Comparing Aerial-RIS- and Aerial-Base-Station-Aided Post-Disaster Cellular Networks

Maurilio Matracia, Mustafa A. Kishk, Mohamed‐Slim AlouiniIEEE Open Journal of Vehicular Technology 2023 · DOI

This paper provides a rigorous mathematical comparison between two leading technologies for restoring cellular connectivity after a disaster: mounting a full Base Station on a drone (ABS) versus mounting a "smart mirror" or Reconfigurable Intelligent Surface (ARIS). Using stochastic geometry, the authors demonstrate that while both help, the ARIS approach generally offers superior coverage because it enhances existing signals without introducing the additional interference that an active aerial base station does.

TL;DR

When disaster strikes and cell towers fail, should we deploy drones carrying base stations or smart reflective surfaces? This study uses stochastic geometry to prove that Aerial Reconfigurable Intelligent Surfaces (ARIS) typically outperform Aerial Base Stations (ABS) by providing cleaner, interference-free coverage, though their success depends heavily on altitude and urbanization.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Natural and man-made disasters often cripple terrestrial telecommunications infrastructure exactly when first responders and victims need it most. Unmanned Aerial Vehicles (UAVs) are the go-to solution for rapid deployment, but there is a debate on the best payload.

An Aerial Base Station (ABS) acts as a new cell tower in the sky, but it requires a power-hungry backhaul link and can create significant interference for users outside the immediate disaster zone. A Reconfigurable Intelligent Surface (ARIS), on the other hand, is a "passive" payload that reflects and beamforms signals from surviving ground towers toward users. Until now, the literature lacked a unified analytical framework to compare these two fairly while accounting for the random, "Swiss cheese" pattern of surviving ground infrastructure.

Methods

The authors employ Stochastic Geometry, a powerful mathematical tool for modeling random spatial networks.

  • Modeling the Disaster: They model surviving Terrestrial Base Stations (TBSs) as an inhomogeneous Poisson Point Process (IPPP). This captures the reality that base stations are more likely to be destroyed near the epicenter of a disaster.
  • Channel Realism: Unlike simpler models, this framework incorporates Nakagami-m fading (which accounts for varying degrees of signal scattering) and S-curve LoS probability (which models how buildings block signals based on the environment's urbanization level).
  • Association Policy: They assume a "maximum-average-received-power" rule, where a user connects to whichever source—ground tower, ABS, or ARIS—provides the strongest average signal.
  • Verification: The complex analytical expressions for coverage probability were verified using Monte Carlo simulations with 50,000 iterations.

Datasets

This is a theoretical and simulation-based paper, so it does not use a static external dataset. Instead, it utilizes standardized environmental parameters for four scenarios: Suburban, Urban, Dense Urban, and High-rise Urban. These parameters (S-curve variables, tower heights, and densities) are based on established ITU and 3GPP-like models for wireless propagation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Interference Paradox: The ABS is its own worst enemy at high altitudes. Because it is an active transmitter, if it flies too high, it starts interfering with users far beyond the disaster zone. The ARIS is "interference-neutral" because it only reflects existing signals toward a specific target.
  • Altitude Sensitivity: For an ARIS, higher is almost always better because it gains a clearer Line-of-Sight (LoS) to more surviving ground towers. For an ABS, there is a "Goldilocks" altitude; too low and its range is tiny, too high and it causes too much interference.
  • Urbanization as a Bottleneck: In high-rise environments, the benefit of any UAV-aided solution drops significantly. The "canyon effect" of tall buildings makes it nearly impossible to maintain LoS links unless the UAV is extremely high and the RIS has a massive number of elements.
  • The Power of Reflection: Even with a modest power budget (1W), an ARIS with ~1100 elements can significantly outperform a traditional ABS in terms of the area it can successfully cover.

Key Results

  • ARIS Dominance: In almost all tested scenarios (suburban to dense urban), the ARIS-aided architecture provided a higher coverage probability than the ABS-aided one.
  • Epicenter Recovery: Without UAV aid, coverage at the disaster epicenter is at its lowest. Deploying an ARIS or ABS shifts the "minimum coverage point" away from the epicenter, effectively filling the "coverage hole."
  • Quantitative Gains: In suburban environments, an ARIS can maintain nearly 90% coverage probability even as power consumption is minimized, whereas an ABS struggles to break 80% due to the interference it generates.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Single vs. Multiple UAVs: The current model focuses on a single UAV hovering over the epicenter. Real-world deployments might use a swarm (modeled as a Binomial Point Process), which would introduce complex inter-UAV interference.
  • Perfect Phase Shifting: The study assumes the RIS can perfectly estimate the channel and shift phases to reflect the signal. In reality, hardware impairments and estimation errors would degrade performance.
  • Flight Dynamics: The paper focuses on communication performance but does not account for the energy required for the UAV to stay aloft, which is significantly higher than the communication payload's power draw.
  • Future Metric: The authors suggest investigating the SIR meta-distribution in future work to understand the "reliability" of the link (i.e., what percentage of users achieve a specific target rate) rather than just the average coverage.

Summary updated

Abstract

Reconfigurable intelligent surface (RIS) technology and its integration into existing wireless networks have recently attracted much interest. While an important use case of said technology consists in mounting RISs onto unmanned aerial vehicles (UAVs) to support the terrestrial infrastructure in post-disaster scenarios, the current literature lacks an analytical framework that captures the networks' topological aspects. Therefore, our study borrows stochastic geometry tools to estimate both the average and local coverage probability of a wireless network aided by an aerial RIS (ARIS); in particular, the surviving terrestrial base stations (TBSs) are modeled by means of an inhomogeneous Poisson point process, while the UAV is assumed to hover above the disaster epicenter. Our framework captures important aspects such as the TBSs' altitude, the fact that they may be in either line-of-sight or non-line-of-sight condition with a given node, and the Nakagami- <italic xmlns:mml="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink">m</i> fading conditions of wireless links. By leveraging said aspects we accurately evaluate three possible scenarios, where TBSs are either: <italic xmlns:mml="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink">(i)</i> not aided, <italic xmlns:mml="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink">(ii)</i> aided by an ARIS, or <italic xmlns:mml="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink">(iii)</i> aided by an aerial base station (ABS). Our selected numerical results reflect various situations, depending on parameters such as the environment's urbanization level, disaster radius, and the UAV's altitude.
BibTeX
@article{matracia2023comparing,
  author = {Maurilio Matracia and Mustafa A. Kishk and Mohamed‐Slim Alouini},
  title = {{Comparing Aerial-RIS- and Aerial-Base-Station-Aided Post-Disaster Cellular Networks}},
  journal = {IEEE Open Journal of Vehicular Technology},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1109/ojvt.2023.3316117},
}
Figure