Comparison of 1-Site and 2-Site Phacotrabeculectomy in the Small Adult Eyes With Concomitant Cataract and Glaucoma

Xiaobo Xia, Ying Tian, Zhenkai Wu, Dan Wen, Weitao SongMedicine 2016 · DOI

TL;DR

This study compares two surgical approaches for combined cataract and glaucoma surgery in small adult eyes: a single-incision (1-site) and a two-incision (2-site) method. While both methods effectively improve vision and lower intraocular pressure, the 1-site approach appears to cause less damage to corneal endothelial cells and results in fewer refractive errors post-surgery.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Small adult eyes, often characterized by short axial length and shallow anterior chambers, present unique surgical challenges, especially when patients have both cataracts and glaucoma. These conditions often require combined surgical intervention, such as phacotrabeculectomy (a procedure to remove the cataract and improve fluid drainage to lower eye pressure). However, performing these complex surgeries in small eyes increases the risk of complications like uveal effusions, retinal detachment, and even malignant glaucoma. The existing surgical techniques, particularly the number of incisions used, might influence outcomes like corneal health and visual precision. This paper aims to clarify whether a 1-site or 2-site approach is superior for these specific patient populations.

Methods

The researchers conducted a retrospective case-control study comparing 1-site and 2-site phacotrabeculectomy in 40 small adult eyes with concomitant cataract and glaucoma.

  • 1-Site Approach: This involved a single incision for both phacoemulsification (cataract removal) and trabeculectomy (glaucoma surgery).
  • 2-Site Approach: This used a separate superior scleral flap for trabeculectomy and a clear corneal incision for phacoemulsification.

Key metrics evaluated included intraocular pressure (IOP), best-corrected visual acuity (BCVA), axial length (AL), anterior chamber depth (ACD), and corneal endothelial cell (CEC) density. These were measured preoperatively and at a 3-month follow-up. Statistical analysis was performed using Kruskal-Wallis and Fisher exact tests.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study utilized patient records from a single eye surgery center.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Corneal Endothelial Cell (CEC) Health is Crucial: The study highlights that the integrity of the corneal endothelium is a significant factor in post-operative outcomes, especially in eyes already predisposed to complications.
  • Minimally Invasive is Often Better: The findings suggest that minimizing surgical trauma, particularly to the cornea, can lead to better long-term visual outcomes and reduced complications.
  • Small Eyes Require Tailored Approaches: The unique anatomical features of small adult eyes necessitate careful consideration of surgical technique to avoid adverse events.

Key Results

  • Visual Acuity and IOP: Both 1-site and 2-site surgeries significantly improved BCVA and lowered IOP, with no statistically significant difference between the two groups in these aspects.
  • Axial Length and Anterior Chamber Depth: Both techniques effectively shortened axial length and deepened anterior chamber depth, with no significant difference between the groups.
  • Corneal Endothelial Cell Loss: The 2-site surgery resulted in significantly more CEC loss (20.97% loss) compared to the 1-site surgery (9.44% loss) at 3 months post-op. This difference was statistically significant (P=0.001).
  • Refractive Error: The 2-site group experienced more refractive errors and astigmatism postoperatively compared to the 1-site group.
  • Intraoperative Complications: One eye in the 1-site group required conversion to extracapsular cataract extraction due to a crowded anterior chamber. In the 2-site group, three eyes had leakage at the clear corneal incision, and two experienced corneal stroma edema at the incision site. Overall, postoperative complications were not significantly different between the groups.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Retrospective Design: The study's retrospective nature means it cannot establish causality definitively.
  • Small Sample Size: The 2-site group had a relatively small sample size (n=14), which could limit the generalizability of findings.
  • Short Follow-up Period: The 3-month follow-up is relatively short for assessing long-term outcomes, particularly CEC density stabilization.

The authors suggest that the 1-site approach may be a better option for managing patients with small eyes who have both visually significant cataracts and uncontrolled glaucoma, especially those at higher risk of endothelial damage. Future research could involve larger, prospective studies with longer follow-up periods to further validate these findings and explore other potential surgical modifications.

Summary updated

Abstract

The aim of this study was to compare the outcomes after phacotrabeculectomy at 1 or 2 sites in the small adult eyes with concomitant cataract and glaucoma.Patients who had 1-site (n = 26) or 2-site (n = 14) phacotrabeculectomy over a 4-year period at an eye surgery center were included. Eighteen eyes of 18 patients with glaucoma using any 1 prostaglandin analogue (latanoprost, travoprost, or bimatoprost) were compared with 8 normal control patients. The records of patients were reviewed, and intraocular pressure, best-corrected visual acuity, axial length, anterior chamber depth, corneal endothelial cell (CEC) density, Diopter were measured. The outcome was compared with postoperative and preoperative measurements for 3-month follow-ups.The follow-up time was 3 months. There was no difference between the operations in improving best-corrected visual acuity, lowering intraocular pressure, shortening axial length, and deepening anterior chamber depth. However, 2-site surgery was associated with significantly more CEC loss and refractive error. Postoperative complications were not different between the 2 groups.The CEC loss and the refractive error in 2-site group were higher than that of 1-site group. One-site surgery seems to cause less CEC damage and refractive error than the 2-site operation during the follow-up time of 3 months.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{xia2016comparison,
  author = {Xiaobo Xia and Ying Tian and Zhenkai Wu and Dan Wen and Weitao Song},
  title = {{Comparison of 1-Site and 2-Site Phacotrabeculectomy in the Small Adult Eyes With Concomitant Cataract and Glaucoma}},
  booktitle = {Medicine},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.1097/md.0000000000002405},
}
Figure