Comparative Prediction of Surface Settlement in Coal Pillar Replacement Mining Based on EFA-tSSA-SVR Model Study

Yong Li, Chang Luo, Hengyu Su, Yichao Jia, Xiaoqin Li, Zhen ChenResearch Square 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

Researchers have developed a hybrid machine learning model (EFA-tSSA-SVR) that predicts surface subsidence in coal mines with significantly higher accuracy than traditional numerical simulations. By combining dimensionality reduction with an optimized "sparrow search" algorithm, the model achieved a prediction error of just 5.9%, providing a more reliable tool for preventing mining-related geological disasters.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In coal mining, "coal pillar replacement" is a technique used to recover coal previously left behind to support the mine roof. While efficient for resource recovery, this process is geologically volatile. As pillars are removed and replaced with backfill material, the equilibrium of the surrounding rock is disrupted, often leading to surface settlement (subsidence).

Predicting exactly how much the ground will sink is vital for protecting surface infrastructure like railways and homes. Traditional methods—ranging from empirical formulas to complex physics-based numerical simulations (like FLAC3D)—often struggle with the non-linear, dynamic nature of the rock strata or require immense computational labor and specialized expertise to set up accurately. This paper seeks a faster, more precise alternative using machine learning.

Methods

The authors propose a multi-stage hybrid model called EFA-tSSA-SVR. Here is the breakdown of the "alphabet soup":

  1. Exploratory Factor Analysis (EFA): The team started with seven key influencing factors (e.g., mining depth, seam dip, filling body strength). EFA was used to reduce these into three "main factors" to eliminate redundant data and noise, making the model more efficient.
  2. Support Vector Regression (SVR): This is the core prediction engine. SVR is particularly good at handling small datasets and non-linear relationships, which are common in mining geology.
  3. Improved Sparrow Search Algorithm (tSSA): SVR performance depends heavily on choosing the right parameters (penalty factor $C$ and kernel parameters). The authors used a "Sparrow Search Algorithm" inspired by bird foraging behavior but improved it with a t-distribution and tangent flight perturbation. These tweaks help the algorithm avoid getting stuck in "local optima" (mediocre solutions) and find the best possible settings for the SVR.

The team compared this hybrid ML approach against a standard FLAC3D numerical simulation, which models the physical stresses of the rock layers.

Datasets

The study utilized a dataset of 20 historical mining records from various sites across China. Each record included seven variables:

  • Depth of coal seam
  • Mining strip width
  • Coal pillar width
  • Mining height
  • Dip of the coal seam
  • Subsidence coefficient
  • Filling body strength

The data was split into a training set (14 samples) and a testing set (6 samples) using a 7:3 ratio.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Simpler is Better: By using EFA to reduce seven variables down to three, the researchers proved that you don't need every single data point to get a high-quality prediction; you just need the right latent factors.
  • Nature-Inspired Optimization: The "Sparrow Search" is effective, but the addition of the t-distribution was the "aha moment." It allows the model to act like a Cauchy distribution (wide search) in the early stages and a Gaussian distribution (refined search) in the later stages, balancing exploration and precision.
  • ML vs. Physics: While numerical simulations (FLAC3D) are the industry standard, they are limited by the user's ability to input perfect rock mechanics parameters. The ML model "learns" the outcome directly from historical data, bypassing some of the human error inherent in setting up complex physical simulations.

Key Results

The proposed EFA-tSSA-SVR model outperformed the traditional numerical simulation across the board:

  • Accuracy: The ML model predicted a maximum subsidence of 26.40mm against an actual measured value of 25.20mm (a 5.90% error).
  • Simulation Comparison: The FLAC3D numerical model predicted 28.00mm (11.10% error), making the ML model nearly twice as accurate.
  • Model Fit: The ML model achieved an $R^2$ of 0.985 and a Root Mean Square Error (RMSE) of 0.0308, indicating an exceptionally tight fit to the actual field data.

Limitations and Future Work

The primary limitation acknowledged is the sample size. While SVR is robust with small datasets, 20 samples is still a narrow window into the vast diversity of global mining geologies.

The authors suggest that future work should focus on:

  • Expanding the database: Collecting and empirically measuring more diverse geological elements to improve the model's generalization.
  • Real-time integration: Moving from "post-hoc" prediction to real-time monitoring systems that can update predictions as mining progresses.

Summary updated

Abstract

<title>Abstract</title> In order to accurately predict it, the maximum subsidence value of the surface of coal pillar replacement fill mining is examined using machine learning and numerical simulation. Exploratory factor analysis (EFA) is utilized to achieve the dimensionality reduction of influencing factors after carefully considering the seven key influencing factors. The findings of the numerical simulation prediction are then compared with the support vector regression machine model (EFA-tSSA-SVR), which is trained on various data sets and optimized using the enhanced sparrow search algorithm (tSSA). The surface subsidence in the first stage is calculated by the numerical model to be 2.00mm, and in the second stage, it is calculated to be 28.00mm, both of which are within 11.10% of the actual amount. The latter forecasts a relative inaccuracy that is about twice as large as the former. The findings show that the EFA-tSSA-SVR optimization model fits well, with an R<sup>2</sup>close to 1, and a predicted value of 26.40mm that is very close to the measured value of 25.20mm with a 5.90% error. The EFA-tSSA-SVR model can predict the maximum amount of surface sinking, and both models can provide reference values for surface subsidence prediction.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{li2023comparative,
  author = {Yong Li and Chang Luo and Hengyu Su and Yichao Jia and Xiaoqin LI and Zhen Chen},
  title = {{Comparative Prediction of Surface Settlement in Coal Pillar Replacement Mining Based on EFA-tSSA-SVR Model Study}},
  booktitle = {Research Square},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.21203/rs.3.rs-3406676/v1},
}
Figure