Comparative Analysis of Artemisia Plastomes, with Implications for Revealing Phylogenetic Incongruence and Evidence of Hybridization

Xinqiang Guo, Yonghe Bai, Jing Ruan, Xin Jin, Shang Wang, Dawei Xue, Yuhuan WuGenes 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This study leverages genome skimming to analyze the plastomes of Artemisia, a diverse genus of medicinal plants. By comparing plastid and nuclear DNA phylogenies, the researchers found evidence of hybridization and non-monophyletic subgenera, suggesting a complex evolutionary history for Artemisia.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The Artemisia genus, known for its medicinal properties (like artemisinin from A. annua) and ecological importance, is taxonomically challenging. Previous attempts to resolve its evolutionary relationships have been hampered by complex evolutionary processes such as hybridization and incomplete lineage sorting. While traditional classifications exist, molecular studies have often shown these groupings to be artificial. Furthermore, a comprehensive comparative analysis of Artemisia plastomes and their phylogenetic implications, particularly concerning evidence of hybridization, has been lacking. This paper aims to address these issues by providing a detailed plastome analysis and comparing it with nuclear DNA phylogenies to shed light on the genus's evolutionary history.

Methods

The researchers employed genome skimming, a cost-effective next-generation sequencing technique, to obtain plastome data from 19 Artemisia samples. These newly generated plastomes, along with publicly available data, were then subjected to comparative analyses of their structure, GC content, and gene order. To reconstruct phylogenetic relationships, they used two main datasets:

  1. Concatenated protein-coding sequences (CDS) from the plastomes.
  2. Nuclear Internal Transcribed Spacer (ITS) sequences.

Phylogenetic trees were built using both Maximum Likelihood (ML) and Bayesian Inference (BI) methods. The study also identified variable regions within the plastomes that could serve as potential DNA barcodes and analyzed Simple Sequence Repeats (SSRs) for population genetics applications. A key aspect of their approach was the direct comparison of the resulting plastid and nuclear phylogenies to detect cytonuclear incongruence, a strong indicator of hybridization.

Datasets

The study utilized two primary sources of data:

  1. Newly sequenced data: 19 Artemisia plastomes from nine species and three varieties, collected from various provinces in China.
  2. Publicly available data: 92 published Artemisia plastomes and three Ajania plastomes were downloaded from NCBI. Additionally, 83 samples for the nuclear ITS dataset were used, with 21 of these being newly generated.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Plastome Conservatism: Despite the genus's complexity, Artemisia plastomes exhibit remarkable structural conservation in terms of size, GC content, gene number, and order. This stability is crucial for their function and likely contributes to their utility in phylogenetic studies.
  • Variable Regions for Barcoding: Certain plastome regions, like accD, ccsA, ndhE, ycf1, ccsA-ndhD, and trnG<sup>GCC</sup>-trnfM<sup>CAU</sup>, showed higher variability. These are identified as promising candidates for DNA barcoding to aid in species identification and delimitation, which is particularly important for this taxonomically difficult genus.
  • Non-Monophyletic Subgenera: The phylogenetic analyses strongly confirmed that the traditional four subgenera of Artemisia are not monophyletic. This suggests that the current classification based on morphological traits does not accurately reflect the evolutionary history of the genus.
  • Evidence of Hybridization: A significant finding is the incongruence between the plastid and nuclear phylogenies. This cytonuclear discordance is a strong signal that hybridization events have played a substantial role in shaping the evolutionary trajectory of Artemisia.

Key Results

  • Plastome Structure: All 19 newly sequenced Artemisia plastomes were typically quadripartite, with lengths ranging from 150,654 bp to 151,125 bp. GC content was consistently around 37.4-37.5%. A total of 132 genes were identified (87 protein-coding, 37 tRNA, 8 rRNA) with no gene rearrangements or inversions observed.
  • Sequence Divergence: Nucleotide diversity (π) values ranged from 0 to 0.0063 in CDSs and 0 to 0.01645 in intergenic regions (IGRs). IGRs exhibited higher variability, with specific genes (accD, ccsA, ndhE, petG, rpl22, ycf1) and IGRs (ccsA-ndhD, trnG<sup>GCC</sup>-trnfM<sup>CAU</sup>, etc.) identified as highly divergent and suitable for phylogenetic analysis.
  • SSRs: A total of 4341 SSRs were found across 75 plastomes, with mononucleotide repeats being the most frequent. A. absinthium had the highest number of SSRs (75), while A. stolonifera had the fewest (45).
  • Phylogenetic Incongruence: Both plastid (CDS) and nuclear (ITS) phylogenies revealed that the traditional subgenera are not monophyletic. Notably, the basal diverging clades differed significantly between the two datasets, providing clear evidence of cytonuclear discordance.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that while their study significantly advances the understanding of Artemisia phylogeny, the sample size, though improved, is still not exhaustive given the large size of the genus. They also note that ITS, while useful, can be subject to concerted evolution, making it less ideal for definitively resolving hybridization events.

Future work should focus on:

  • Sequencing and analyzing more Artemisia taxa to further clarify the evolutionary history.
  • Employing single- or low-copy nuclear genes (SLCN genes), which exhibit biparental inheritance and lack significant concerted evolution, to more robustly investigate hybridization events.
  • Integrating additional evidence, such as cytology and morphology, to provide a more comprehensive re-classification of the genus.
  • Further investigating the roles of hybridization/introgression and incomplete lineage sorting, which are suggested as major drivers of diversification in Artemisia.

Summary updated

Abstract

<b>Background</b>: With the advancement of the next-generation sequencing technology, it is becoming more cost-effective to obtain plastomes from genome skimming data at shallow sequencing depth. <i>Artemisia</i> is a species-rich genus, comprising species of great medicinal or economic value. However, plastomes of <i>Artemisia</i> have not been thoroughly and comparatively analyzed, and the phylogenetic relationships within the genus are still not well resolved. <b>Methods</b>: In this study, 19 <i>Artemisia</i> plastomes were obtained from genome skimming data. Together with the plastomes retrieved from the public database, comparative analyses of their structure were also conducted. We further used sequences of plastomes and nuclear internal transcribed spacer sequences to conduct phylogenetic reconstruction. <b>Results</b>: The <i>Artemisia</i> plastomes are conserved in terms of structure, GC content, gene number, and order. Some regions, i.e., <i>accD</i>, <i>ccsA</i>, <i>ndhE</i>, <i>ycf1</i>, <i>ccsA-ndhD</i>, <i>trnG<sup>GCC</sup>-trnfM<sup>CAU</sup></i>, were found to be variable and could be chosen as candidates for the DNA barcode. Phylogenetic analyses also confirmed that the four subgenera of <i>Artemisia</i> are not monophyletic. The incongruence between plastid and nuclear phylogenies indicated that hybridization events have occurred during the evolution of the genus. <b>Conclusions</b>: Reconstructed phylogenies using plastome sequences and nuclear internal transcribed spacers improved our understanding of the phylogenetic backbone of <i>Artemisia</i>. In the future, more taxa of <i>Artemisia</i> should be sequenced and analyzed to clarify the evolutionary history.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{guo2025comparative,
  author = {Xinqiang Guo and Yonghe Bai and Jing Ruan and Xin Jin and Shang Wang and Dawei Xue and Yuhuan Wu},
  title = {{Comparative Analysis of Artemisia Plastomes, with Implications for Revealing Phylogenetic Incongruence and Evidence of Hybridization}},
  booktitle = {Genes},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.3390/genes16101145},
}
Figure