Comparative study of transport and magnetic Jc in the polycrystalline iron-based superconductor NdFeAsO{0.88}F{0.12}

You‐Song Ding, Yi Sun, X. D. Wang, H. C. Wang, Z. X. Shi, Z. A. Ren, Jiong Yang, Weijia LüarXiv 2010 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

Polycrystalline $NdFeAsO_{0.88}F_{0.12}$ superconductors synthesized via high-pressure (HP) and ambient-pressure (AP) methods were evaluated through magnetization and transport measurements. While high-pressure synthesis yielded samples with superior density, higher transition temperatures ($T_c$), and enhanced magnetic critical current density ($J_{cm}$), both samples exhibited significant "weak-link" behavior at grain boundaries. This study characterizes the upper critical field ($H_{c2}$), irreversibility field ($H_{irr}$), and anisotropy, while highlighting the substantial discrepancy between magnetic and transport critical current densities ($J_{ct}$), which remains the primary obstacle for practical applications.

Introduction

Iron-based pnictide superconductors, particularly the "1111" family such as $NdFeAsO_{1-x}F_x$, have garnered intense interest due to their high transition temperatures (exceeding 50 K) and extraordinary upper critical fields ($H_{c2}$), which can surpass 100 Tesla. These properties position them as potential successors to conventional superconductors in high-field magnet applications. However, translating these intrinsic properties into usable polycrystalline wires or tapes is challenging. Like cuprate superconductors, pnictides suffer from grain boundary issues where the superconducting order parameter is suppressed, creating "weak links" that limit the bulk transport critical current density ($J_c$). This research compares two synthesis routes—High Pressure (HP) and Ambient Pressure (AP)—to determine their impact on connectivity and current-carrying capacity.

Experimental Methodology

Two distinct batches of $NdFeAsO_{0.88}F_{0.12}$ were prepared:

  1. Sample HP: Synthesized using a high-pressure apparatus at 6 GPa and 1250°C for 2 hours. This method typically promotes higher density and better chemical homogeneity.
  2. Sample AP: Prepared through a standard two-step solid-state reaction at ambient pressure, with a final sintering stage at 1150°C for 45 hours.

Structural integrity and phase purity were verified using X-ray diffraction (XRD) and scanning electron microscopy (SEM). Superconducting performance was characterized using a Vibrating Sample Magnetometer (VSM) to generate magnetic hysteresis loops (MHLs), from which $J_{cm}$ was calculated using the Bean critical state model. Direct transport measurements ($J_{ct}$) were conducted using a standard four-probe technique in magnetic fields up to 9 Tesla.

Results and Discussion

Structural and Transition Properties

High-pressure synthesis proved superior in several key metrics. Sample HP achieved a theoretical density of 82%, significantly higher than the 53% observed in Sample AP. Furthermore, the HP process facilitated more effective Fluorine doping, resulting in a $T_c$ of 51 K, compared to 44 K for the AP sample.

The upper critical field $H_{c2}(0)$ was estimated from the resistance transition curves. Sample HP exhibited a staggering $H_{c2}(0)$ of approximately 283 T, while Sample AP reached 195 T. Both values significantly exceed the Pauli paramagnetic limit, confirming the robust nature of superconductivity in these materials. The anisotropy parameter ($\Gamma$) was found to be between 34 and 40, aligning with values typically observed in single-crystal specimens.

A critical finding in this study is the behavior of the magnetic hysteresis loops in low fields. Both samples showed "reclosed" loops at very low magnetic fields. In the context of polycrystalline superconductors, this is a signature of weak-link behavior: the magnetic field easily penetrates the poorly connected grain boundaries, decoupling the grains even while the grains themselves remain strongly superconducting.

Critical Current Density Discrepancy

The most telling evidence of connectivity issues is the massive gap between magnetic ($J_{cm}$) and transport ($J_{ct}$) critical current densities.

  • $J_{cm}$: Reflects the local current density circulating within individual grains or well-connected clusters. Sample HP showed significantly higher $J_{cm}$ than Sample AP, likely due to enhanced flux pinning from defects induced by the high-pressure environment.
  • $J_{ct}$: Reflects the global current that can traverse the entire length of the sample. For both samples, $J_{ct}$ was orders of magnitude lower than $J_{cm}$.

In both HP and AP samples, $J_{ct}$ dropped precipitously when a small external magnetic field (0–0.1 T) was applied. This sharp decline indicates that the majority of inter-grain paths are weak links that are "quenched" by low fields. However, the fact that a residual $J_{ct}$ persists up to 9 T suggests the existence of a small fraction of "intrinsic strong links" that maintain connectivity even in high-field environments.

Conclusion

While high-pressure synthesis significantly improves the density and intrinsic superconducting parameters ($T_c$, $H_{c2}$) of $NdFeAsO_{0.88}F_{0.12}$, it does not fully resolve the weak-link problem inherent in polycrystalline pnictides. The large discrepancy between $J_{cm}$ and $J_{ct}$ highlights that the bulk current is limited by extrinsic factors such as grain boundary impurities, cracks, and phase inhomogeneity. Future development must focus on textural alignment and the purification of grain boundaries to bridge the gap between the material's immense microscopic potential and its macroscopic performance.

Summary updated

Abstract

Polycrystalline NdFeAsO0.88F0.12 superconductors prepared by high pressure (HP) and ambient pressure (AP) method were comparatively studied by magnetization and transport measurements. Upper critical field (Hc2), irreversibility field (Hirr) and the anisotropy parameter were estimated from resistance transition curves. The broadening of transition width was observed, and ascribed to both Hc2 anisotropy and superconductivity inhomogeneity of samples. Magnetic hysteresis loops (MHLs) in low fields were measured to detect the trace of weak-link behavior. The reclosed hysteresis loops in low fields manifest that there are weak-links in both samples. Magnetization critical current density Jcm were derived from MHLs. High-pressure synthesized sample shows higher Jcm. However, by means of direct transport I-V measurements, transport critical current density Jct was very low. The Jct values for two samples are comparable. Large discrepancies between Jcm and Jct also indicate that there are weak-links in both samples. The relative mechanism is discussed in detail.
BibTeX
@misc{ding2010comparative,
  author = {You‐Song Ding and Yi Sun and X. D. Wang and H. C. Wang and Z. X. Shi and Z. A. Ren and Jiong Yang and Weijia Lü},
  title = {{Comparative study of transport and magnetic Jc in the polycrystalline iron-based superconductor NdFeAsO\{0.88\}F\{0.12\}}},
  year = {2010},
  eprint = {1003.0946},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1003.0946},
}
Figure