Abstract
Day surgery with MRI-assisted diagnosis for mixed hemorrhoids is effective, feasible, and associated with shorter hospitalization times, higher patient satisfaction, faster recovery, improved resource efficiency, and enhanced bed turnover. It is a promising model worthy of clinical adoption.
Introduction: The Clinical Challenge
Advanced hemorrhoids (grades III–IV) significantly impact quality of life, often requiring the Procedure for Prolapse and Hemorrhoids (PPH). Traditionally, this surgery necessitates a multi-day hospital stay for monitoring and pain management. However, in modern tertiary hospitals, inpatient beds are increasingly prioritized for critical oncology cases, creating a bottleneck for patients with benign anorectal conditions.
The "day surgery" (DS) model—defined as admission, operation, and discharge within 24 to 48 hours—offers a potential solution to these resource constraints. This study investigates whether a DS protocol, enhanced by preoperative MRI, can maintain surgical safety and efficacy compared to traditional non-day surgery (NDS) protocols.
Methods and the MRI Innovation
Researchers at Changhai Hospital in Shanghai conducted a retrospective cohort study involving 341 patients. The study compared 107 patients in the DS group (treated between 2021 and 2023) against 234 patients in the NDS group (treated between 2008 and 2023).
MRI-Assisted Surgical Planning
A key innovation in this study was the integration of preoperative perianal MRI. While hemorrhoids are typically diagnosed through clinical examination, MRI provides a detailed anatomical "roadmap."
This imaging allowed surgeons to:
- Assess the exact volume and distribution of hemorrhoidal tissue.
- Detect occult pathologies, such as hidden fistulas, that might complicate recovery.
- Determine if the standard PPH needed to be supplemented with additional techniques, such as the Milligan-Morgan hemorrhoidectomy, to ensure complete resection.
Key Results: Efficiency and Patient Outcomes
The study found that the day surgery model significantly optimized hospital resources without compromising clinical safety.
- Hospitalization Time: The median hospital stay was reduced from 6 days in the NDS group to just 2 days in the DS group ($p < 0.001$).
- Surgical Precision: Intraoperative blood loss was significantly lower in the DS group (10 ml vs. 20 ml, $p < 0.001$). Furthermore, the DS group experienced a lower rate of residual tissue prolapse (0.9% vs. 6.0%), likely due to the precision afforded by MRI planning.
- Recovery and Satisfaction: DS patients returned to normal activities significantly faster (20 days vs. 30 days). Overall patient satisfaction was higher in the DS group (97.2% vs. 90.6%, $p = 0.030$).
- Safety Profile: No significant differences were found between the groups regarding major complications such as anal stenosis, infection, or postoperative incontinence.
Discussion: The Compliance Gap and Recovery Dynamics
Despite the positive outcomes, the study identified a "compliance gap" in pain management. Patients in the DS group were less likely to follow regular analgesic schedules at home (50.5% compliance) compared to NDS patients whose medication was managed by hospital staff (93.2% compliance). This led to slightly higher pain scores post-discharge, suggesting that improved patient education is vital for the success of the day surgery model.
Interestingly, the faster return to normal activities in the DS group suggests that the home environment may provide psychological benefits that accelerate physical recovery, provided that post-operative monitoring remains robust.
Conclusion and Limitations
While the results are promising, the authors note that the retrospective nature of the study and the 15-year timeline discrepancy between the two cohorts may introduce bias. Improvements in anesthesia and surgical technology over the last decade likely favored the more recent DS group.
Nonetheless, the study demonstrates that day surgery for advanced hemorrhoids is a safe and highly efficient model. By utilizing MRI for precise preoperative planning, hospitals can improve bed turnover and patient satisfaction while maintaining high standards of surgical care. Future prospective, multi-center trials are recommended to further validate these findings.
Summary updated