Comparing national greenhouse gas budgets reported in UNFCCC inventories against atmospheric inversions

Zhu Deng, Philippe Ciais, Zitely A. Tzompa‐Sosa, Marielle Saunois, Chunjing Qiu, Chang Tan, Taochun Sun, Piyu Ke, Yanan Cui, Katsumasa Tanaka, Xin Lin, Rona L. Thompson, Hanqin Tian, Yuanzhi Yao, Yuanyuan Huang, Ronny Lauerwald, Atul K. Jain, Xiaoming Xu, Ana Bastos, Stephen Sitch, Paul I. Palmer, Thomas Lauvaux, Alexandre d’Aspremont, Clément Giron, Antoine Benoit, Benjamin Poulter, Jinfeng Chang, Ana Maria Roxana Petrescu, Steven J. Davis, Zhu Liu, Giacomo Grassi, Clément Albergel, Frédéric Chevallier2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents a novel framework for comparing national greenhouse gas (GHG) inventories with atmospheric inversion models for CO2, CH4, and N2O. By harmonizing data and accounting for previously excluded fluxes, the study reveals discrepancies between reported inventories and top-down estimates, highlighting potential underestimations in national reports, particularly for CH4 and N2O.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Accurate national greenhouse gas (GHG) inventories are crucial for tracking progress towards climate goals like those set by the Paris Agreement. However, these "bottom-up" inventories, compiled from national statistics, can have significant uncertainties and may not fully capture all emission sources or sinks. Atmospheric "top-down" inversion models, which use atmospheric concentration measurements to infer emissions, offer an independent check. The challenge lies in making these two approaches directly comparable, as they often use different definitions, spatial resolutions, and accounting rules. This paper addresses the need for a robust methodology to reconcile these differences and provide a more accurate assessment of national GHG budgets, particularly for CO2, CH4, and N2O.

Methods

The authors developed a comprehensive framework to make atmospheric inversion results comparable to national inventories. Key methodological advances include:

  • CO2:
    • Separating CO2 fluxes from inversions over managed lands to align with inventory definitions.
  • Adjusting inversion results by subtracting CO2 fluxes not accounted for in inventories, such as those from lateral transport (rivers, crop/wood trade).
  • Masking out fluxes from unmanaged forests to focus on managed land emissions.
  • CH4:
    • Processing inversions to separate natural and anthropogenic CH4 emissions, as inventories typically only report anthropogenic sources.
  • Developing four different methods to partition anthropogenic emissions, accounting for various source categories (fossil, agriculture & waste, biomass burning).
  • N2O:
    • Similar to CH4, separating anthropogenic emissions by removing natural sources.
  • Accounting for indirect N2O emissions (from atmospheric deposition and river leaching) that are often not reported in national inventories, especially for non-Annex I countries.

The study utilizes an ensemble of global inversion models and a harmonized database of national inventories.

Datasets

  • Atmospheric Inversions: Ensemble of global inversions from the Global Carbon Project for CO2, CH4, and N2O. Specific models include CarbonTracker-Europe, Jena Carboscope, CAMS, University of Edinburgh, MIROC, NISMON-CO2 (for CO2); CarbonTracker-Europe CH4, GELCA, LMDZ-PYVAR, MIROC4-ACTM, NICAM-TM, NIES-TM-FLEXPART, TM5-CAMS, TM5-JRC (for CH4); GEOS-Chem, PyVAR-CAMS, INVICAT (for N2O).
  • National Inventories: Periodical UNFCCC inventories from Annex I countries (NIRs and CRF tables) and sporadic/less detailed reports from non-Annex I countries (National Communications and Biennial Update Reports).
  • Ancillary Data: Intact Forest Landscapes maps (Potapov et al., 2017), FAOSTAT data for crop trade, GFEDv4 dataset for wildfire emissions, EDGARv4.3.2 inventory, DLEM model simulations, NMIP model ensemble, PRIMAP-HIST dataset.
  • Newly Introduced Data: A new global harmonized database of national emissions and removals from UNFCCC inventories, compiled from various reports.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Inversions as a Crucial Complement: The study strongly advocates for the use of atmospheric inversions as an independent and complementary tool to national inventories, especially for evaluating climate mitigation policies.
  • Systematic Underestimation in Inventories: A recurring theme is the tendency for national inventories to underestimate emissions, particularly for CH4 and N2O, and potentially for CO2 sinks in certain regions. This suggests a need for improved reporting and methodologies.
  • Importance of Unaccounted Fluxes: Lateral carbon transport (rivers, trade) and natural emissions (unmanaged lands, wetlands) play a significant role and must be accounted for to achieve a fair comparison between inversions and inventories.
  • Ultra-emitters and Fossil Fuel CH4: The study highlights the potential impact of "ultra-emitters" (large, sporadic leaks from oil and gas facilities) on CH4 emissions, which are often not captured by traditional inventory methods.
  • Tropical N2O Challenges: Natural N2O emissions from tropical regions are substantial and can be overlooked, creating a disconnect between targeted emission reductions and observed atmospheric trends.

