  • TOPSIS Method: The Technique for Order of Preference by Similarity to Ideal Solution (TOPSIS) was used to calculate the UFR and ULC for each grid within the study areas, providing a quantitative score for each community.
  • Coupling Coordination Analysis Model: This model was applied to assess the degree of interaction (coupling) and synergy (coordination) between UFR and ULC.
  • Geographic Detector: This tool was used to identify the key factors influencing spatial variations in flood resilience and low-carbon development.
  • Spatial Autocorrelation (Moran's I): This statistical method was employed to analyze the spatial clustering patterns of the coupling coordination degree, revealing spatial dependence and identifying areas of high or low coordination.

Datasets

The study utilized a variety of datasets:

  • Administrative divisions, population density, and GDP: Sourced from the Data Center for Resources Science and Environment, Chinese Academy of Sciences.
  • Elevation data: Obtained from the Geospatial Data Cloud.
  • Land-use information: Derived from Kunming's Third National Land Survey.
  • Points of Interest (POI) data: Extracted using Amap Web Service API for infrastructure like sports facilities, healthcare, charging stations, financial services, and public transport.
  • Road network, drainage pipeline, building contour, and regulating reservoir data: Provided by the Kunming Municipal Survey and Mapping Research Institute.
  • Rail transit data: Obtained from open-source maps.
  • Carbon emission data: Collected for each prefecture-level city in China.

No new benchmark datasets were introduced; rather, existing data was integrated and analyzed.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Initial Disparity: The study highlights that, at present, newly established low-carbon communities in Kunming do not automatically outperform traditional communities in flood resilience. This suggests that simply designating an area as "low-carbon" doesn't guarantee immediate flood resilience improvements.
  • Synergistic Potential: Despite the initial disparity, there's a strong "high coupling" between flood resilience and low-carbon development across both community types. This indicates that these two aspects are intrinsically linked and can mutually reinforce each other.
  • Long-Term Vision: The findings suggest that while traditional communities may have an advantage now, the integrated approach of low-carbon development holds significant promise for enhancing flood resilience over time. This points to the importance of sustained investment and planning.
  • Factor Importance Varies: The study identified key drivers for both UFR and ULC, with some factors being more influential in one community type than the other (e.g., financial services for traditional communities, charging stations for low-carbon communities). This underscores the need for tailored strategies.

Key Results

  • Flood Resilience (UFR): Traditional communities showed, on average, 21.53% higher flood resilience than low-carbon communities.
  • Low-Carbon Development (ULC): Low-carbon communities had, on average, 4.33% higher low-carbon development levels compared to traditional ones.
  • Coupling: UFR and ULC demonstrated a high coupling level (over 98%) in both community types, indicating a strong correlation.
  • Spatial Dependence: The Moran's I index of 0.664 for coupling coordination revealed significant spatial dependence, meaning that areas with similar coupling coordination levels tend to cluster together.
  • Key Drivers for UFR: The rain and sewage diversion ratio (C12) was the strongest explanatory factor for flood resilience (q=0.415), followed by medical service capacity (C7, q=0.360) and rainwater pipe density (C11, q=0.358).
  • Key Drivers for ULC: Charging station service capability (C20, q=0.444) and public transport station service capacity (C22, q=0.433) were the most influential factors for low-carbon development.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Data Availability: The selection of evaluation indicators was constrained by data availability, potentially omitting some relevant metrics. Future research could expand data sources for more comprehensive evaluation.
  • Objective Weighting: The study relied solely on an objective weighting method, which, while reducing bias, might overlook crucial subjective factors like expert judgment. Future work could integrate subjective and objective weighting for a more robust analysis.
  • Generalizability: The study focused on two specific communities in Kunming. Broader investigations across diverse urban contexts are needed to assess the generalizability of these findings.

Future work should focus on:

  • Developing more comprehensive evaluation index systems.
  • Exploring integrated weighting methods.
  • Conducting wider-ranging studies to confirm generalizability.
  • Identifying strategies that effectively align low-carbon development and flood resilience for optimized urban sustainability.

Summary updated

Abstract

Under China’s dual carbon strategy, low-carbon city construction is expected to help reduce urban flood risks. However, the flood resilience of low-carbon communities remains unclear, limiting effective disaster prevention. This study examines traditional and newly built low-carbon communities in Kunming, establishing indices for community flood resilience and low-carbon development according to current national and local standards. Flood resilience (UFR) and low-carbon development level (ULC) were measured using the critic–entropy weight and TOPSIS methods, and a coupling coordination analysis model was used to analyze their correlation and coordination. The results are as follows: (1) The two communities exhibit marked spatial heterogeneity in both UFR and ULC. On average, the UFR in traditional communities is 21.53% higher than in low-carbon communities, while the ULCs are 4.33% higher in low-carbon communities compared to traditional ones. (2) UFR and ULC showed a high coupling level in both communities (over 98%), indicating a strong correlation. (3) The Moran’s I index of 0.664 for coupling coordination indicates notable spatial dependence. These results suggest that, initially, low-carbon communities in Kunming may not exhibit stronger flood resilience, but low-carbon development can significantly improve flood resilience over time. This paper also provides recommendations for enhancing flood resilience in urban low-carbon communities.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2025comparison,
  author = {Zheng Zhang and Dan Zhou and Ling Zhu and Zhiqiang Xie and Wei Cheng and Q. Yang and Junxiao Wang and Zhiyong Yuan and Yifei Liu and Yang Li and Ping Wen and Shihan Bai and Sidong Zhao},
  title = {{Comparison of Flood Resilience Between Low-Carbon and Traditional Communities: A Case Study of Kunming, China}},
  booktitle = {Land},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.3390/land14071368},
}
Figure