Comparative Chloroplast Genomics of Gossypium Species: Insights Into Repeat Sequence Variations and Phylogeny

Ying Wu, Fang Liu, Daigang Yang, Wei Li, Xiaojian Zhou, Xiaoyu Pei, Yangai Liu, Kunlun He, Wensheng Zhang, Zhongying Ren, Kehai Zhou, Xiongfeng Ma, Zhong‐Hu LiFrontiers in Plant Science 2018 · DOI

TL;DR

This study provides a comprehensive comparative analysis of chloroplast genomes from 40 Gossypium species, revealing insights into repeat sequence variations and their impact on phylogeny. The findings highlight the conserved nature of chloroplast genomes but also identify key divergence hotspots and regions under positive selection, offering valuable markers for future evolutionary studies and clarifying the complex phylogenetic relationships within the Gossypium genus.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Cotton (Gossypium species) is a globally significant crop, but its evolutionary history, particularly the relationships between its diverse diploid and allotetraploid species, remains complex and not fully understood. While previous studies have explored nuclear and some chloroplast DNA markers, a comprehensive understanding of chloroplast genome evolution, specifically focusing on the role of repeat sequences and their variations, and a robust phylogenetic framework for the entire genus were lacking. This paper aims to fill this gap by analyzing a broad range of Gossypium chloroplast genomes to elucidate the evolution of repeat sequences and refine the phylogenetic relationships within the genus.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-faceted approach:

  • Genome Sequencing and Assembly: They sequenced and assembled the chloroplast genomes of five newly identified diploid species and one semi-wild race of upland cotton. Standard next-generation sequencing (Illumina Hiseq 2500) and reference-guided assembly methods were used.
  • Repeat Sequence Analysis: They identified and characterized various types of repeat sequences, including tandem, dispersed, and palindromic repeats, as well as simple sequence repeats (SSRs). Tools like Tandem Repeats Finder, REPuter, and MISA were utilized.
  • Sequence Divergence Analysis: They compared chloroplast genome sequences from a representative set of species to identify regions of high variability (divergence hotspots) using mVISTA and calculated nucleotide variation percentages.
  • Protein Sequence Evolution Analysis: They investigated sites under positive selection in protein-coding genes using the Codeml program within the PAML package, employing site-specific models to assess selection pressure.
  • Phylogenetic Analysis: They reconstructed the evolutionary relationships of the Gossypium species using two datasets: complete chloroplast genomes and concatenated protein-coding genes. Maximum likelihood (ML) phylogenetic trees were generated using RAxML, with Hibiscus syriacus and Theobroma cacao as outgroups.

Datasets

The study utilized chloroplast genome data from 40 Gossypium species. This dataset included:

  • Five newly sequenced diploid species: G. nandewarense (C1-n), G. armourianum (D2-1), G. lobatum (D7), G. trilobum (D8), and G. schwendimanii (D11).
  • One semi-wild race of upland cotton: G. hirsutum race latifolium (AD1).
  • Previously published chloroplast genome sequences from other Gossypium species, representing a broad diversity across the genus.

No new benchmarks were introduced; rather, the study leveraged existing publicly available data and newly generated sequences to create the most comprehensive dataset for Gossypium chloroplast genomics to date.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Repeat sequences are abundant and conserved: The study found a significant number of repeat sequences across Gossypium chloroplast genomes, with dispersed repeats being the most common. These repeats, while varying in number between species (e.g., G. longicalyx F1 having the most, G. stocksii E1 the least), appear to play a role in enriching genetic information and maintaining genome stability.
  • Divergence hotspots offer valuable markers: The identification of 10 specific regions with high sequence divergence (e.g., rpl33-rps18, psbZ-trnG) is a crucial outcome. These hotspots are likely to be highly informative for future population genetics and phylogenetic studies, potentially serving as universal primers or DNA barcodes.
  • Positive selection shapes key genes: The analysis revealed that several chloroplast protein-coding genes, including those involved in ATP synthesis (atpB, atpE), photosynthesis (rbcL), and ribosomal function (rps2, rps3), show evidence of positive selection. This suggests that these genes have undergone adaptive evolution, potentially fine-tuning their function in response to environmental pressures or metabolic demands.
  • Complex phylogenetic relationships revealed: While the study largely confirmed previously identified major genetic clades (A+AD, F, E, D, B, and C+G+K), it also uncovered unexpected patterns. Notably, the D-genome species formed a strongly monophyletic group, but the C, G, and K-genome species were admixed, suggesting recent rapid radiation, incomplete lineage sorting, or introgression.

