Comparative Analysis of Absorption Resonances between Carbynes and Cyclo[n]carbons

Renebeth B. Payod, Aliaxandr Pushkarchuk, Dominik L. Michels, Dmitry Lyakhov, Vasil A. SarokaResearch Square 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper explores the optical "fingerprints" of two elusive carbon allotropes: linear carbynes and cyclic cyclo[n]carbons. By combining analytical tight-binding models with numerical TD-DFT simulations, the researchers identified a structural rule ($N_{ring} = 2N_{chain} + 2$) for matching energy levels between rings and chains, while discovering that allowed molecular transitions in both structures are driven by a specific symmetry flip from inversion to reflection.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Carbon is famous for its diverse forms, from 3D diamonds to 2D graphene. However, 1D carbon allotropes—linear chains (carbynes) and atomic rings (cyclo[n]carbons)—remain the "holy grail" of carbon science due to their extreme instability and high reactivity.

Because these materials are so difficult to synthesize in a pristine state, researchers rely heavily on spectroscopy to identify them. The challenge is that we lack a clear understanding of how the optical absorption resonances of a linear chain relate to those of a ring. If we can find a mathematical or physical "bridge" between these two geometries, we can better characterize new synthetic carbon structures used in future nanoelectronics.

Methods

The authors employed a dual-methodology approach to bridge the gap between theory and simulation:

  1. Analytical Tight-Binding (TB) Model: Used to derive optical selection rules for cumulenic structures (consecutive double bonds, $=C=C=$). This model provided the mathematical foundation for the $2N+2$ rule.
  2. Time-Dependent Density Functional Theory (TD-DFT): A more complex numerical approach used to investigate polyynic structures (alternating single and triple bonds, $-C \equiv C-$). Unlike the TB model, TD-DFT accounts for many-body effects, atomization energies, and charge transfer excitations.
  3. Symmetry Analysis: The team analyzed the molecular orbital (MO) wave functions to determine why certain transitions are "allowed" (visible in a spectrum) while others are "forbidden."

Datasets

This study does not use traditional large-scale datasets. Instead, it generates high-precision computational data using:

  • Gaussian 09: For geometry optimization and TD-DFT calculations.
  • Experimental Benchmarks: The results for carbyne $N=8$ were compared against existing experimental data for the polyyne $HC_8H$ in the gas phase to validate the model's accuracy.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The $2N+2$ Rule: The most striking theoretical finding is that an atomic ring with $N$ atoms will have an energy level structure matching a finite chain if the ring has exactly twice the atoms of the chain plus two extra ($N_{ring} = 2N_{chain} + 2$). For example, a 16-atom ring matches the energy levels of a 7-atom chain.
  • Symmetry is the Gatekeeper: For both chains and rings, optical transitions aren't just about energy; they are about a "symmetry flip." The researchers found that allowed transitions occur when the wave function changes from inversion symmetry (centered at the midpoint) to reflection symmetry (mirrored across a plane), or vice versa.
  • Energy $\neq$ Absorption: While the $2N+2$ rule works perfectly for matching eigenenergies in simple models, the TD-DFT results showed that it doesn't guarantee matching absorption peaks in polyynic structures. Many-body effects and bond-length alternations cause the actual resonance peaks to shift significantly between the ring and its "matching" chain.

Key Results

  • Cyclo[18]carbon: The resonance peak for this recently synthesized ring was found at 2.44 eV, placing it in the visible light spectrum.
  • Carbyne Comparison: The "matching" carbynes ($N=7$ and $N=8$) showed peaks at 5.51 eV and 5.92 eV, respectively. These are in the ultraviolet (UV) range, meaning that despite having related energy levels, the ring and chain "look" very different to a spectrometer.
  • Validation: The calculated peak for carbyne $N=8$ (5.9164 eV) showed excellent agreement with experimental gas-phase data for $HC_8H$ (~5.904 eV), proving the simulation's reliability.
  • Isotropy vs. Anisotropy: Linear carbynes show strong polarization (they absorb light differently depending on the light's orientation to the chain), whereas cyclo[18]carbon is isotropic (it reacts to light the same way from any in-plane angle).

Limitations and Future Work

The primary limitation is the mismatch between the analytical TB model (which predicts a resonance match) and the numerical TD-DFT results (which show a peak shift). This suggests that while the $2N+2$ rule is a great starting point for understanding energy levels, it is too simple to predict the full optical behavior of real-world polyynic carbon.

Future research could look into how these optical properties change when carbynes are encapsulated inside carbon nanotubes or when the rings are placed on different substrates, which are common environments for experimental study. Exploring the "twins problem"—where different allotropes produce nearly identical signals—also remains a high priority for the field.

Summary updated

Abstract

<title>Abstract</title> We present here two approaches to analyze the absorption resonances between carbynes and cyclo[n]carbons, namely the analytical tight-binding model to calculate the optical selection rules of cumulenic atomic rings and chains and the numerical time-dependent density functional theory for the optical investigation of polyynic carbon ring and chains. The optical absorption spectra of the carbon ring match that of the finite chain when their eigenenergies align following the Nring = 2Nchain+2 rule, which states that the number of atoms in an atomic ring Nring is twice the number of atoms on a finite chain Nchain with two additional atoms. We chose two representative atomic chains for our numerical calculations, specifically carbynes with N = 7 and 8 carbon atoms as a possible optical resonance spectra match to a recently synthesized carbon ring called cyclo[18]carbon. Despite the mismatch in resonance peaks, molecular orbital transitions of both carbynes N = 7 and 8 and cyclo[18]carbon reveal a wave function symmetry change from inversion to reflection and vice versa for allowed molecular orbital transitions which results in electron density redistribution along the polyynic carbyne axis or the cyclo[18]carbon circumference.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{payod2023comparative,
  author = {Renebeth B. Payod and Aliaxandr Pushkarchuk and Dominik L. Michels and Dmitry Lyakhov and Vasil A. Saroka},
  title = {{Comparative Analysis of Absorption Resonances between Carbynes and Cyclo[n]carbons}},
  booktitle = {Research Square},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.21203/rs.3.rs-3631466/v1},
}

Loading related content...

Figure