Comparative population genomics identified genomic regions and candidate genes associated with fruit domestication traits in peach

Ke Cao, Yong Li, Cecilia Deng, Susan E. Gardiner, Gengrui Zhu, Weichao Fang, Chang Wen Chen, Xinwei Wang, Lirong WangPlant 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This study leverages population genomics and genome-wide association studies (GWAS) on a large dataset of peach accessions to pinpoint genomic regions and candidate genes responsible for key fruit domestication traits. The findings reveal distinct evolutionary trajectories for domestication and improvement, offering valuable insights for breeding more nutritious and desirable peach varieties.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

While the domestication of annual crops has been extensively studied, the genetic underpinnings of domestication and improvement in perennial fruit crops like peach remain less understood. This is partly due to their longer lifespans and clonal propagation, which can complicate evolutionary analyses. Understanding the genetic basis of traits like fruit size, sugar content, and polyphenol composition is crucial for breeding efforts aimed at enhancing both nutritional value and consumer appeal. This paper aims to fill this knowledge gap by performing a comprehensive genomic analysis of peach evolution.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach:

  • Genome-wide resequencing: They sequenced 418 peach accessions to capture a broad spectrum of genetic diversity, including wild relatives, landraces, and improved varieties.
  • Population structure analysis: Using phylogenetic trees and STRUCTURE analysis, they inferred the evolutionary history and relationships among these accessions, confirming a single domestication event.
  • Selective sweep detection: They identified regions of the genome that have undergone strong selection during domestication (wild relatives vs. landraces/improved varieties) and improvement (landraces vs. improved varieties) by analyzing patterns of genetic diversity (π values) and using the XP-EHH test.
  • Genome-wide association studies (GWAS): They performed GWAS using millions of single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) to identify genetic loci associated with 26 fruit domestication traits, including fruit weight, sugar, acid, and polyphenol content.
  • Tissue-specific gene expression analysis: RNA sequencing was used to examine the expression patterns of selected genes in different tissues (root, phloem, leaf, fruit, seed) across various peach groups to understand where selection pressures were most active.
  • Candidate gene validation: For key identified loci, they performed further analyses, including promoter sequencing and overexpression in a heterologous system (tomato), to validate candidate genes.

Datasets

The study utilized a dataset of 418 peach accessions, encompassing:

  • Wild related species (e.g., P. mira, P. davidiana)
  • Wild peach varieties
  • Ornamental lines
  • Edible landraces
  • Improved varieties

This dataset was generated through genome-wide resequencing, yielding approximately 1.17 Tb of clean sequencing reads. For GWAS, a subset of 313 accessions was used. For tissue-specific expression analysis, samples from three varieties of wild related species, three ornamental peaches, three edible landraces, and three improved varieties were analyzed.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Distinct evolutionary paths for domestication and improvement: The study highlights that selection pressures during domestication (from wild to cultivated) and improvement (from landraces to modern cultivars) targeted different genomic regions and potentially different sets of genes.
  • Fruit and seeds as key domestication tissues: Genes showing increased expression during domestication were predominantly found in fruit and seeds, suggesting these organs were primary targets of early selection.
  • Leaves and seeds for improvement: In contrast, during the improvement phase, selection appears to have favored genes expressed more in leaves and seeds.
  • Trade-offs in trait evolution: The research suggests a potential evolutionary trade-off, where selection for increased sugar content might have led to a decrease in polyphenol content, implying a complex balance in breeding goals.
  • Candidate genes for key traits identified: The study successfully pinpointed candidate genes associated with crucial traits like fruit weight, sorbitol content, and catechin/epicatechin content, providing molecular targets for future breeding.

Key Results

  • 132 selective sweeps associated with domestication and 106 selective sweeps associated with improvement were identified.
  • 171 loci were found to be associated with 26 fruit domestication traits through GWAS.
  • Three candidate genes were strongly associated with fruit weight, sorbitol, and catechin content.
  • A significant decrease in allele frequency for SNPs associated with high polyphenol composition was observed during peach evolution, while alleles associated with high sugar content increased.
  • The study identified a candidate gene, Prupe.6G046800, a cytochrome P450 gene, strongly associated with fruit weight, with mutations in its promoter region linked to variations in fruit size.
  • A candidate gene, Prupe.4G191900, a diacylglycerol kinase, was identified for sorbitol content.
  • A candidate gene, Prupe.2G087000, encoding a ribosomal protein, was linked to catechin and epicatechin content.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Tissue-specific expression limitations: While fruit and seeds were highlighted for domestication, the study notes that seeds were not the primary focus for further analysis due to persistent up-regulation of genes. The authors also suggest that fruit might not be the primary selection organ during improvement, which could explain fewer improvement-related genes being regulated in fruit tissue.
  • Breeding implications: The study provides valuable information for breeders regarding allele frequencies for key traits. They suggest that heterozygosity in fruit weight offers room for improvement, and that wild species could be utilized for recovering health-related polyphenols through distant hybridization, while cautioning against bitterness and browning.
  • Future research: The authors believe their generated genomic resources and characterized traits will facilitate further investigation into the mechanisms of peach evolution and provide a foundation for future genetic improvement. They emphasize the need to select for specific potent compounds with high nutritional value that do not lead to undesirable traits like bitterness.

Summary updated

Abstract

Crop evolution is a long-term process involving selection by natural evolutionary forces and anthropogenic influences; however, the genetic mechanisms underlying the domestication and improvement of fruit crops have not been well studied to date. Here, we performed a population structure analysis in peach (Prunus persica) based on the genome-wide resequencing of 418 accessions and confirmed the presence of an obvious domestication event during evolution. We identified 132 and 106 selective sweeps associated with domestication and improvement, respectively. Analysis of their tissue-specific expression patterns indicated that the up-regulation of selection genes during domestication occurred mostly in fruit and seeds as opposed to other organs. However, during the improvement stage, more up-regulated selection genes were identified in leaves and seeds than in the other organs. Genome-wide association studies (GWAS) using 4.24 million single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) revealed 171 loci associated with 26 fruit domestication traits. Among these loci, three candidate genes were highly associated with fruit weight and the sorbitol and catechin content in fruit. We demonstrated that as the allele frequency of the SNPs associated with high polyphenol composition decreased during peach evolution, alleles associated with high sugar content increased significantly. This indicates that there is genetic potential for the breeding of more nutritious fruit with enhanced bioactive polyphenols without disturbing a harmonious sugar and acid balance by crossing with wild species. This study also describes the development of the genomic resources necessary for evolutionary research in peach and provides the large-scale characterization of key agronomic traits in this crop species.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{cao2019comparative,
  author = {Ke Cao and Yong Li and Cecilia Deng and Susan E. Gardiner and Gengrui Zhu and Weichao Fang and Chang Wen Chen and Xinwei Wang and Lirong Wang},
  title = {{Comparative population genomics identified genomic regions and candidate genes associated with fruit domestication traits in peach}},
  booktitle = {Plant},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1111/pbi.13112},
}
Figure