Comparative analysis of clonal evolution among patients with right-sided colon cancer, left-sided colon cancer and rectal cancer

Santasree Banerjee, Xianxiang Zhang, Shan Kuang, Jigang Wang, Lei Li, Guangyi Fan, Yonglun Luo, Shuai Sun, Peng Han, Qingyao Wu, Shujian Yang, Xiaobin Ji, Yong Li, Li Deng, Xiaofen Tian, Zhiwei Wang, Yue Zhang, Kui Wu, Shida Zhu, Lars Bolund, Huanming Yang, Xun Xu, Junnian Liu, Yun Lu, Xin LiubioRxiv 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This study provides a comprehensive, high-depth analysis of colorectal cancer (CRC) evolution across different tumor locations (right-sided colon, left-sided colon, and rectum). It reveals that left-sided colon and rectal cancers exhibit more complex evolutionary patterns than right-sided colon cancers, suggesting distinct evolutionary trajectories that could inform future diagnostics and therapeutics.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Colorectal cancer (CRC) is a major global health concern, but its complex nature, including intratumor heterogeneity (ITH) and clonal evolution, is not fully understood. While ITH is known to drive tumor progression and metastasis, large-scale, high-depth studies comparing the evolutionary dynamics across different anatomical locations of CRC (right-sided colon, left-sided colon, and rectum) have been scarce. Furthermore, the evolutionary relationship between primary tumors, lymph node metastases (LN), and extranodal tumor deposits (ENTD) remains unclear. This paper aims to fill these knowledge gaps by providing a detailed comparative analysis of clonal evolution in these distinct CRC subtypes and investigating the evolutionary origins of metastatic spread.

Methods

The researchers employed high-depth whole exome sequencing (WES) on 206 tumor regions from 68 CRC patients, including primary tumors, lymph nodes (LN), and extranodal tumor deposits (ENTD). This approach allowed for the detection of both clonal and subclonal mutations, providing a detailed view of ITH. They utilized phylogenetic tree construction to visualize the evolutionary relationships between different tumor regions and metastatic sites. Additionally, they analyzed somatic copy number alterations (SCNAs) and identified driver mutations to understand the genomic events driving tumor evolution. The study also employed statistical analyses to compare evolutionary patterns across different CRC locations.

Datasets

The study utilized data from 68 CRC patients, comprising 18 with right-sided colon cancer (RCC), 20 with left-sided colon cancer (LCC), and 30 with rectal cancer (RC). A total of 206 tumor regions were sequenced, including 176 primary tumor regions, 19 LN regions, and 11 ENTD regions. Matched germline samples from these patients were also analyzed. The sequencing data has been deposited at the CNGB Nucleotide Sequence Archive (CNSA) under accession number CNP0000594.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Location Matters: The anatomical location of CRC significantly influences its evolutionary trajectory. LCC and RC exhibit more complex and divergent evolutionary patterns compared to RCC.
  • Darwinian Evolution Dominates: The study predominantly observed a Darwinian pattern of evolution, characterized by natural selection favoring advantageous mutations, across all CRC subtypes.
  • ENTD as a Distinct Entity: Extranodal tumor deposits (ENTD) are not simply extensions of lymph node metastases but represent a distinct evolutionary event that occurs later in the process.
  • Polyclonal Origin of Metastases: Both lymph node metastases (LN) and extranodal tumor deposits (ENTD) arise from multiple distinct clones, highlighting the complexity of metastatic spread.
  • SCNA Patterns as Biomarkers: The frequency patterns of SCNA in different CRC locations show distinct characteristics, suggesting their potential as biomarkers to differentiate between RCC and LCC/RC.

Key Results

  • The study identified intratumor heterogeneity (ITH) in all CRC patients, consistent with a Darwinian pattern of evolution.
  • LCC and RC patients showed more complex and divergent evolutionary patterns than RCC patients, indicating greater evolutionary diversity in their initiation and progression.
  • Genetic and evolutionary evidence indicated that both LN and ENTD were of polyclonal origin.
  • ENTD was identified as a distinct entity from LN and evolved later in the tumor's evolutionary history.
  • RCC patients had significantly more clonal mutations than RC patients, suggesting higher ITH at the mutational level in RC.
  • The SCNA frequency patterns in RCC were distinct from those in LCC and RC, potentially serving as a biomarker.
  • Phylogenetic trees for LCC and RC patients were more complex and branched than those for RCC patients, with LCC patients exhibiting the most intricate structures.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that while their study provides a comprehensive analysis, further research is needed to fully elucidate the mechanisms driving the observed evolutionary differences between CRC subtypes. Future work could focus on integrating multi-omics data (e.g., transcriptomics, epigenomics) with the genomic data presented here to gain a more holistic understanding of CRC evolution. Investigating the functional consequences of these evolutionary differences in more detail, particularly in relation to treatment response and patient outcomes, would also be a valuable next step. The potential of SCNA frequency patterns as biomarkers for distinguishing CRC subtypes warrants further validation in larger cohorts.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Background Tumor multi-region sequencing reveals intratumor heterogeneity (ITH) and clonal evolution which play a key role in progression and metastases of the tumor. However, large-scale high depths multiregional sequencing of colorectal cancer (CRC) has not been well studied. In addition, the comparative analysis among right-sided colon cancer (RCC), left-sided colon cancer (LCC) and rectal cancer (RC) patients as well as the study of lymph node metastasis (LN) with extranodal tumor deposits (ENTD) from evolutionary perspective remain unknown. Results In this prospective study, we recruited different stages of 68 CRC patients with RCC (18), LCC (20) and RC (30). We performed high-depth whole exome sequencing (WES) of 206 tumor regions including 176 primary tumors, 19 LN and 11 ENTD samples. Our results showed ITH with a Darwinian pattern of evolution. We identified that the evolution pattern of LCC and RC was more complex and divergent than RCC, suggesting the evolutionary diversity in the initiation and progression of LCC and RC. Genetic and evolutionary evidences found that both LN and ENTD were of polyclonal in origin. Moreover, ENTD was a distinct entity from LN and evolved later. Conclusions In conclusion, our study showed the Darwinian pattern of evolution with differences in clonal evolution between RCC with LCC and RC.
BibTeX
@misc{banerjee2020comparative,
  author = {Santasree Banerjee and Xianxiang Zhang and Shan Kuang and Jigang Wang and Lei Li and Guangyi Fan and Yonglun Luo and Shuai Sun and Peng Han and Qingyao Wu and Shujian Yang and Xiaobin Ji and Yong Li and Li Deng and Xiaofen Tian and Zhiwei Wang and Yue Zhang and Kui Wu and Shida Zhu and Lars Bolund and Huanming Yang and Xun Xu and Junnian Liu and Yun Lu and Xin Liu},
  title = {{Comparative analysis of clonal evolution among patients with right-sided colon cancer, left-sided colon cancer and rectal cancer}},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1101/2020.07.01.181586},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure