Comparative effects of high-intensity interval training and moderate-intensity continuous training on weight and metabolic health in college students with obesity

Xu Song, Xianyou Cui, Wenbo Su, Xueyan Shang, Tao Meng, Jing Wang, Chang Liu, Yaowei Sun, Hezhang YunScientific 2024 · DOI

Abstract

The purpose of this study was to compare the effects of High-Intensity Interval Training (HIIT) and Moderate-Intensity Continuous Training (MICT) on weight, body composition, blood lipid indicators, and metabolic status in college students living with obesity. The study focused on a sample of 40 college students living with obesity, including 20 males and 20 females, aged between 18 and 25. Participants were randomly assigned to either the HIIT group or the MICT group. Both groups underwent an 8-week intervention, consisting of three sessions per week with alternate-day training. Compared to the baseline assessment, the HIIT group showed a more favorable declining trend than the MICT group in terms of body morphology and body composition, particularly in the aspect of body fat percentage (BF%). Among these, HIIT demonstrates greater effectiveness compared to MICT in BF% and biochemical markers.

Introduction

Obesity rates among college students are rising, bringing a host of metabolic risks including hypertension, hyperlipidemia, and insulin resistance. While exercise is the standard prescription, the "best" modality remains a subject of debate. MICT (steady-state aerobic exercise) is the traditional approach, but it requires significant time commitments. HIIT (short bursts of intense effort followed by recovery) is touted for its efficiency, but its specific impact on the obese student demographic—and how these effects might differ by gender—needed more rigorous exploration. This study sought to determine if the physiological "bang for your buck" with HIIT justifies the higher intensity for this specific population.

Methods

The researchers conducted an 8-week randomized controlled trial with 40 obese college students (20 male, 20 female), aged 18–25, with a BMI $\ge$ 25. Initially, 50 subjects were recruited, with 10 lost to follow-up or missing data.

Study flow and participant randomization

The participants were split into HIIT and MICT groups. A critical strength of this study's methodology was energy expenditure matching (~34 liters of $O_2$ per session):

  • HIIT Group: 28-minute sessions. 4 sets of 4-minute high-intensity phases (85–90% HRmax) interspersed with 3-minute recovery periods (50–60% HRmax).
  • MICT Group: 35-minute sessions. Continuous aerobic exercise at 60–70% HRmax.

Measurements included anthropometric data (weight, BMI, body fat %, waist/hip circumference) and biochemical markers (TC, TG, LDL-C, HDL-C, ALT, and Uric Acid) taken at baseline and after 8 weeks.

Results

Even when total energy expenditure is matched, HIIT produces superior fat loss. This suggests that the manner in which energy is spent (intensity fluctuations) triggers different physiological adaptations than steady-state work. The authors attribute HIIT’s edge to Excess Post-exercise Oxygen Consumption (EPOC), which keeps the metabolic rate elevated for longer during the recovery phase.

Comparison of anthropometric changes (Weight, BMI, BF%) between HIIT and MICT groups over 8 weeks

Body Composition and Morphology

The HIIT group saw much steeper declines in BF% than the MICT group. Specifically, the female HIIT group reduced BF% by 26.76%, while the female MICT group only saw a 7.16% reduction. Overall, the male HIIT group, female HIIT group, male MICT group, and female MICT group reduced BF% by 23.71%, 26.76%, 9.81%, and 7.16%, respectively. A significant observation was that the rate of decline in weight and BMI was much higher in the first 4 weeks than in the final 4 weeks, suggesting an early "adaptation window."

Biochemical Markers

HIIT was significantly more effective at lowering Triglycerides (TG). The female HIIT group saw an 18.91% greater reduction in TG compared to the female MICT group. In males, HIIT led to a 22.13% greater reduction in LDL-C compared to the MICT group. Additionally, HIIT significantly reduced Alanine Aminotransferase (ALT) levels in females ($P < 0.01$), whereas MICT did not produce a statistically significant change for that subgroup.