Key Results

  • Genome Structure: The chloroplast genomes of the studied Gossypium species were highly conserved in terms of size (159-161 kb), gene order, and GC content (37.1-37.4%).
  • Repeat Sequences: A total of 2860 long sequence repeats (>10 bp) were identified. G. longicalyx (F1) had the highest number of repeats (108), while G. stocksii (E1) had the lowest (53). Simple sequence repeats (SSRs) were also abundant, with mononucleotide repeats being the most common.
  • Divergence Hotspots: Ten divergence hotspot regions were identified, with non-coding regions showing significantly higher divergence (mean 15.1%) than coding regions (mean 2.5%).
  • Positive Selection: Ten chloroplast protein-coding genes were found to harbor sites under positive selection. Genes like atpB, atpE, rps2, and ycf1 showed multiple sites under selection.
  • Phylogeny: The phylogenetic analysis, based on complete chloroplast genomes, largely supported six previously identified genetic clades. All 13 D-genome species formed a strong monophyletic clade. However, species from the C, G, and K genomes were admixed, indicating complex evolutionary histories. The A+AD genome species showed close relationships, confirming the maternal donor role of A-genome species in allotetraploids.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Admixed C, G, K genomes: The admixed nature of the C, G, and K genomes is a significant finding that warrants further investigation. The authors suggest that recent rapid radiation, incomplete lineage sorting, and introgression hybridization are likely causes, and future studies could explore these mechanisms in more detail.
  • Inconsistencies with nuclear markers: The paper notes that chloroplast and nuclear gene markers sometimes yield differing phylogenetic relationships, particularly in certain clades. This discrepancy highlights the need for further exploration of the complex inheritance patterns and network of connections within the Gossypium genus.
  • SSR variability: While SSRs were identified as potentially useful molecular markers, the authors note that mononucleotide SSRs are prone to sequencing errors. Future work could focus on optimizing the use of polymorphic SSRs for population genetics and phylogeography.
  • Further exploration of repeat function: While the study identifies repeat sequences and their variations, their precise functional roles in genome evolution and stability could be further investigated.

The study's comprehensive dataset and detailed analyses provide a strong foundation for future research into Gossypium evolution, speciation, and the functional genomics of chloroplasts in this important crop genus.

Summary updated

Abstract

Cotton is one of the most economically important fiber crop plants worldwide. The genus <i>Gossypium</i> contains a single allotetraploid group (AD) and eight diploid genome groups (A-G and K). However, the evolution of repeat sequences in the chloroplast genomes and the phylogenetic relationships of <i>Gossypium</i> species are unclear. Thus, we determined the variations in the repeat sequences and the evolutionary relationships of 40 cotton chloroplast genomes, which represented the most diverse in the genus, including five newly sequenced diploid species, i.e., <i>G. nandewarense</i> (C<sub>1-n</sub>), <i>G. armourianum</i> (D<sub>2-1</sub>), <i>G. lobatum</i> (D<sub>7</sub>), <i>G. trilobum</i> (D<sub>8</sub>), and <i>G. schwendimanii</i> (D<sub>11</sub>), and an important semi-wild race of upland cotton, <i>G. hirsutum</i> race <i>latifolium</i> (AD<sub>1</sub>). The genome structure, gene order, and GC content of cotton species were similar to those of other higher plant plastid genomes. In total, 2860 long sequence repeats (>10 bp in length) were identified, where the F-genome species had the largest number of repeats (<i>G. longicalyx</i> F<sub>1</sub>: 108) and E-genome species had the lowest (<i>G. stocksii</i> E<sub>1</sub>: 53). Large-scale repeat sequences possibly enrich the genetic information and maintain genome stability in cotton species. We also identified 10 divergence hotspot regions, i.e., <i>rpl33-rps18, psbZ-trnG</i> (<i>GCC</i>), <i>rps4-trnT</i> (<i>UGU</i>), <i>trnL</i> (<i>UAG</i>)<i>-rpl32, trnE</i> (<i>UUC</i>)<i>-trnT</i> (<i>GGU</i>), <i>atpE, ndhI, rps2, ycf1</i>, and <i>ndhF</i>, which could be useful molecular genetic markers for future population genetics and phylogenetic studies. Site-specific selection analysis showed that some of the coding sites of 10 chloroplast genes (<i>atpB, atpE, rps2, rps3, petB, petD, ccsA, cemA, ycf1</i>, and <i>rbcL</i>) were under protein sequence evolution. Phylogenetic analysis based on the whole plastomes suggested that the <i>Gossypium</i> species grouped into six previously identified genetic clades. Interestingly, all 13 D-genome species clustered into a strong monophyletic clade. Unexpectedly, the cotton species with C, G, and K-genomes were admixed and nested in a large clade, which could have been due to their recent radiation, incomplete lineage sorting, and introgression hybridization among different cotton lineages. In conclusion, the results of this study provide new insights into the evolution of repeat sequences in chloroplast genomes and interspecific relationships in the genus <i>Gossypium</i>.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wu2018comparative,
  author = {Ying Wu and Fang Liu and Daigang Yang and Wei Li and Xiaojian Zhou and Xiaoyu Pei and Yangai Liu and Kunlun He and Wensheng Zhang and Zhongying Ren and Kehai Zhou and Xiongfeng Ma and Zhong‐Hu Li},
  title = {{Comparative Chloroplast Genomics of Gossypium Species: Insights Into Repeat Sequence Variations and Phylogeny}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Plant Science},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.3389/fpls.2018.00376},
}
Figure