Comparative Insect Faunas between Ganghwado and Six Others Islands of West Coastal in Incheon, Korea

Seong‐Joon Park, Hyuksoo Kwon, Seo-Kyoung Park, Do Sung Kim, Doo‐Sang Park, Doo-Sang ParkJournal of Asia-Pacific Biodiversity 2013 · DOI

TL;DR

This study quantifies insect fauna similarity across seven islands off Korea's west coast, revealing distinct biogeographic patterns. The findings highlight how island size and distance from the mainland influence species richness and composition, offering insights into island biogeography principles.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Island biogeography is a classic field for understanding ecological processes like colonization, adaptation, and speciation due to their inherent isolation. While the general principles of island biogeography (e.g., species-area and species-distance relationships) are well-established, there's a need for detailed, quantitative studies on specific taxa in under-researched regions. This paper addresses this gap by providing a comprehensive comparative analysis of insect faunas across seven islands in the west coastal region of Incheon, Korea. The authors aim to understand the biogeographic characteristics and faunal similarities of these islands, contributing to a better understanding of insect distribution patterns in this specific archipelago.

Methods

The researchers employed a quantitative approach to analyze insect faunal similarity. The core method involved calculating the Bray & Curtis similarity index, a standard metric for comparing ecological communities based on species presence and absence. This similarity matrix was then subjected to hierarchical cluster analysis using the UPGMA (Unweighted Pair Group Method with Arithmetic Mean) method. This allowed them to group islands with similar insect faunal compositions. Additionally, they analyzed species-area and species-distance relationships, transforming these variables logarithmically as per established island biogeography theory.

Datasets

The study utilized insect survey data collected from seven islands in the west coastal region of Incheon, Korea: Baengnyeongdo, Boleumdo, Daecheongdo, Ganghwado, Gyodongdo, Seokmodo, and Yeonpyeongdo. Data for Ganghwado and six other islands were compiled from previous investigations and direct collection by the authors. The total dataset comprised 1,001 insect species belonging to 12 orders.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Island size and distance matter: The study reinforces the fundamental principles of island biogeography, showing that larger islands and those closer to the mainland tend to harbor more insect species.
  • Distinct faunal groupings: Cluster analysis revealed that the seven islands could be divided into three distinct groups based on their insect faunal similarity, suggesting underlying ecological or historical factors shaping their communities.
  • Ganghwado as an outlier: Ganghwado, being connected to the mainland by a bridge and subject to significant human disturbance, emerged as an outlier in the species-area and species-distance analyses, highlighting the impact of anthropogenic factors on island ecosystems.
  • Varied species richness: Seokmodo stood out with the highest species diversity (497 species), while Yeonpyeongdo had the lowest (136 species), underscoring the heterogeneity in species composition even among relatively close islands.

Key Results

  • A total of 1,001 insect species from 12 orders were recorded across the seven islands.
  • Seokmodo had the highest number of species (497), followed by Ganghwado (309 species from seven orders).
  • Yeonpyeongdo had the lowest species count (136).
  • Faunal similarity values ranged from 24.907% (Gyodongdo to Yeonpyeongdo) to 49.899% (Baengnyeongdo to Ganghwado).
  • Cluster analysis indicated that the islands could be divided into 3 groups at a similarity level of 30.97%.
  • Islands farther from the mainland generally showed less species richness than those closer to it.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Human disturbance: The authors acknowledge that Ganghwado's unique position as a connected island, subject to human disturbance, makes it an outlier and complicates direct comparisons with more isolated islands.
  • Further island comparisons: The study suggests that future research could expand by estimating species numbers on other islands and comparing them with inhabited and uninhabited islands to further refine understanding of island biogeography.
  • Taxonomic depth: While the study covers 12 orders, further detailed taxonomic work within specific orders could reveal finer-scale biogeographic patterns.

Summary updated

Abstract

This study was conducted to investigate the biogeographic characteristics of the insect faunas of the seven islands of the west coast of Incheon, Korea, using a quantitative analysis method. The faunal similarity was examined using the Bray & Curtis similarity. The obtained similarity value matrix was examined with cluster analysis using the UPGMA method. The recorded number of each species in the areas was 1,001 from 12 orders and they were distributed on the seven islands surveyed. Among the surveyed islands, Seokmodo had the highest number of species with 497, while Yeonpyeongdo had the lowest with 136 species. The species composition of insects reported in Ganghwado was 309 species belonging to seven orders. The similarity values between the seven localities investigated ranged from 24.907 (Gyodongdo to Yeonpyeongdo) to 49.899 (Baengnyeongdo to Ganghwado). That is, the species composition of Baengnyeongdo (47.90%) was similar to that of Ganghwado, while it was different from that of Yeonpyeongdo (25.28%). The cluster analysis using a similarity index shows that all the islands in these areas can be divided into 3 groups at the level of 30.97%.
BibTeX
@article{park2013comparative,
  author = {Seong‐Joon Park and Hyuksoo Kwon and Seo-Kyoung Park and Do Sung Kim and Doo‐Sang Park and Do Sung Kim and Doo-Sang Park},
  title = {{Comparative Insect Faunas between Ganghwado and Six Others Islands of West Coastal in Incheon, Korea}},
  journal = {Journal of Asia-Pacific Biodiversity},
  year = {2013},
  doi = {10.7229/jkn.2013.6.2.197},
}
Figure