TL;DR
This paper compares the economic feasibility of grid-connected versus off-grid renewable energy systems for two South Korean islands. The study finds that for these specific islands, a hybrid system combining wind, solar PV, batteries, and converters is the most optimal solution, with the specific configuration depending on the island's proximity to the mainland grid.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
South Korea, heavily reliant on imported fossil fuels, faces a critical need for stable and sustainable energy. This is particularly true for remote islands, which often struggle with inconsistent power supply. The challenge lies in identifying the most economically, technologically, and environmentally suitable energy grid solution for these areas. The paper aims to address this by comparing the viability of integrating with the existing national grid (on-grid) versus establishing independent renewable energy systems (off-grid) for two specific islands: Jindo-gun and Wando-gun.
Methods
The core of this research utilizes the Hybrid Optimization Model for Electric Renewables (HOMER) software. HOMER is a widely used simulation tool for designing and optimizing microgrids. The authors employed HOMER to:
- Simulate various hybrid energy system configurations: This included combinations of solar PV, wind turbines, batteries for energy storage, and converters for DC-AC power conversion.
- Analyze load profiles: Detailed daily and seasonal electricity consumption data for both islands were incorporated.
- Incorporate renewable energy resource data: Wind speed and solar radiation data were gathered for the specific island locations.
- Perform economic analysis: Key economic indicators such as Net Present Cost (NPC) and Cost of Electricity (COE) were calculated to compare the financial viability of different system designs.
- Conduct sensitivity analysis: While not extensively detailed for all parameters, the study mentions using sensitivity analysis to assess the impact of uncertainties in input values.
The study also assumed specific project durations (20 years), interest rates (1.16%), and costs for equipment installation, replacement, and operation and maintenance, drawing from existing literature and reports.
Datasets
The study used the following datasets:
- Jindo-gun Real Daily Demand List (2013): Provided by the Korea Electric Power Company (KEPCO) for load profile analysis.
- Wando-gun Real Daily Demand List (2013): Also provided by KEPCO for load profile analysis.
- Korea Meteorological Administration (KMA) data: Used for monthly average wind speed and solar radiation.
- NASA Surface Meteorology and Solar Energy data: Used for solar radiation and clearness index.
- Bank of Korea data: Used to determine the real annual interest rate.
- Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) reports: Used for initial cost estimates of PV arrays and other components.
No new benchmarks were introduced; rather, existing data and established models were utilized.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Hybrid systems are key for island electrification: The study strongly suggests that a combination of renewable energy sources (wind and solar PV) coupled with energy storage (batteries) and power conversion (converters) is the most effective approach for these islands.
- Proximity to the mainland matters significantly: The economic feasibility of an on-grid versus off-grid system is heavily influenced by the distance to the existing national grid. For islands within a certain distance, grid connection is more cost-effective.
- Off-grid is viable when grid extension is too costly: When the cost of extending the grid to an island exceeds the cost of establishing a self-sufficient renewable energy system, the off-grid approach becomes more attractive.
- Batteries are essential but costly: While batteries are crucial for ensuring a stable and reliable power supply from intermittent renewables, they represent a significant portion of the system's cost.
- No carbon emissions: The proposed hybrid systems generate electricity without emitting carbon dioxide, aligning with global sustainability goals.
Key Results
- Jindo-gun: The optimal system for Jindo-gun, assumed to be independent of the grid for the analysis, was a wind-PV-battery-converter hybrid system. This system was projected to produce 217,810 kWh/year from PV and 251,255 kWh/year from wind, consuming 275,469 kWh/year. The Net Present Cost (NPC) was $1,247,399, and the Cost of Electricity (COE) was $0.254/kWh. Solar contributed 46% and wind 54% of the power generation.
- Wando-gun: For Wando-gun, which is already connected to the power grid, the analysis indicated that a grid-connected system would be more economically feasible. However, if an independent system were to be considered, the optimal configuration was also a wind-PV-battery-converter hybrid system. This system was expected to produce 466,737 kWh/year from PV and 332,090 kWh/year from wind, consuming 505,499 kWh/year. The NPC was $2,224,835, and the COE was $0.247/kWh. Solar contributed 58% and wind 42% of the power generation.
- Cost Comparison: Figures 10 and 12 visually demonstrate the trade-off between grid extension costs and standalone system costs for Jindo-gun and Wando-gun, respectively, highlighting the distance thresholds where each becomes more economical.
Limitations and Future Work
The authors acknowledge several limitations:
- Land and Turbine Placement Costs: The cost of purchasing land and the specific placement of wind turbines, which can be affected by wind interference, were not considered in the analysis.
- Sensitivity Analysis Depth: While mentioned, the sensitivity analysis could have been more extensive to explore a wider range of uncertainties and input variations.
- Generalizability: The study's findings are specific to the two analyzed islands. Extending the analysis to other regions with similar characteristics would be valuable.
- HOMER Model Assumptions: While HOMER is a powerful tool, its modeling of wind power at one-hour intervals and the distinction between mandatory and secondary loads may introduce some uncertainties. There might be other optimal solutions not captured by the simulation.
Future work suggested includes:
- Varying Economic Values: Incorporating Renewable Portfolio Standards (RPS) and carbon emissions trading systems into economic evaluations.
- Learning Curves and Economies of Scale: Reflecting how technology costs decrease over time with increased adoption.
- Precise Land Cost Evaluation: Including the cost of land in future analyses.
- Multi-Methodology Research: Employing multiple research methodologies to strengthen the findings.
- Considering ESS Lifespan: The study used a conservative 15-year lifespan for Energy Storage Systems (ESS), while research suggests they can last longer, which could improve economic feasibility.
Summary updated