Comparative Study on Marine Environmental Protection Legislation Between China and Japan from The Perspective of International Environmental Law

Meng YangJournal of Education Humanities and Social Sciences 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper provides a comparative legal analysis of how China and Japan—two major maritime powers—approach marine environmental protection. While Japan excels in domestic management, public education, and local-level enforcement, China is rapidly evolving its legal framework to transition from industry-focused regulations to a broader "big country" responsibility guided by the concept of a "community of human destiny."

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The authors tackle the "vicious circle" where rapid economic development and population growth lead to the degradation of marine ecosystems. Despite international frameworks like the 1972 Stockholm Declaration and the UN Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS), translating these global ideals into effective domestic legislation remains a challenge.

The paper specifically explores the gap between policy objectives and actual governance in China and Japan. It seeks to understand how different natural conditions, economic models, and legislative histories shape the way these nations protect their oceans from land-based pollution, industrial wastewater, and resource over-exploitation.

Methods

The paper employs a qualitative comparative legal analysis. The author reviews and compares:

  • Statutory Frameworks: Analyzing Japan’s Basic Law on the Oceans and Environmental Education Act against China’s Marine Environment Protection Act and Island Protection Law.
  • Policy Strategies: Comparing Japan’s "Basic Marine Plan" with China’s "Agenda 21 for China’s Oceans."
  • Case Studies: Looking at Japan’s management of the Seto Inland Sea and Lake Biwa as benchmarks for successful local governance.
  • International Context: Evaluating how both nations align their domestic laws with international environmental law and the UN’s 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development.

Datasets

As a legal and policy study, the paper does not use traditional numerical datasets. Instead, its "data" consists of:

  • Legal Texts: National laws and regulations from both China and Japan.
  • International Treaties: UNCLOS and the Stockholm Declaration.
  • Academic Literature: 10 cited references covering historical surveys of Japanese policy and recent trends in Chinese marine legislation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Japan’s Local-First Approach: A standout feature of Japanese governance is that local government standards for pollution are often stricter than national ones. This "bottom-up" pressure ensures higher compliance and innovation at the source.
  • The Power of Public Engagement: Japan utilizes "Ocean Day" and "Ocean Month" to foster a culture of marine stewardship. The author notes that Japan was the second country (after the US) to enact an Environmental Education Act, which significantly boosted public acceptance of strict pollution controls.
  • China’s "Big Country" Responsibility: While China started its environmental legislation later (major laws appearing in the late 1980s), it is shifting toward a strategy that balances domestic protection with international leadership. The paper highlights the "community of human destiny" as a guiding philosophy for China's future maritime cooperation.
  • The US Influence: Interestingly, the paper cites the United States as a model for both nations regarding the integration of scientific knowledge into the core of environmental decision-making.

Key Results

  • Governance Maturity: Japan is identified as having a more "perfected" and comprehensive legal system, particularly regarding land-based pollution and garbage classification.
  • Legislative Evolution in China: China has successfully moved from having no basic environmental law to a system that includes the Fisheries Act and the Law on the Administration of the Use of the Seas. However, the author admits the current system is still "relatively weak" and overly focused on specific industries rather than regional ecological health.
  • Convergence on Liability: Both nations are trending toward stricter enforcement. There is a shared move to expand legal liability for environmental violations beyond civil damages to include administrative and criminal penalties.

Limitations and Future Work

The author acknowledges several hurdles:

  • Governance Modernization: China’s current marine ecological governance system lacks "modernization" and needs better institutionalization to handle regional (rather than just industry-specific) issues.
  • Implementation Gaps: While laws exist on paper, the paper notes that the "governance capacity" needs improvement to meet the increasingly rigorous demands of marine ecological protection.
  • Future Directions: The paper suggests that future efforts should focus on "scientific and technological innovation" in governance and strengthening regional cooperation to treat the ocean as an inseparable, shared system rather than a collection of national zones.

Summary updated

Abstract

With the development of the economy and the rapid expansion of the global population, the effective utilization of marine resources has become an important way to alleviate the burden of the global population and environmental pressure. After entering the 21st century, the ocean is a strong driving force to promote the sustainable development of human society, however, with the development of industry, many countries have more or less fallen into the “vicious circle” of developing at the expense of the ecological environment for economic benefit. In recent years, a large number of chemicals by human activities and exploitation at sea has caused an imbalance of ecological environment in large area of sea areas; Discharging a large amount of industrial wastewater into the ocean, has deepened the degree of eutrophication is greatly and resulting in frequent red tides; the dumping of land waste makes it impossible for marine life to survive, and a large number of marine plants and animals died. In order to protect the natural environment, International environmental law was concluded in Stockholm, Sweden, in 1972. Both China and Japan are maritime powers, and detailed marine environmental protection laws and regulations have been formulated on the basis of international environmental law. This paper makes a comparative analysis on the similarities and differences of marine environmental protection legislation between China and Japan, and it is believed that Japan pays more attention to the protection of the domestic environment,while China has assumed more responsibilities as a big country in the legislation of marine environmental protection.
BibTeX
@article{yang2022comparative,
  author = {Meng Yang},
  title = {{Comparative Study on Marine Environmental Protection Legislation Between China and Japan from The Perspective of International Environmental Law}},
  journal = {Journal of Education Humanities and Social Sciences},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.54097/ehss.v1i.649},
}
Figure