Comparative DFT+U and HSE Study of the Oxygen Evolution Electrocatalysis on Perovskite Oxides

Vladimir Tripković, Heine Anton Hansen, J. M. García‐Lastra, Tejs VeggeThe Journal of Physical Chemistry C 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how the accuracy of computational methods (DFT+U and HSE) for predicting the performance of perovskite oxides as oxygen evolution electrocatalysts is highly sensitive to the choice of computational parameters (U and α). The findings highlight significant challenges in using these methods for reliable catalyst design, especially for strongly correlated systems.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Designing efficient and stable electrocatalysts for the oxygen evolution reaction (OER) is crucial for technologies like water splitting and metal-air batteries. Perovskite oxides are promising candidates due to their abundance and tunability. However, accurately predicting their catalytic activity and stability computationally is challenging. This is because these materials often involve "strongly correlated" electrons, which are not well-described by standard Density Functional Theory (DFT) methods. To address this, researchers often use DFT with an added Hubbard U correction (DFT+U) or employ hybrid functionals like Heyd-Scuseria-Ernzerhof (HSE). The problem is that the results from these methods can be highly dependent on the specific parameters chosen (the U value in DFT+U and the exact exchange parameter α in HSE), making it difficult to know which results are reliable and how to best design new catalysts. This paper aims to systematically explore this sensitivity and its implications for OER electrocatalysis.

Methods

The researchers employed Density Functional Theory (DFT) calculations using the Vienna Ab initio Simulation Package (VASP). They utilized the Projector Augmented-Wave (PAW) pseudopotentials and the Perdew-Burke-Ernzerhof (PBE) exchange-correlation functional.

Key methodological aspects include:

  • DFT+U: They applied the Hubbard U correction to account for strong electron correlations. They systematically varied the U parameter across three values (0, 3, and 5 eV) to assess its impact.
  • HSE Hybrid Functional: They used the Heyd-Scuseria-Ernzerhof (HSE) hybrid functional, which incorporates a portion of exact exchange (Fock exchange). They investigated the influence of the exact exchange parameter, α, by testing discrete values (0, 0.15, 0.25, and 0.35).
  • Computational Cost Reduction: For HSE calculations, they fixed the lattice constants to those obtained from DFT+U calculations with U=5 eV to reduce computational expense.
  • Surface Modeling: They modeled the most stable (001) perovskite facet and used thin slabs (4 layers) for surface calculations.
  • Thermodynamic Stability: They used heats of formation calculated against relevant oxide phases as a measure of electrochemical stability.
  • Catalytic Activity: They calculated reaction overpotentials for the oxygen evolution reaction (OER) using the computational hydrogen electrode (CHE) method, focusing on the difference between adsorption free energies of intermediates.
  • Electronic Conductivity: They analyzed the electronic density of states (DOS) to determine conductivity types.

The novelty lies in the systematic and comparative study of the sensitivity of OER-relevant properties (stability, activity, conductivity) to both U and α parameters across a range of perovskite oxides.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on first-principles calculations rather than experimental datasets for training or evaluation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Parameter Sensitivity is a Major Hurdle: The most striking finding is the profound dependence of calculated heats of formation, adsorption energies, and reaction overpotentials on the chosen U (in DFT+U) and α (in HSE) parameters. This sensitivity is particularly pronounced when the oxidation state of the B cation in the perovskite differs from that in the reference oxide used for formation energy calculations.
  • Oxidation State Dictates Sensitivity: The degree of dependence on U and α is directly linked to changes in the oxidation state of the B cations. If the valence remains the same, the parameters have a minimal effect. However, if the valence changes significantly, the calculated energies can shift by as much as 1 eV.
  • HSE Not Necessarily a Better Benchmark: The study questions the assumption that HSE calculations, due to their higher computational cost, always provide superior benchmarks for DFT+U results. The results show that HSE is equally sensitive to its parameter α as DFT+U is to its parameter U, suggesting that α also needs careful fitting.
  • Structural Trends Emerge: Despite the parameter sensitivity, some general trends in stability were observed. Perovskites with face-shared octahedra appear to be more stable, while those with negative charge transfer energy are less stable.
  • Conductivity is Less Sensitive: In contrast to stability and activity, electronic conductivity shows less qualitative dependence on the specific U or α values. This suggests that conductivity predictions might be more robust, although the absolute values can still be affected.
  • Diverse Conduction Mechanisms: The study identifies three main types of electronic conductivity in these oxides: intrinsic conductivity (e.g., Fe⁴⁺, Co³⁺(IS), Ni³⁺), electron polaron hopping (along Mn³⁺–O–Mn⁴⁺ chains), and hole transport in the valence band.

