TL;DR
This study compares the diagonal stride (DS) technique in cross-country skiing between roller skiing and on-snow skiing for young athletes. It finds that roller skiing is a good simulation of on-snow skiing for most kinematic aspects, but highlights specific differences in body and calf anteversion, and joint angles at critical moments, which coaches should consider when transferring training.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Cross-country (XC) skiing is a demanding endurance sport. To train during the off-season (May-October), athletes often use roller skiing as an on-snow equivalent. While roller skiing is a primary training method, it's crucial to understand how well it translates to actual on-snow performance. Previous research has explored differences in techniques like V2 skating, but a detailed kinematic comparison of the diagonal stride (DS) – a key technique for uphill ascents – between roller skiing and on-snow skiing, particularly in youth athletes, was lacking. This study aims to bridge that gap by quantifying similarities and differences in the DS technique across these two surfaces.
Methods
The researchers employed a motion capture system to analyze the DS technique of six young cross-country skiers. Two high-definition video cameras were used to record the skiers performing the DS on both asphalt roller skis and snow skis. A calibration space was set up to establish a 3D coordinate system. The FastMove 3D Motion software was used to digitize 21 critical body landmarks and pole tips, which were then used to calculate 3D coordinates.
Key kinematic variables analyzed included:
- Cycle Characteristics: Leg cycle time (LCT), leg frequency (LF), stance phase time (ST), swing phase time (SWT), pole cycle time (PCT), poling frequency (PF), poling time (PT), and recovery time (RT).
- Joint Kinematics: Angles for hip flexion-extension, hip adduction-abduction, knee flexion-extension, body anteversion, trunk anteversion, and calf anteversion (for the leg cycle), and shoulder flexion-extension, shoulder adduction-abduction, elbow flexion-extension, body anteversion, trunk anteversion, and pole inclination (for the pole cycle).
To quantify similarities between roller skiing and on-snow skiing, the Coefficient of Multiple Correlation (CMC) was used for angle-time curves. A CMC value of 0.75 or higher indicates high similarity. Statistical significance of differences in cycle characteristics and joint angles was assessed using the Wilcoxon signed rank test and one-dimensional statistical parametric mapping (SPM).
Datasets
This study utilized data collected from six male youth cross-country skiers. The data was collected in two distinct environments:
- Asphalt Roller Skiing: Conducted in May at the National Roller Skiing Base in Jingyuetan National Forest Park, Changchun City, Jilin Province, China, on a 7.6° uphill slope.
- On-Snow Skiing: Conducted in July in a ski tunnel at the Beishan Four Seasons XC Ski Resort in Jilin City, Jilin Province, China, on a 6.6° uphill slope.
The study did not introduce a new benchmark dataset but rather collected original kinematic data from participants.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Roller skiing is a strong proxy for on-snow DS: For the most part, the kinematic patterns of the diagonal stride are remarkably similar between roller skiing and on-snow skiing in youth athletes. This validates roller skiing as a valuable training tool.
- Hip adduction-abduction is a notable outlier: The hip adduction-abduction angle showed a lower degree of similarity, suggesting that hip movement might be one area where roller skiing doesn't perfectly replicate on-snow skiing.
- Body and calf anteversion differ: Significant differences were observed in body and calf anteversion angles, particularly at critical moments like ski/roller ski touchdown and take-off. This suggests that athletes might adjust their posture differently on the two surfaces.
- Equipment and friction matter: The authors hypothesize that differences in roller ski weight, flexibility, and significantly higher static friction compared to snow skis might influence body and calf anteversion. Athletes might adopt a more upright posture on roller skis to manage instability.
- Critical instants are key: Differences were most pronounced at specific points in the stride cycle (e.g., pole touchdown, ski touchdown). This highlights that while the overall trend is similar, the fine-tuning of movements at these critical junctures is where the surfaces diverge.
Key Results
- Cycle Characteristics: No significant differences were found in cycle characteristics (e.g., leg cycle time, pole cycle time) or maximum speed between roller skiing and on-snow skiing.
- Joint Kinematics (Angle-Time Curves):
- High Similarity (CMC > 0.75): Hip flexion-extension, calf anteversion (stance phase), hip and knee flexion-extension, and body anteversion (swing phase), shoulder flexion-extension, shoulder adduction-abduction, elbow flexion-extension, and body anteversion (pole cycle).
- Moderate Similarity (0.50 < CMC < 0.75): Hip adduction-abduction, knee flexion-extension, body anteversion, trunk anteversion (stance phase), trunk and calf anteversion (swing phase), and trunk anteversion (pole cycle).
- Low Similarity (CMC < 0.50): Hip adduction-abduction (swing phase).
- Joint Angles at Critical Instants:
- Knee Flexion: Significantly greater at roller ski touchdown than ski touchdown.
- Body and Calf Anteversion: Significantly greater at ski/roller ski touchdown and take-off on snow compared to roller skiing.
- Trunk Anteversion: Significantly greater at ski/roller ski take-off on snow.
- Pole Inclination: Significantly greater at pole touchdown on snow.
Limitations and Future Work
The authors acknowledge several limitations:
- Youth Athletes: The study focused on youth skiers whose techniques are still developing, meaning results might differ for elite adult athletes.
- Environmental Factors: Weather conditions, snow quality, ski wax, and detailed equipment specifications were not strictly controlled, which could influence results.
- Slope Incline: The slopes used for roller skiing (7.6°) and on-snow skiing (6.6°) were not identical, which can affect technique.
- Speed Control: Skiing speed was not strictly controlled, with participants performing the DS at maximum speed.
Future research could investigate these differences with elite athletes, under more controlled environmental conditions, and at standardized sub-maximum speeds to better understand the transferability of roller skiing training to on-snow performance. The authors also suggest that combining roller skiing with specific upper limb extensor muscle training might further enhance the transfer of technique.
Summary updated