Discussion

The study highlights gender dimorphism in response to exercise. Females showed a more pronounced response to HIIT in terms of Body Fat Percentage (BF%) reduction, while males showed greater improvements in biochemical markers (Total Cholesterol, LDL-C, and Uric Acid) through HIIT compared to females.

Despite these findings, the study has limitations, including the lack of a sedentary control group and strict dietary tracking. Future research should include a non-exercise control group and more rigorous dietary monitoring to further refine the "dose-response" relationship of HIIT in diverse populations.

Conclusion

For college students living with obesity, both HIIT and MICT have shown positive effects. However, HIIT demonstrates greater effectiveness compared to MICT in reducing body fat percentage and improving biochemical markers, often requiring less time per session.

Summary updated

Abstract

The purpose of this study was to compare the effects of High-Intensity Interval Training (HIIT) and Moderate-Intensity Continuous Training (MICT) on weight, body composition, blood lipid indicators, and metabolic status in college students living with obesity. The study focused on a sample of 40 college students living with obesity, including 20 males and 20 females, aged between 18 and 25. Participants were randomly assigned to either the HIIT group or the MICT group. Both groups underwent an 8-week intervention, consisting of three sessions per week with alternate-day training. The MICT group's training consisted of continuous aerobic exercise for 35 min at 60-70% of maximum heart rate. The HIIT group engaged in 28 min of alternating high-intensity and low-intensity exercise, where the high-intensity phase was at 85-90% of maximum heart rate for 4 min, followed by a 3-min recovery period at 50-60% of maximum heart rate, repeated four times. Both groups underwent heart rate monitoring before and after the training sessions to ensure the accuracy of the training intensity. Within each group, further distinctions were made based on gender, resulting in the following subgroups: Male HIIT group (n = 10), Female HIIT group (n = 10), Male MICT group (n = 10), and Female MICT group (n = 10). Differences in anthropometric and biochemical indicators among the groups were analyzed, and the different effects of the two intervention strategies on the obese college student population were comprehensively evaluated. Compared to the baseline assessment, the HIIT group showed a more favorable declining trend than the MICT group in terms of body morphology and body composition, particularly in the aspect of body fat percentage (BF%). The male HIIT group, female HIIT group, male MICT group, and female MICT group respectively reduced by - 23.71%, - 26.76%, - 9.81%, - 7.16%. Male and female HIIT group experienced a more pronounced decrease compared to the MICT group, with the female HIIT group reducing an additional 3.75% more than the male HIIT group. Regarding intergroup differences, BF% significant differences were shown between male MICT group and the HIIT group (P < 0.05), and female MICT group and the HIIT group (P < 0.01). In terms of biochemical indicators, the HIIT group also presented a more favorable declining trend compared to the MICT group, with male HIIT participants showing more reduction than female HIIT participants, especially in total cholesterol (TC) (10.64%), low-density lipoprotein cholesterol (LDL-C) (11.73%), alanine aminotransferase (ALT) (11.99%), and uric acid (UA) (11.76%). Regarding triglycerides (TG), significant intergroup differences were observed between male MICT and HIIT groups (P < 0.01) and female MICT and HIIT groups (P < 0.01). Concerning ALT, a significant difference was shown between female MICT and HIIT groups (P < 0.01), while no significant difference was observed among male participants. Overall, for college students living with obesity, both HIIT and MICT have shown positive effects. Among these, HIIT demonstrates greater effectiveness compared to MICT in BF% and biochemical markers.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{song2024comparative,
  author = {Xu Song and Xianyou Cui and Wenbo Su and Xueyan Shang and Tao Meng and Jing Wang and Chang Liu and Yaowei Sun and Hezhang Yun},
  title = {{Comparative effects of high-intensity interval training and moderate-intensity continuous training on weight and metabolic health in college students with obesity}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1038/s41598-024-67331-z},
}
Figure