Comparison of Durability and Gamma-Ray Shielding Performance of High-Velocity Oxygen Fuel Tungsten Carbide-Based Coatings on Cold-Rolled Steel Surface

Yeong-Ho Son, Seung Heon Baek, Beom Kyu Kim, Jeong Ho Hwang, Jae Hun Lee, Geun Dong SongCrystals 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates the use of tungsten carbide (WC)-based coatings applied via High-Velocity Oxygen Fuel (HVOF) spraying to enhance the durability and gamma-ray shielding of radioactive waste storage containers. The research found that higher WC content improves mechanical properties and shielding, while higher nickel-chromium (NiCr) content enhances corrosion resistance, offering a path to tailor coatings for specific safety requirements.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The safe management and disposal of low- and intermediate-level radioactive waste (LILW) is a critical challenge. Current storage containers, often made of cold-rolled steel, face degradation issues like corrosion and wear, compromising their long-term integrity. Furthermore, these containers typically lack inherent gamma-ray shielding capabilities, necessitating additional measures for radiation protection. This paper addresses the need for more robust and effective storage solutions by exploring advanced coating technologies that can simultaneously improve durability and radiation shielding performance.

Methods

The researchers employed the High-Velocity Oxygen Fuel (HVOF) spraying process to deposit four different tungsten carbide (WC)-NiCr composite coatings onto cold-rolled steel substrates. These coatings were categorized by their WC content: WC-85, WC-73, WC-66, and WC-39. A comprehensive evaluation was conducted, encompassing:

  • Microstructural Analysis: Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM) and Energy Dispersive Spectroscopy (EDS) were used to examine the coatings' microstructure, porosity, and elemental composition.
  • Mechanical Property Testing:
    • Hardness: Vickers hardness tests were performed to assess the coatings' resistance to indentation.
  • Wear Resistance: Taber abrasion tests were conducted using an H-22 abrasive wheel for 30,000 cycles to measure thickness reduction.
  • Adhesion Strength: Universal tensile testing (ASTM C633) was used to determine the bond strength between the coating and the substrate.
  • Corrosion Resistance: Electrochemical potentiodynamic polarization tests were performed in a simulated condensate solution to evaluate corrosion current density (icorr) and corrosion potential (Ecorr).
  • Gamma-Ray Shielding Performance: A Cs-137 gamma-ray source was used to measure the shielding efficiency of the coated samples under narrow-beam conditions.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study utilized commercially available WC-NiCr powders and standard ASTM testing procedures.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • WC Content is Key for Mechanical Strength and Shielding: The study clearly shows a direct correlation between higher WC content and improved hardness, wear resistance, and gamma-ray shielding efficiency. This is attributed to the inherent properties of tungsten carbide.
  • Cr Content is Crucial for Corrosion Resistance: Conversely, higher chromium (Cr) content in the NiCr binder phase significantly enhances corrosion resistance. The WC-39 coating, with the highest Cr content, demonstrated the best performance in this regard.
  • HVOF is a Suitable Deposition Method: The HVOF process successfully produced dense, high-adhesion coatings with minimal porosity, validating its suitability for creating durable protective layers.
  • Tailoring Coatings for Specific Needs: The findings suggest that by adjusting the WC and NiCr (specifically Cr) content, coatings can be optimized for either enhanced mechanical properties and shielding or superior corrosion resistance, allowing for tailored solutions for different storage environments.
  • Intrinsic Shielding Capability of WC: The research effectively isolated the shielding contribution of the WC coating itself, demonstrating its significant inherent ability to attenuate gamma radiation, independent of the substrate thickness.

Key Results

  • Hardness: Coatings exhibited significantly higher hardness than the substrate (113.2 HV0.3). WC-85 and WC-73 achieved hardness values around 1090 HV0.3, while WC-66 and WC-39 were around 880 HV0.3.
  • Wear Resistance: All coatings showed superior wear resistance compared to the substrate. Thickness reduction after 30,000 cycles was approximately 29 µm for WC-85, 32 µm for WC-73, 31 µm for WC-66, and 65 µm for WC-39, compared to 620 µm for the substrate.
  • Adhesion Strength: Most coatings achieved excellent adhesion strengths between 72 and 82 MPa, with WC-85 showing the highest at 82.2 MPa. WC-73 had a slightly lower adhesion of 65.2 MPa.
  • Corrosion Resistance: All WC-based coatings exhibited superior corrosion resistance compared to the substrate. The corrosion current density (icorr) for the substrate was 2.224 µA/cm², while for the coatings, it ranged from 0.620 µA/cm² (WC-85) down to 0.232 µA/cm² (WC-39). WC-39 showed the lowest icorr.
  • Gamma-Ray Shielding: All coatings significantly improved shielding efficiency over the substrate (6.65%). WC-85 achieved the highest efficiency at 9.57%, followed closely by WC-73 (8.98%), WC-66 (8.83%), and WC-39 (8.78%). The study demonstrated that WC-85 provided over a 40% improvement in shielding efficiency compared to the uncoated substrate of the same thickness.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Simulated vs. Actual Environment: The corrosion tests were conducted in an aqueous solution simulating condensate, while actual LILW storage environments are typically atmospheric. The authors note that atmospheric corrosion rates are significantly lower at controlled humidity levels, suggesting that the evaluated coatings would likely perform even better in real-world conditions.
  • Limited Cr Content Range for Corrosion: While WC-39 showed the best corrosion resistance, the study focused on four specific WC compositions. Further exploration of Cr content within the NiCr binder could potentially yield even more optimized corrosion-resistant coatings.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that depending on the specific storage container's operational environment and durability requirements, the composition of NiCr and WC in coatings can be tailored to optimize specific properties. This implies future work could involve developing more precisely engineered coatings for various applications. The study also highlights the need for further investigation into the long-term performance and durability of these coatings under actual storage conditions.

Summary updated

Abstract

This paper provides a comparative evaluation of the mechanical properties, corrosion resistance, and gamma-ray shielding performance of four different types of tungsten carbide (WC)-NiCr coatings deposited on cold-rolled steel surfaces, which are used as materials for low- and intermediate-level radioactive waste (LILW) storage containers. The four types of coatings were classified as WC-85, WC-73, WC-66, and WC-39 according to their WC content and were applied to the cold-rolled steel surfaces using the High-Velocity Oxygen Fuel (HVOF) spraying process. The performance of the layered coatings was analyzed in terms of their microstructure, hardness, wear resistance, adhesion strength, corrosion properties, and gamma-ray shielding characteristics. Coatings with elevated WC contents showed enhanced mechanical properties and gamma-ray shielding effectiveness, whereas coatings with relatively lower WC contents and higher NiCr contents exhibited greater corrosion resistance. This paper discusses the performance of WC-NiCr coatings from the viewpoint of enhancing the durability and safety of commercial LILW storage containers.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{son2024comparison,
  author = {Yeong-Ho Son and Seung Heon Baek and Beom Kyu Kim and Jeong Ho Hwang and Jae Hun Lee and Geun Dong Song},
  title = {{Comparison of Durability and Gamma-Ray Shielding Performance of High-Velocity Oxygen Fuel Tungsten Carbide-Based Coatings on Cold-Rolled Steel Surface}},
  booktitle = {Crystals},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3390/cryst15010021},
}
Figure