Comparing Relative Bond Characteristics Between Spherical and Elongated Morphologies for Cold Spray Process Using SPH Simulation

Wesley Kean Wah Tai, R. Chakrabarty, Samuel Pinches, Xiaodong Huang, Jeffrey H. Lang, Jun Song, Andrew Siao Ming AngJournal of Thermal Spray Technology 2022 · DOI

Abstract

Under cold spray conditions, the modified Johnson–Cook model was adopted to perform single and multiple particle simulation for spherical and elongated aluminum alloy- Al-6061 feedstock particles. The splat formations were realistically presented; the temperature evolution throughout the deposition process stayed below the melting point of Al-6061, and the feedstock particles exhibited restitution for impact velocities lower than 200 m/s. Feedstock particles with elongated morphology experienced a lower elastic strain energy level than spherical morphology after impact, which implied the relative bond strength was higher for elongated particles than spherical particles. The displacement curves in single particle simulations for both morphologies suggested a spherical particle experienced a greater shock than the elongated particle upon impact. The relative bond strength achieved by multiple particle impact was lower than the single particle impact, even though the displacement curves showed the feedstock particles were individually embedded in the substrate.

Introduction

Cold spray is a solid-state additive manufacturing technique where metal powders are propelled at supersonic speeds (Mach 1–4) to bond with a substrate upon impact. By avoiding melting, it circumvents thermal defects typical of traditional 3D printing. However, industrial feedstock often deviates from the ideal spherical shapes assumed in most predictive models. This study addresses the knowledge gap regarding how non-spherical morphologies affect "relative bond strength"—the likelihood of a particle adhering to the substrate rather than rebounding.

Methodology

The researchers utilized Smoothed Particle Hydrodynamics (SPH), a meshless Lagrangian method well-suited for the extreme plastic deformation and high strain rates ($10^9 s^{-1}$) characteristic of cold spray impacts. Unlike traditional Finite Element Analysis (FEA), SPH handles these conditions without numerical errors from mesh tangling.

Material Modeling

A Modified Johnson–Cook (JC) Model was implemented to accurately represent the Al-6061 aluminum alloy. Unlike standard models, this version accounts for viscous regimes and power-law hardening, which are critical at high impact velocities. The simulation framework was validated against established literature for copper-on-copper impacts.

Morphology and Simulation

Spherical particles were modeled at 80 μm. Elongated particles were parametrically designed in OpenSCAD using Bezier functions to maintain a consistent maximum diameter, ensuring a fair comparison of shape effects.

Spherical and elongated Al-6061 feedstock particle models used in SPH simulations.

Simulations were conducted for both single and multiple (5) particle impacts at velocities ranging from 200 to 800 m/s.

Results and Discussion

The "Spring-Back" Effect and Shape Superiority

The study used recoverable elastic strain energy as a proxy for bond strength. High post-impact elastic energy acts as a "compressed spring," promoting particle separation. Elongated particles exhibited lower elastic strain energy levels than spherical ones, suggesting they are less prone to rebounding and form more stable bonds. Displacement curves further indicated that spherical particles experience a sharper "impact shock," whereas elongated particles deform more gradually.

Impact of Particle Crowding

In multiple-particle simulations, the relative bond strength was found to be lower than in single-particle impacts. This suggests that the interaction between neighboring "splats" during simultaneous deposition interferes with individual bonding efficiency, a phenomenon known as crowding, even when particles appear individually embedded.

Model Accuracy and Thermal Behavior

The modified JC model demonstrated a 44.2% increase in maximum von Mises stress compared to standard models, which tend to underestimate high-speed impact physics. The modified model predicted a realistic flattening ratio of 1.69, whereas the standard model over-predicted it at 2.53. Furthermore, simulations confirmed that maximum temperatures remained below the Al-6061 melting point (502°C), validating the solid-state nature of the process. A critical velocity threshold of 200 m/s was identified, below which particles exhibited restitution rather than embedding.

Conclusion

This research highlights that elongated aluminum particles may offer superior bonding characteristics in cold spray processes compared to traditional spherical ones due to reduced impact shock and lower recoverable elastic energy. While these benefits are slightly mitigated in multi-particle scenarios, the findings suggest significant potential for optimizing feedstock morphology. Future work will aim to integrate Cohesive Zone Models (CZM) to explicitly simulate atomic-level bonding and explore more complex, irregular industrial powder shapes.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Under cold spray conditions, the modified Johnson–Cook model was adopted to perform single and multiple particle simulation for spherical and elongated aluminum alloy- Al-6061 feedstock particles. The splat formations were realistically presented; the temperature evolution throughout the deposition process stayed below the melting point of Al-6061, and the feedstock particles exhibited restitution for impact velocities lower than 200 m/s. Feedstock particles with elongated morphology experienced a lower elastic strain energy level than spherical morphology after impact, which implied the relative bond strength was higher for elongated particles than spherical particles. The displacement curves in single particle simulations for both morphologies suggested a spherical particle experienced a greater shock than the elongated particle upon impact. The relative bond strength achieved by multiple particle impact was lower than the single particle impact, even though the displacement curves showed the feedstock particles were individually embedded in the substrate.
BibTeX
@article{tai2022comparing,
  author = {Wesley Kean Wah Tai and R. Chakrabarty and Samuel Pinches and Xiaodong Huang and Jeffrey H. Lang and Jun Song and Andrew Siao Ming Ang},
  title = {{Comparing Relative Bond Characteristics Between Spherical and Elongated Morphologies for Cold Spray Process Using SPH Simulation}},
  journal = {Journal of Thermal Spray Technology},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1007/s11666-022-01448-3},
}
Figure