Key Results

  • CO2: Inversions generally indicate a larger terrestrial carbon sink than inventories over temperate countries (e.g., Russia, Canada, EU), even after accounting for lateral fluxes and unmanaged lands.
  • CH4:
    • Good consistency is found between in-situ and satellite-based inversions.
  • Inversions tend to diagnose higher CH4 emissions than reported by inventories, especially in oil and gas-producing regions (Central Asia, Persian Gulf).
  • Ultra-emitters can significantly contribute to fossil fuel CH4 emissions, explaining some of the discrepancies.
  • N2O: Inversions often produce higher anthropogenic N2O emissions than inventories for tropical countries, potentially due to underestimation of natural sources and indirect emissions in national reports.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Spatial Resolution: Global inversions still operate at a relatively coarse spatial resolution, limiting their ability to constrain emissions from smaller countries or highly localized sources. Future work should focus on increasing resolution.
  • Unmanaged Lands: The masking of unmanaged forests was an attempt to align with inventory definitions, but the precise definition and extent of "managed" vs. "unmanaged" lands remain a source of uncertainty. Extending this masking to unmanaged grasslands is suggested.
  • Natural Emission Estimates: The accuracy of separating natural from anthropogenic emissions relies on robust bottom-up estimates of natural sources (wetlands, rivers, lakes), which themselves have uncertainties. Improving these datasets is crucial.
  • Data Availability for Non-Annex I Countries: The reporting of GHG inventories by non-Annex I countries is less detailed and sporadic, making direct comparisons more challenging.
  • Future Work: The authors recommend developing regional campaigns, refining emission factors, utilizing new tools for tracking ultra-emitters, and improving reporting of indirect N2O emissions and natural sources. They also emphasize the need for countries to report managed land spatially explicitly and to use atmospheric data as an independent check on national reports.

Summary updated

Abstract

In support of the Global Stocktake of the Paris Agreement on Climate change, this study presents a comprehensive framework to process the results of atmospheric inversions in order to make them suitable for evaluating UNFCCC national inventories of land-use carbon dioxide (CO2) emissions and removals, corresponding to the Land Use, Land Use Change and Forestry and waste sectors. We also deduced anthropogenic methane (CH4) emissions regrouped into fossil and agriculture and waste emissions, and anthropogenic nitrous oxide (N2O) emissions from inversions. To compare inversions with national reports, we compiled a new global harmonized database of national emissions and removals from periodical UNFCCC inventories by Annex I countries, and from sporadic and less detailed emissions reports by Non-Annex I countries, given by National Communications and Biennial Update Reports. The method to reconcile inversions with inventories is applied to selected large countries covering 78 % of the global land carbon uptake for CO2, as well as emissions and removals in the land use, land use change and forestry sector, and top-emitters of CH4 and N2O. Our method uses results from an ensemble of global inversions produced by the Global Carbon Project for the three greenhouse gases, with ancillary data. We examine the role of CO2 fluxes caused by lateral transfer processes from rivers and from trade in crop and wood products, and the role of carbon uptake in unmanaged lands, both not accounted for by the rules of inventories. Here we show that, despite a large spread across the inversions, the median of available inversion models points to a larger terrestrial carbon sink than inventories over temperate countries or groups of countries of the Northern Hemisphere like Russia, Canada and the European Union. For CH4, we find good consistency between the inversions assimilating only data from the global in-situ network and those using satellite CH4 retrievals, and a tendency for inversions to diagnose higher CH4 emissions estimates than reported by inventories. In particular, oil and gas extracting countries in Central Asia and the Persian Gulf region tend to systematically report lower emissions compared to those estimated by inversions. For N2O, inversions tend to produce higher anthropogenic emissions than inventories for tropical countries, even when attempting to consider only managed land emissions. In the inventories of many non-Annex I countries, this can be tentatively attributed to either a lack of reporting indirect N2O emissions from atmospheric deposition and from leaching to rivers, or to the existence of natural sources intertwined with managed lands, or to an under-estimation of N2O emission factors for direct agricultural soil emissions. The advantage of inversions is that they provide insights on seasonal and interannual greenhouse gas fluxes anomalies, e.g. during extreme events such as drought or abnormal fire episodes, whereas inventory methods are established to estimate trends and multi-annual changes. As a much denser sampling of atmospheric CO2 and CH4 concentrations by different satellites coordinated into a global constellation is expected in the coming years, the methodology proposed here to compare inversion results with inventory reports could be applied regularly for monitoring the effectiveness of mitigation policy and progress by countries to meet the objective of their pledges.
BibTeX
@misc{deng2021comparing,
  author = {Zhu Deng and Philippe Ciais and Zitely A. Tzompa‐Sosa and Marielle Saunois and Chunjing Qiu and Chang Tan and Taochun Sun and Piyu Ke and Yanan Cui and Katsumasa Tanaka and Xin Lin and Rona L. Thompson and Hanqin Tian and Yuanzhi Yao and Yuanyuan Huang and Ronny Lauerwald and Atul K. Jain and Xiaoming Xu and Ana Bastos and Stephen Sitch and Paul I. Palmer and Thomas Lauvaux and Alexandre d’Aspremont and Clément Giron and Antoine Benoit and Benjamin Poulter and Jinfeng Chang and Ana Maria Roxana Petrescu and Steven J. Davis and Zhu Liu and Giacomo Grassi and Clément Albergel and Frédéric Chevallier},
  title = {{Comparing national greenhouse gas budgets reported in UNFCCC inventories against atmospheric inversions}},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.5194/essd-2021-235},
}
Figure