Comparing fMRI responses measured at 3 versus 7 Tesla across human cortex, striatum, and brainstem

Olympia Colizoli, Jan Willem de Gee, Wietske van der Zwaag, Tobias H. DonnerbioRxiv 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This study directly compares 3T and 7T fMRI for their ability to detect brain activity, finding that 7T fMRI offers a significant advantage for imaging small, deep brain structures like the brainstem, which are crucial for decision-making and reward processing. This work highlights the potential of ultra-high field fMRI for advancing our understanding of complex cognitive functions.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Functional Magnetic Resonance Imaging (fMRI) is a powerful tool for studying brain activity, but its sensitivity can be limited, especially for small or deep brain structures. While higher magnetic field strengths (like 7 Tesla, or 7T) promise increased sensitivity compared to standard strengths (like 3 Tesla, or 3T), it's not always clear which applications benefit the most. Specifically, the brainstem, a region critical for neuromodulatory systems involved in cognition and behavior, contains numerous small nuclei that are notoriously difficult to image with 3T fMRI due to their size and susceptibility to signal distortions. This paper aims to systematically compare the performance of 7T and 3T fMRI in detecting task-evoked responses across different brain regions, with a particular focus on the brainstem, to determine where the benefits of ultra-high field fMRI are most pronounced.

Methods

The researchers conducted a within-subject, head-to-head comparison of 3T and 7T fMRI data acquired from the same participants. Participants performed a challenging random dot motion discrimination task with delayed monetary feedback. This task was designed to engage various brain regions, including visual cortex, striatum, and brainstem nuclei.

Key methodological aspects include:

  • Task Design: A two-alternative forced choice (2AFC) random dot motion discrimination task with two difficulty levels (hard and easy) and monetary feedback. This task is well-characterized and known to involve the brain regions of interest.
  • fMRI Acquisition: Near-whole brain coverage was acquired at both 3T and 7T. While imaging parameters were optimized for each field strength, the researchers ensured comparability where possible. Notably, the voxel size was smaller at 7T to potentially improve spatial resolution in challenging areas.
  • Data Analysis:
    • Task-Evoked Responses: General Linear Models (GLMs) were used to quantify BOLD responses during the decision interval (stimulus onset) and the post-feedback interval.
  • Temporal Signal-to-Noise Ratio (tSNR): This metric, a proxy for image quality and signal stability, was computed to assess overall signal reliability.
  • Region of Interest (ROI) Analysis: Specific ROIs were defined a priori based on their known involvement in the task, including cortical areas (V1, V3AB, MT+, IPS01, ACC), striatum (caudate, putamen, NAc), and brainstem nuclei (LC, SN, VTA). These ROIs were grouped for analysis.
  • Statistical Comparisons: Repeated-measures ANOVAs and non-parametric permutation tests were used to compare responses and tSNR between field strengths and across ROI groups. Whole-brain analyses were also conducted.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study utilized data collected from human participants during the experiment.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Brainstem Benefit: The most striking finding is that 7T fMRI provides a significantly greater benefit for detecting task-evoked responses in the brainstem nuclei compared to 3T fMRI. This is crucial because these small nuclei play vital roles in cognition and behavior.
  • Differential Responses in Brainstem: Specifically, evoked differential responses (e.g., between hard and easy decisions) in dopaminergic brainstem nuclei (VTA and SN) were stronger at 7T, aligning with theories of reward expectation and confidence coding.
  • Varied Benefits Across Regions: While the brainstem showed the most pronounced improvement with 7T, the benefits were less substantial for cortical regions and the striatum, suggesting that the advantages of higher field strength are application-specific.
  • tSNR Similarities: Despite the differences in evoked responses, the temporal signal-to-noise ratio (tSNR) was comparable between 3T and 7T across most regions, including the brainstem. This indicates that while signal stability might be similar, the ability to detect subtle task-related signal changes is enhanced at 7T, particularly in challenging areas.
  • Potential for Small Structure Imaging: The results underscore the potential of 7T fMRI to unlock new insights into the function of small, deep brain structures that have been difficult to study with conventional fMRI.

Key Results

  • Evoked Responses: A significant interaction between ROI group and field strength was observed for the overall response during the decision interval, with the largest improvement at 7T seen in brainstem nuclei.
  • Brainstem Nuclei: Evoked differential responses in the VTA and SN during the decision interval were significantly stronger at 7T than at 3T (p < .05).
  • Cortical and Striatal Regions: No significant differences in task-evoked responses were found between 3T and 7T for cortical regions and the striatum.
  • Whole Brain: No significant differences between field strengths for task-evoked responses were obtained at the whole-brain level.
  • tSNR: At the ROI level, a significant interaction between ROI group and field strength was found for tSNR, with higher tSNR in the brainstem ROI group at 7T compared to 3T. However, at the whole-brain level, no significant differences in tSNR were observed.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Imaging Parameter Differences: The authors acknowledge that imaging parameters (e.g., voxel size, echo time) differed between the 3T and 7T acquisitions. While they argue these differences are unlikely to have biased the core findings, it's a point to consider.
  • tSNR and BOLD Relationship: The relationship between tSNR and BOLD sensitivity is complex and non-linear, so while tSNR is a useful metric, it doesn't directly equate to BOLD signal detectability. The study focused on evoked response amplitude as the primary measure of benefit.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that the progressive establishment of 7T fMRI will lead to a surge of studies illuminating the role of the brainstem in cognition. This could deepen our understanding of healthy cognition and advance the mechanistic understanding of psychiatric disorders. Further research could explore how to optimize acquisition parameters for specific brain regions and investigate the dynamic interaction between brainstem nuclei and cortical regions.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Significant progress has been made in ultra-high field functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) at 7 Tesla (T). While fMRI at 7 T promises a general increase in sensitivity compared to lower field strengths, the benefits may be most pronounced for specific applications. The current study aimed to evaluate the relative benefit of 7 T over 3 T fMRI for the assessment of task-evoked fMRI responses in different brain regions. We compared the amplitude of task-evoked responses between 3 T and 7 T measured from the same human participants. Participants performed a challenging random dot motion discrimination task with delayed monetary feedback, which animal physiology has linked to several cortical and subcortical structures including extrastriate (dorsal) visual cortical areas, the striatum, and the brainstem including dopaminergic midbrain nuclei. We quantified the evoked fMRI responses in each of these brain regions during the decision interval and the post-feedback interval of the task, and compared them between brain regions and field strengths. The dependence of response amplitudes on field strength during the decision interval differed between cortical, striatal, and brainstem regions, with a generally bigger 7 T vs. 3 T benefit in subcortical (in particular brainstem) structures. We also found stronger differential responses during easy than hard decisions at 7 T for the dopaminergic nuclei, possibly reflecting reward expectation. Our results demonstrate the potential of 7 T fMRI for illuminating the contribution of small brainstem nuclei to the orchestration of cognitive computations in the human brain. Highlights We compared 7 T to 3 T fMRI during perceptual decision-making under uncertainty. Differences between 7 T and 3 T evoked responses and tSNR varied across the brain. Evoked responses in dopaminergic brainstem nuclei were bigger at 7 T than 3 T. The responses of dopaminergic nuclei are consistent with reward expectation. Results highlight the potential of 7 T fMRI for imaging small brainstem nuclei.
BibTeX
@misc{colizoli2020comparing,
  author = {Olympia Colizoli and Jan Willem de Gee and Wietske van der Zwaag and Tobias H. Donner},
  title = {{Comparing fMRI responses measured at 3 versus 7 Tesla across human cortex, striatum, and brainstem}},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1101/2020.05.12.090175},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure