Comparative Whole-Genomic Analysis of an Ancient L2 Lineage Mycobacterium tuberculosis Reveals a Novel Phylogenetic Clade and Common Genetic Determinants of Hypervirulent Strains

Rahim Rajwani, Wing Cheong Yam, Ying Zhang, Yu Kang, Barry Kin Chung Wong, Kenneth Siu Sing Leung, Kingsley King Gee Tam, Ketema Tafess, Li Zhu, G. G. SiuFrontiers in Cellular and Infection Microbiology 2018 · DOI

TL;DR

This study identifies a novel phylogenetic clade of hypervirulent Mycobacterium tuberculosis strains, revealing common genetic determinants that likely contribute to their increased virulence. By comparing the whole genomes of a hypervirulent strain (H112) with a less virulent strain from the same lineage, researchers pinpointed specific mutations and structural variations associated with hypervirulence, offering new targets for understanding and combating severe tuberculosis.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Tuberculosis (TB) remains a major global health challenge, exacerbated by the emergence of drug-resistant strains. Developing effective treatments and vaccines is hampered by our incomplete understanding of how genetic variations within Mycobacterium tuberculosis (Mtb) influence disease severity and virulence. Previous work identified a hypervirulent Mtb strain, H112, which caused aggressive disease and exhibited enhanced survival within human macrophages. This study aims to identify the specific genetic factors responsible for this hypervirulence, particularly those shared among other hypervirulent strains from the same evolutionary lineage.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach:

  • Whole-Genome Sequencing (WGS): They performed PacBio sequencing on two Mtb strains: the hypervirulent H112 and a less virulent strain, H54, from the same L2 lineage. This technology provides long, contiguous reads, enabling high-quality genome assembly.
  • Comparative Genomics: They compared the genomes of H112 and H54 to identify single-nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) and structural variations (SVs) unique to H112. To isolate lineage-specific variations, they focused on differences after accounting for shared lineage-related mutations.
  • Extensive Phylogenetic Analysis: They integrated their data with a large dataset of publicly available Mtb genomes (over 4,300) to construct a comprehensive phylogenetic tree. This allowed them to identify novel clades and pinpoint strains that shared the identified hypervirulence-associated genetic markers.
  • Bioinformatic Prediction: They used tools like SIFT to predict the functional impact of non-synonymous SNPs on protein function.

Datasets

  • Primary Strains: Mycobacterium tuberculosis strains H112 (hypervirulent) and H54 (low-virulence), both belonging to the L2 lineage.
  • Publicly Available Genomes: Over 4,300 M. tuberculosis whole-genome sequences from NCBI GenBank and other studies, representing various lineages and geographical locations.
  • Reference Strains: M. tuberculosis H37Rv (virulent) and H37Ra (avirulent) were used for control experiments.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • A Novel Hypervirulent Clade: The study identified a previously unrecognized phylogenetic clade within the ancient L2 lineage that specifically clusters hypervirulent Mtb strains. This suggests that hypervirulence is not randomly distributed but can be associated with specific evolutionary branches.
  • Distinguishing Lineage vs. Hypervirulence Mutations: A crucial aspect of their methodology was to first account for genetic variations common to the L2 lineage before identifying mutations specific to hypervirulent strains. This rigorous approach helps to avoid misattributing lineage-level variations to hypervirulence.
  • Key Genetic Determinants: The research pinpointed a small set of 12 SNPs and 5 SVs that are consistently found in hypervirulent strains within this novel clade. These are strong candidates for driving hypervirulence.
  • Functional Significance of Mutations: One particularly interesting finding is a deleterious SNP (rv0178 p. D150E) within the mce1 operon, which is known to be involved in Mtb virulence. Another significant finding is an intergenic deletion near the phoP operon, which plays a critical role in Mtb pathogenesis.

Key Results

  • Phylogenetic Clustering: The analysis revealed a novel phylogenetic clade containing four hypervirulent strains, including H112, isolated from diverse geographical regions.
  • Shared Genetic Markers: All hypervirulent strains within this clade shared 12 specific SNPs and 5 structural variations (SVs) with H112.
  • Deleterious SNP: A SNP in rv0178 (p. D150E) within the mce1 operon was identified and predicted to be deleterious, potentially impacting Mtb virulence.
  • Intergenic Deletion: A 2 bp deletion in the intergenic region between rv0759c and rv0760c, located near the phoP operon, was found in all members of the H112-clade.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Experimental Validation: The authors acknowledge that the causative role of the identified mutations in mycobacterial virulence needs to be experimentally validated. They suggest future work involving genetic manipulation (e.g., introducing mutations into wild-type strains or compensating for them) and testing in cell culture and animal models.
  • Limited Sample Size for Initial Comparison: While the study compared H112 to H54, the initial identification of hypervirulent strains was based on a single strain (H112) and its comparison to other clinical isolates. However, the subsequent analysis with a larger global dataset mitigates this limitation.
  • Incomplete Phenotypic Data: The virulence of some strains within the identified clades was not fully characterized, limiting the scope of direct phenotypic correlation for all members.
  • Animal Models: The study primarily used human macrophage models for virulence assessment. The authors suggest that future work should include animal models of Mtb infection for a more comprehensive understanding.

Summary updated

Abstract

<b>Background:</b> Development of improved therapeutics against tuberculosis (TB) is hindered by an inadequate understanding of the relationship between disease severity and genetic diversity of its causative agent, <i>Mycobacterium tuberculosis</i>. We previously isolated a hypervirulent <i>M. tuberculosis</i> strain H112 from an HIV-negative patient with an aggressive disease progression from pulmonary TB to tuberculous meningitis-the most severe manifestation of tuberculosis. Human macrophage challenge experiment demonstrated that the strain H112 exhibited significantly better intracellular survivability and induced lower level of TNF-α than the reference virulent strain <i>H37Rv</i> and other 123 clinical isolates. <b>Aim:</b> The present study aimed to identify the potential genetic determinants of mycobacterial virulence that were common to strain H112 and hypervirulent <i>M. tuberculosis</i> strains of the same phylogenetic clade isolated in other global regions. <b>Methods:</b> A low-virulent <i>M. tuberculosis</i> strain H54 which belonged to the same phylogenetic lineage (L2) as strain H112 was selected from a collection of 115 clinical isolates. Both H112 and H54 were whole-genome-sequenced using PacBio sequencing technology. A comparative genomics approach was adopted to identify mutations present in strain H112 but absent in strain H54. Subsequently, an extensive phylogenetic analysis was conducted by including all publically available <i>M. tuberculosis</i> genomes. Single-nucleotide-polymorphisms (SNPs) and structural variations (SVs) common to hypervirulent strains in the global collection of genomes were considered as potential genetic determinants of hypervirulence. <b>Results:</b>Sequencing data revealed that both H112 and H54 were identified as members of the same sub-lineage L2.2.1. After excluding the lineage-related mutations shared between H112 and H54, we analyzed the phylogenetic relatedness of H112 with global collection of <i>M. tuberculosis</i> genomes (<i>n</i> = 4,338), and identified a novel phylogenetic clade in which four hypervirulent strains isolated from geographically diverse regions were clustered together. All hypervirulent strains in the clade shared 12 SNPs and 5 SVs with H112, including those affecting key virulence-associated loci, notably, a deleterious SNP (<i>rv0178</i> p. D150E) within <i>mce1</i> operon and an intergenic deletion (854259_ 854261delCC) in close-proximity to <i>phoP</i>. <b>Conclusion:</b> The present study identified common genetic factors in a novel phylogenetic clade of hypervirulent <i>M. tuberculosis</i>. The causative role of these mutations in mycobacterial virulence should be validated in future study.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{rajwani2018comparative,
  author = {Rahim Rajwani and Wing Cheong Yam and Ying Zhang and Yu Kang and Barry Kin Chung Wong and Kenneth Siu Sing Leung and Kingsley King Gee Tam and Ketema Tafess and Li Zhu and G. G. Siu},
  title = {{Comparative Whole-Genomic Analysis of an Ancient L2 Lineage Mycobacterium tuberculosis Reveals a Novel Phylogenetic Clade and Common Genetic Determinants of Hypervirulent Strains}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Cellular and Infection Microbiology},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.3389/fcimb.2017.00539},
}
Figure