Key Results

  • Formation Energies: Heats of formation can change by up to 1 eV depending on the U or α values when B cation valences differ between the perovskite and reference oxide.
  • Reaction Overpotentials: Similar to formation energies, reaction overpotentials for OER show a large dependence on U and α, making direct comparisons between catalysts challenging without careful parameterization.
  • Stability: Perovskites with face-shared octahedra were found to be generally more stable.
  • Conductivity: While the qualitative conductivity type (semiconductor, metallic, etc.) was less sensitive to U and α, the specific mechanisms (intrinsic, polaron hopping, hole transport) were identified. For example, Fe⁴⁺, Co³⁺(IS), and Ni³⁺ were identified as contributing to intrinsic conductivity.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Parameter Fitting is Crucial: The study strongly suggests that for accurate predictions of stability and activity in these strongly correlated systems, the U and α parameters need to be carefully fitted to experimental data (e.g., reaction enthalpies). This is a significant practical challenge.
  • HSE Cost vs. Benefit: The authors conclude that the increased computational cost of HSE calculations may not be justified for multi-step electrochemical reactions on complex oxides, given their similar sensitivity to parameters as DFT+U.
  • Generalizability: While the study focused on perovskite oxides and OER, the authors believe the findings regarding parameter sensitivity are likely generalizable to other strongly correlated systems where oxidation states change during reactions.
  • Future Directions: The authors are pursuing two avenues to address these challenges:
  • A computationally low-cost approach using thermochemical tables to make reaction energetics U-independent.
  • Applying higher-level methods like Møller-Plesset second-order perturbation (MP2) theory with an affordable basis set.

Summary updated

Abstract

The most common method for incorporating strong electron correlations is either to apply the Hubbard U correction on top of standard density functional theory calculations (DFT) or to use hybrid functionals. In this study, we elucidate the sensitivity of the Hubbard U correction in the PBE+U functional and the amount of exact exchange, α, in the hybrid HSE functional on the structural stability, catalytic activity, and electronic conductivity of pure and doped perovskite oxides, ABO3 (A = La, Ca, Sr, and Ba; B = Cr, Mn, Fe, Co, Ni, and Cu) for oxygen evolution electrocatalysis. We find a strong dependence of heat of formations and reaction overpotentials for a range of U = 0, 3, and 5 eV and α = 0, 0.15, 0.25, and 0.35 values investigated in this study, which we attribute primarily to changes in the oxidation state of B cations. If the valence of B cations in the perovskite and reference oxide is the same, then the U and α dependences are very small. However, if the valences are different then heat of formations can change by as much as 1 eV. As the oxidation state of a surface metal ion depends on adsorbed intermediate and nature of the element, similar differences in energies appear in the calculated reaction overpotentials for oxygen evolution. The large U and α dependences set serious constraints on the use of DFT+U and HSE methods for assessing stabilities and catalytic activities of perovskite oxides. In addition, the large α dependence raises the question whether HSE calculations can improve sufficiently the accuracy of DFT+U results for multistep electrochemical reactions to justify the excess computational cost. Although we have investigated only one particular class of catalysts and one electrochemical reaction, the results of this study can expectantly be generalized to other strongly correlated systems in which the oxidation state of the surface changes during reaction. The influence of U on the electronic conductivity is significant only in cases where it qualitatively changes the electronic structure, by, e.g., opening the band gap. From a combinatorial analysis on pure and doped La perovskites, we identify electronically conductive catalysts classified according to different electron conduction types: intrinsic conductivity (Fe4+, Co3+ (intermediate spin, IS), and Ni3+), electron polaron hopping (along Mn3+–O–Mn4+ chains), and charge transport through holes in the valence band.
BibTeX
@article{tripkovic2017comparative,
  author = {Vladimir Tripković and Heine Anton Hansen and J. M. García‐Lastra and Tejs Vegge},
  title = {{Comparative DFT+U and HSE Study of the Oxygen Evolution Electrocatalysis on Perovskite Oxides}},
  journal = {The Journal of Physical Chemistry C},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.1021/acs.jpcc.7b07660},
}
Figure