COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF RESILIENT PRESTRESSED STEEL FRAMES

Y.x. Zhang, Qizheng Li, Kun Jiang, Yan Sun2018 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates the seismic performance of resilient prefabricated prestressed steel frames (RSF) and a novel variant incorporating intermediate columns with friction dampers (RSFFD). The RSFFD demonstrates superior seismic resilience by significantly reducing inter-story drift and residual deformations, making it a promising structural system for high seismic zones.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Traditional steel structures can suffer significant damage and residual deformations after seismic events, leading to costly repairs and extended downtime. Resilient prefabricated prestressed steel frames (RSF) have emerged as a solution, offering self-centering capabilities to minimize residual deformations and facilitate easier repair. However, for large-span structures in high seismic zones, further enhancements to lateral stiffness and energy dissipation are desirable. This paper addresses this need by proposing and analyzing a new RSF configuration that includes intermediate columns equipped with friction dampers (RSFFD), aiming to improve its overall seismic performance.

Methods

The study employs a combination of experimental testing and advanced numerical simulations. A pseudo-dynamic test of a 1-story, 0.75-scale experimental sub-structure of an RSF was conducted. Based on these experimental findings, finite element models of both the RSF and the proposed RSFFD were developed using ABAQUS software. These models were then subjected to dynamic time-history analysis under various magnitudes of the El-Centro ground motion. The analysis focused on comparing key performance indicators such as displacement response, inter-story drift, gap opening, residual rotation, hysteretic behavior, and plastic strain distribution.

Datasets

The study utilizes the El-Centro (E-W) earthquake ground motion records for its analysis. These records were scaled to different peak ground accelerations (PGA) corresponding to various seismic design codes (0.07g, 0.2g, 0.4g, and 0.51g), representing frequent, design, rare, and 8.5-degree rare earthquake scenarios as per the Chinese Code for Seismic Design of Buildings [10].

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Enhanced Stiffness and Drift Control: The addition of intermediate columns with friction dampers (RSFFD) significantly increases the lateral stiffness of the RSF, leading to a substantial reduction in inter-story drift, particularly under higher seismic intensities.
  • Improved Self-Centering and Resilience: The RSFFD exhibits a more favorable capacity for self-centering, evidenced by significantly smaller residual rotations compared to the standard RSF, indicating a greater ability to return to its original position after an earthquake.
  • Effective Energy Dissipation: The friction dampers in the intermediate columns, along with the web friction dampers in the RSF, contribute to enhanced energy dissipation capacity, especially under design and rare earthquakes. The RSFFD demonstrates a fuller hysteresis loop area, signifying better energy absorption.
  • Plasticity Mitigation: While the intermediate column might introduce some localized plasticity at the beam-intermediate column interface, the RSFFD effectively protects the main structural components (columns and beams) from developing significant plasticity, thereby reducing overall structural damage.

Key Results

  • Under a PGA of 0.07g, both RSF and RSFFD exhibit elastic behavior with minimal displacement.
  • At PGA=0.2g, the RSFFD shows a maximum displacement of 16.6mm and an inter-story drift of 1/549, well within the elastic limit (1/250), while the RSF's inter-story drift exceeds this limit.
  • For PGA=0.4g, the RSFFD's maximum displacement is 37.3mm with an inter-story drift of 1/61, compared to the RSF's 66.9mm displacement and 1/33 drift, which exceeds the elastic-plastic limit of 1/50.
  • At PGA=0.51g, the RSFFD's maximum displacement is 53.5mm with a drift of 1/44, while the RSF experiences 73.9mm displacement and 1/29 drift.
  • Residual rotations for the RSFFD are consistently lower than for the RSF across all tested PGA levels, with values of 0%rad, 0.03%rad, and 0.05%rad for PGA=0.2g, 0.4g, and 0.51g respectively, compared to the RSF's 0.03%rad, 0.11%rad, and 0.23%rad.
  • Plastic strain analysis shows that while the RSF develops significant plasticity at column bases and beam ends, the RSFFD largely confines plasticity to the beam-intermediate column interface, with minimal to no plasticity observed at column bases.

Limitations and Future Work

The paper notes that the intermediate column in the RSFFD can have a negative impact on the interface of the beam and the intermediate column, leading to some localized plasticity. However, this is outweighed by the protection offered to the main structural components. Future work could explore optimizing the design of the beam-intermediate column connection to further mitigate this localized plasticity. Additionally, further investigation into the long-term performance and cost-effectiveness of the RSFFD system would be beneficial.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@misc{zhang2018comparative,
  author = {Y.X. Zhang and Qizheng Li and Kun Jiang and Yan Sun},
  title = {{COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF RESILIENT PRESTRESSED STEEL FRAMES}},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.18057/icass2018.p.108},
}
Figure