TL;DR
This paper compares two models for transforming urban villages in China: the market-driven Demolition/Relocation Market-Oriented Model (D/RMM) and the community-led New Rural Construction Model (NRCM). It finds that NRCM significantly outperforms D/RMM in ensuring residential sustainability for villagers, particularly in housing conditions, community environment, and livelihoods, by preserving social networks and collective economic structures.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
China's rapid urbanization has led to the widespread transformation of "urban villages" (UVs) – formerly rural settlements now surrounded by urban development. The dominant approach, D/RMM, often prioritizes market interests, leading to the displacement of original residents and the erosion of their livelihoods and social structures. This model has been criticized for negatively impacting the residential sustainability of indigenous villagers. While NRCM was initially designed for rural development, it has occasionally been adapted for UV transformation. This paper addresses the critical question of which model, D/RMM or NRCM, better safeguards the residential sustainability of villagers during this complex urban transformation process, and what mechanisms drive these differences.
Methods
The study employed a comparative case study approach, analyzing two urban villages in Lanzhou, China: Beimiantan New Village (BNV) transformed under NRCM, and Xiaoyantan Village (XV) transformed under D/RMM. Residential sustainability was evaluated across three key dimensions: housing condition sustainability, community environment sustainability, and livelihood sustainability. A mixed-methods approach was used, including:
- Field Research: Preliminary and formal investigations were conducted in the selected villages.
- Household Questionnaire Survey: A structured questionnaire was administered to villagers to gather data on their perceptions and experiences. A total of 260 questionnaires were distributed, with 240 valid responses.
- Interviews: In-depth interviews were conducted with villagers and village committee cadres to gain qualitative insights.
- Statistical Analysis: Factor analysis was used to identify the underlying structural dimensions of residential sustainability and to calculate composite scores for each village. Pearson correlation analysis was also performed.
Datasets
The study utilized data collected through field research, household surveys, and interviews in two specific urban villages in Lanzhou, China:
- Beimiantan New Village (BNV): Transformed using the New Rural Construction Model (NRCM).
- Xiaoyantan Village (XV): Transformed using the Demolition/Relocation Market-Oriented Model (D/RMM).
No pre-existing public datasets were used; the data was generated specifically for this research.
Key Insights and Ideas
- NRCM's Superiority: The study strongly suggests that NRCM is a more effective model for ensuring residential sustainability compared to D/RMM. This is not just about building new houses, but about preserving the holistic well-being of villagers.
- The Power of Social Networks: The preservation of existing social relationship networks (strong ties) is a critical factor in NRCM's success. These networks provide informal support, reduce transaction costs, and foster a sense of community that D/RMM often dismantles.
- Collective Economy as a Buffer: NRCM's ability to maintain and activate the collective economy provides a vital safety net for villagers, offering employment opportunities and income diversification that are often lost under D/RMM.
- Land Rights Matter: The way land development rights are allocated and how earnings are redistributed fundamentally impacts housing conditions. NRCM's approach, which keeps land collectively owned and allows for self-building, leads to better housing outcomes than D/RMM's developer-led model.
- Beyond Economic Rationality: NRCM demonstrates that successful transformation can move beyond pure market-driven logic by incorporating "non-market folk society forces" and prioritizing community interests.
Key Results
- Housing Conditions: BNV (NRCM) showed significantly higher scores in Housing Ownership Index (HOI), Housing Privacy Index (HPI), Housing Quality Index (HQI), and Housing Facilities Index (HFI) compared to XV (D/RMM). XV had a higher Housing Crowding Index (HCI).
- Income: 93% of BNV villagers reported increased income post-transformation, primarily from house rentals and village collective dividends. In contrast, only 28% of XV villagers reported income increases, with more singular income sources.
- Community Environment & Livelihoods: Overall, BNV scored higher in community environment and livelihood sustainability, largely due to stronger social relationship networks and economic status.
- Factor Analysis: The study identified key factors influencing residential sustainability. For BNV, social relationship factors (F2) and economic status (F1) were most significant. For XV, economic status (F1), community environment (F3), and social guarantee (F5) were most impactful, but with lower overall scores.
Limitations and Future Work
- Limited Scope: The study focused on only two urban villages, which may limit the universal applicability of the findings. Future research should consider a wider range of UVs.
- Villager-Centric Focus: The research primarily examined the sustainability from the perspective of indigenous villagers. Future work should also investigate the experiences of floating urban laborers and tenants.
- Future Directions: The authors suggest that future UV transformation should explore land development right allocation models that involve government, village collectives, and villagers simultaneously. They also advocate for policies that support the economic transformation of community joint-stock companies and establish special investment and financing platforms to reduce risks for village collectives. Socially, promoting community self-governance and allowing village collectives to develop remaining land are recommended.
Summary updated