Comparative Analysis of the Physical and Chemical Properties of Different Biomass Ashes Produced from Various Combustion Conditions

Xiwen Yao, Kaili Xu, Yu LiangBioResources 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how different biomass types and combustion temperatures affect the resulting ash properties, focusing on composition, mineral phases, and slagging tendencies. The findings reveal that higher temperatures increase slagging due to potassium chloride coating, while lower temperatures yield porous ashes suitable for adsorbents, offering insights into biomass ash valorization.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

As fossil fuels deplete and environmental concerns grow, biomass is gaining traction as a renewable energy source. However, the ash produced during biomass combustion presents challenges, particularly slagging and fouling in boilers, which can disrupt operations and reduce efficiency. Understanding the physical and chemical properties of biomass ash is crucial for optimizing combustion processes and exploring its potential for beneficial reuse. While research exists on coal ash, biomass ash, with its diverse compositions and volatile inorganic elements, remains less understood, especially concerning the combined effects of biomass species and ashing temperature on its characteristics and potential applications. This paper aims to bridge this knowledge gap by systematically analyzing ashes from different biomass sources under varying combustion conditions.

Methods

The researchers employed a comprehensive suite of analytical techniques to characterize the biomass ashes:

  • X-ray Fluorescence (XRF): Used to determine the elemental composition of the ashes.
  • X-ray Diffraction (XRD): Employed to identify the crystalline mineral phases present in the ashes.
  • Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM): Utilized to visualize the surface morphology and agglomeration characteristics of the ash particles.
  • Energy Dispersive X-ray (EDX): Coupled with SEM to analyze the elemental composition of specific surface areas, providing localized compositional data.
  • Thermogravimetric Analysis (TGA) and Differential Thermal Analysis (DTA): Performed simultaneously to study the thermal decomposition behavior, weight loss, and phase transitions of the ashes as a function of temperature.

These methods were applied to ashes produced from three common biomass types (rice straw, peanut shell, and corn cob) at different ashing temperatures (500, 600, and 815 °C).

Datasets

The study utilized three types of biomass as raw materials: rice straw, peanut shell, and corn cob. These were sourced from the peripheral rural area of Shenyang, Northeast China. The ashes were then generated under controlled laboratory conditions. No pre-existing benchmark datasets were used or introduced; the study generated its own experimental data.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Temperature is a double-edged sword for ash: While higher temperatures lead to more complete combustion and potentially lower ash yield, they also significantly increase the risk of slagging and agglomeration.
  • Potassium chloride is the culprit for slagging: The study identified potassium chloride (KCl) as a key component coating ash particles at higher temperatures, facilitating the formation of a sticky layer that causes severe agglomeration.
  • Low-temperature ashes are porous treasures: Ashes produced at lower temperatures (e.g., 600 °C) retain higher carbon content and exhibit a porous structure, making them promising candidates for low-cost adsorbents.
  • Biomass species matter, but temperature's impact is pronounced: While different biomass types yield ashes with distinct compositions, the effect of ashing temperature on properties like slagging tendency and volatile element content is a dominant factor.
  • Ash composition dictates potential applications: The presence of silica, alkali metals, and alkaline earth metals influences whether ash is suitable for glass production, soil amendment, or even as a component in cement.

Key Results

  • Ash Yield: Ash yield decreased with increasing ashing temperature for all biomass types. Ashes produced at 500 °C contained residual char, making them unsuitable for analysis, so 600 °C and 815 °C ashes were used.
  • Chemical Composition: SiO2 was predominant in most ashes. Potassium (K) and Sodium (Na) were present in large amounts, contributing to slagging. The proportions of K2O and Na2O, along with Chlorine (Cl), decreased with increasing ashing temperature due to volatilization. Conversely, CaO and MgO content increased at higher temperatures.
  • Mineral Phases: XRD analysis revealed variations in crystalline phases with temperature. For rice straw ash (RSA), arcanite, quartz, and sylvite were identified, with KCl decreasing at higher temperatures. Peanut shell ash (PSA) showed arcanite, plagioclase, kalicinite, and periclase, with calcite and fairchildite disappearing at 815 °C, and larnite emerging. Corn cob ash (CCA) contained kalicinite, potash, potassium aluminum silicates, sylvite, arcanite, and quartz, with CaO reacting with SiO2 at higher temperatures.
  • Morphology and Agglomeration: SEM images showed that higher ashing temperatures led to more severe agglomeration and compact ash particles, attributed to the melting of coating materials, primarily potassium chloride. Lower temperature ashes exhibited more irregular shapes and some unburnt carbon.
  • Thermal Decomposition: All ashes displayed stepwise decomposition mechanisms. Weight loss decreased with increasing ashing temperature, correlating with phase transitions and reaction sequences.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited Biomass Types: The study focused on only three common biomass types. Future research could expand to a wider range of biomass feedstocks to capture more diverse ash characteristics.
  • Slagging Mechanism Detail: While the role of KCl in slagging is highlighted, further detailed mechanistic studies could provide deeper insights into the precise interactions and formation pathways of slag.
  • Application Exploration: The paper suggests potential applications (adsorbents, glass production, soil amendments, cement additives), but these are largely based on compositional analysis. Experimental validation of these applications, including performance testing, is a crucial next step.
  • Clarification Potential: The authors note that the ashes were devoid of toxic metals, suggesting potential for industrial clarification, but this application remains unexplored and warrants further investigation.
  • Ash for Clarification: The potential of biomass ash for clarification in industries is mentioned as an area for future research, as it has not been explored.

Summary updated

Abstract

The ash yield, composition, mineral phases, and other physical and chemical properties of various biomass ashes are dependent on ashing temperature. To fully understand the impacts of biomass species and ashing temperature on the characterization of biomass ashes, three kinds of biomass fuels were treated at different ashing temperatures to produce biomass ashes. Their properties were analyzed by a series of qualitative and quantitative methods, including X-ray fluorescence (XRF), X-ray diffraction (XRD), scanning electron microscopy (SEM), energy dispersive X-ray (EDX), thermal gravimetric, and differential thermal analyzer (TG-DTA). The experimental results indicated that as the ashing temperature was raised, the ash slagging tendency could be enhanced. The fused layer on the surface of ash particles was coated with potassium chloride, which was the key reason for the development of severe agglomeration and slagging. Due to the high carbon content and large number of pores in the lower temperature ashes, a low-cost adsorbent could be developed effectively from these carbon materials. The thermal decomposition of all ashes showed a stepwise mechanism. The total weight loss of the same biomass ash decreased with increased ashing temperature, which corresponded well with the phase transitions and thermal reaction sequences.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{yao2017comparative,
  author = {Xiwen Yao and Kaili Xu and Yu Liang},
  title = {{Comparative Analysis of the Physical and Chemical Properties of Different Biomass Ashes Produced from Various Combustion Conditions}},
  booktitle = {BioResources},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.15376/biores.12.2.3222-3235},
}
Figure