Comparison between buttress plate and anteroposterior screw internal fixation for posterior pilon fracture: a retrospective study

Linyuan Zhang, zhiqing liu, yueting wang, Chao Yu, Jian Tang, yuehua sun, Zhen-an Zhu, Xu Chen, fengxiang liuResearch Square 2020 · DOI

Abstract

Posterior pilon fractures (PPFs) are complex ankle injuries resulting from combined vertical and rotational forces. This retrospective study compared the clinical and radiological outcomes of two common surgical interventions: buttress plate (BP) fixation and anteroposterior screw (APS) fixation. Analyzing 37 patients, the study found that BP fixation resulted in significantly better functional recovery (AOFAS scores), superior anatomical reduction, and reduced pain during exercise compared to APS fixation. Consequently, buttress plates are recommended for the internal fixation of PPFs.

Introduction

Ankle fractures involving the posterior tibial margin, known as posterior pilon fractures (PPFs), are typically caused by high-energy axial loading. These injuries often lead to significant displacement of the posterior malleolus and joint instability. Historically, surgical intervention was reserved for large fragments (over 25% of the joint surface), but modern clinical consensus suggests that even smaller fragments (10%) require stabilization to prevent post-traumatic arthritis.

Two primary surgical techniques are employed: buttress plate (BP) fixation, which provides direct posterior support, and anteroposterior screw (APS) fixation, which is less invasive but relies on indirect compression. This study evaluates which method offers superior long-term therapeutic effects.

Methods

A retrospective analysis was conducted on 37 patients treated for PPFs between January 2015 and June 2018. Patients were divided into two groups based on the fixation method:

  • BP Group (n=11): Patients underwent fixation using a buttress plate, typically requiring a prone or floating position for a posterolateral approach.
  • APS Group (n=26): Patients underwent fixation using screws inserted from anterior to posterior in a supine position.

Outcomes were assessed at a minimum 12-month follow-up using the American Orthopedic Foot and Ankle Society (AOFAS) score for function, the Visual Analog Scale (VAS) for pain, and the Burwell-Charnley system for radiological reduction quality.

Results

The study revealed several key differences between the two surgical approaches:

Functional and Pain Outcomes

The BP group demonstrated significantly higher AOFAS scores (mean 89.45) compared to the APS group (mean 83.92, p=0.002), indicating better functional recovery. While resting pain (VAS) was similar between groups, the BP group reported significantly lower pain levels during exercise (0.64 vs. 1.38, p=0.033).

Radiological Reduction

Anatomical reduction was achieved in 100% of the BP group cases. In contrast, the APS group achieved anatomical reduction in only 73% (19/26) of cases, with the remaining 27% (7/26) classified as "fair." This suggests that direct visualization and plating allow for more precise bone realignment.

Complications and Healing

Bone healing time was comparable between groups (approximately 10-11 weeks). Complications in the BP group were primarily related to the posterolateral incision (e.g., local necrosis). In the APS group, complications included chronic pain, soft tissue irritation from long screws, and local numbness.

Discussion

The superiority of buttress plates in this study can be attributed to their mechanical advantage. PPFs are subject to vertical shear stress, which tends to displace fragments upward. A buttress plate acts as a physical barrier against this displacement, whereas screws primarily provide compression and may fail to resist shear forces as effectively. The higher rate of anatomical reduction in the BP group likely contributed to the improved functional scores and reduced exercise-induced pain, as even minor joint incongruity can lead to accelerated wear and discomfort.

Conclusion

Compared to anteroposterior screws, buttress plates provide more stable fixation, better anatomical reduction, and superior functional outcomes for patients with posterior pilon fractures. Despite the more complex surgical approach, BP fixation is recommended to optimize patient recovery and minimize long-term complications.

Summary updated

Abstract

<title>Abstract</title> <bold>Background:</bold> Posterior pilon fracture (PPF) is a serious ankle injury caused by combined vertical and rotational trauma. Surgical treatment includes buttress plate (BP), anteroposterior screw (APS) and posteroanterior screw (PAS) fixation. This study aimed to compare the therapeutic effects after PPF internal fixation with BPs and APSs. <bold>Methods:</bold> From January 2015 to June 2018, 37 patients with PPFs underwent surgical treatment in our institution. The patients were divided into the BP (11 patients) and APS (26 patients) groups according to the internal fixation method. Bone healing time and postoperative complications were recorded. At the last follow-up, American Orthopedic Foot and Ankle Society (AOFAS) scores, visual analog scale (VAS) scores and Burwell-Charnley scores were used to evaluate ankle joint function, ankle joint pain, and fracture reduction on imaging, respectively. <bold>Results: </bold>No significant difference in bone healing time was found between the two groups (<italic>P </italic>&gt; 0.05). Local necrosis of the posterolateral incision and chronic ankle pain occurred in 1 case each in the BP group. Chronic ankle joint pain occurred in 4 cases in the APS group. Two cases of soft tissue irritation were caused by screws that were too long. Local numbness of the posterolateral incision occurred in 1 case. At the last follow-up, no significant difference in VAS scores between the two groups at rest (<italic>P </italic>= 0.477), but a significant difference during exercise was noted (<italic>P </italic>= 0.033). AOFAS scores were better in the BP group than those in the APS group (<italic>P </italic>= 0.002). According to the Burwell-Charnley scoring system, 11 cases were anatomically reduced in the BP group. In the APS group, anatomical reduction was achieved in 19 cases and fair in 7 cases. <bold>Conclusion:</bold> Compared with APSs, BPs resulted in better reduction, ankle joint functional recovery and complication rates. BPs are recommended for internal fixation of PPFs.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2020comparison,
  author = {Linyuan Zhang and zhiqing liu and yueting wang and Chao Yu and Jian Tang and yuehua sun and Zhen-an Zhu and Xu Chen and fengxiang liu},
  title = {{Comparison between buttress plate and anteroposterior screw internal fixation for posterior pilon fracture: a retrospective study}},
  booktitle = {Research Square},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.21203/rs.3.rs-18058/v2},
}
Figure