Comparative Analyses of Chloroplast Genome Provide Effective Molecular Markers for Species and Cultivar Identification in Bougainvillea

Xinggu Lin, Shiou Yih Lee, Jianzhong Ni, Xiaomin Zhang, Xing Hu, Peishan Zou, Wei Wang, Guofeng LiuInternational Journal of Molecular Sciences 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This study addresses the confusion surrounding Bougainvillea species and cultivar identification by sequencing and analyzing the complete chloroplast (cp) genome of B. spectabilis 'Splendens'. By comparing this with other Bougainvillea cp genomes, researchers identified key variable regions and developed five molecular markers that can effectively distinguish species and cultivars, aiding in breeding and genetic resource management.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Bougainvillea is a highly popular ornamental plant, prized for its vibrant bracts and adaptability. However, the complex genetic relationships within the genus are poorly understood, leading to significant confusion in species and cultivar identification. This ambiguity stems from limited genomic data and the plant's propensity for hybridization and spontaneous mutations, which generate numerous cultivars with often overlapping or misattributed names. Existing molecular markers have shown limitations in resolving these relationships, necessitating the development of more robust and informative tools for accurate classification and breeding efforts.

Methods

The core of this research involved sequencing and assembling the complete chloroplast (cp) genome of Bougainvillea spectabilis 'Splendens' using next-generation sequencing. Following assembly and annotation, the researchers performed comparative genomic analyses across 12 Bougainvillea species. This involved aligning the cp genomes to identify conserved regions and pinpoint areas of divergence, particularly focusing on intergenic spacer regions and protein-coding genes known for variability. They utilized tools like mVISTA for sequence identity comparison and sliding window analysis to calculate nucleotide diversity (Pi) and identify "mutational hotspots." Based on these identified hypervariable regions and other conserved plastid regions, five molecular markers were developed. These markers were then applied to classify 53 ornamental Bougainvillea cultivars through phylogenetic analysis, constructing Maximum Likelihood (ML) trees to visualize the genetic relationships.

Datasets

The primary dataset used was the newly sequenced complete chloroplast genome of Bougainvillea spectabilis 'Splendens' (accession number OR253994). This was compared with 12 previously published Bougainvillea cp genomes obtained from the NCBI GenBank database (listed in Table S2). For phylogenetic analysis of cultivars, data from 53 Bougainvillea cultivars were used, alongside the 12 species genomes. Two closely related Nyctaginaceae species (Nyctaginia capitate and Mirabilis jalapa) were included as outgroups in the phylogenetic analysis.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Cp Genome as a Powerful Discriminator: The study highlights the chloroplast genome as a rich source of genetic information for resolving complex phylogenetic relationships, even at the species and cultivar levels within a genus like Bougainvillea.
  • Identification of Key Variable Regions: The research successfully pinpointed five specific regions within the cp genome (rps16-trnQ, psbl-trnG, petA-psbJ, ndhF-rpl32, and ycf1) that exhibit significant variability and are thus ideal for developing molecular markers.
  • Controversial Phylogenetic Relationships: The study revealed unexpected phylogenetic placements, particularly regarding the relationship between B. spectabilis and B. glabra, suggesting potential inaccuracies in previous classifications or the need for more refined markers. The placement of B. spectabilis 'Splendens' also differed from expectations.
  • Development of Practical Molecular Markers: The creation of five molecular markers from these variable regions offers a tangible tool for accurate species and cultivar identification, addressing a critical need in the horticultural industry.
  • Cultivar Origin Insights: The phylogenetic analysis of cultivars provided valuable insights into their likely origins, often confirming or challenging existing records and suggesting a significant number of misattributed cultivars.

Key Results

  • The complete chloroplast genome of B. spectabilis 'Splendens' was assembled and annotated, measuring 154,869 bp and containing 131 predicted genes.
  • Comparative analysis of 13 Bougainvillea cp genomes identified five significant mutational hotspots, with the intergenic region psbl-trnG showing the highest nucleotide diversity (Pi = 0.035).
  • Five molecular markers were developed and successfully applied to classify 53 ornamental Bougainvillea cultivars, demonstrating their effectiveness in distinguishing genetic affiliations.
  • Phylogenetic analysis revealed distinct clades and subclades, with B. spectabilis 'Splendens' clustering with B. praecox, and B. spectabilis (previously published) and B. glabra forming a separate, closely related group.
  • The study suggests that many Bougainvillea cultivars are derived from three main ornamental species: B. glabra, B. spectabilis, and B. peruviana.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that while the developed markers are effective, some cultivar identifications remain controversial or require further exploration. They suggest that the previously published cp genome of B. spectabilis might contain sampling errors, contributing to the unexpected phylogenetic placements. Future work could focus on expanding the marker set, investigating the genetic basis of cross-incompatibility, and further refining the classification of cultivars where origins are still ambiguous. The establishment of a comprehensive cp genome database for Bougainvillea is also proposed as a valuable resource for future research and breeding.

Summary updated

Abstract

<i>Bougainvillea</i> is popular in ornamental horticulture for its colorful bracts and excellent adaptability, but the complex genetic relationship among this genus is fuzzy due to limited genomic data. To reveal more genomic resources of <i>Bougainvillea</i>, we sequenced and assembled the complete chloroplast (cp) genome sequences of <i>Bougainvillea spectabilis</i> 'Splendens'. The cp genome size was 154,869 bp in length, containing 86 protein-coding genes, 38 tRNAs, and eight rRNAs. Cp genome comparison across 12 <i>Bougainvillea</i> species (<i>B. spectabilis</i>, <i>B. glabra</i>, <i>B. peruviana</i>, <i>B. arborea</i>, <i>B. praecox</i>, <i>B. stipitata</i>, <i>B. campanulata</i>, <i>B. berberidifolia</i>, <i>B. infesta</i>, <i>B. modesta</i>, <i>B. spinosa</i>, and <i>B. pachyphylla</i>) revealed five mutational hotspots. Phylogenetic analysis suggested that <i>B. spectabilis</i> published previously and <i>B. glabra</i> clustered into one subclade as two distinct groups, sister to the subclade of <i>B. spectabilis</i> 'Splendens'. We considered the phylogeny relationships between <i>B. spectabilis</i> and <i>B. glabra</i> to be controversial. Based on two hypervariable regions and three common plastid regions, we developed five molecular markers for species identification in <i>Bougainvillea</i> and applied them to classify 53 ornamental <i>Bougainvillea</i> cultivars. This study provides a valuable genetic resource for <i>Bougainvillea</i> breeding and offers effective molecular markers to distinguish the representative ornamental species of <i>Bougainvillea</i>.
BibTeX
@article{lin2023comparative,
  author = {Xinggu Lin and Shiou Yih Lee and Jianzhong Ni and Xiaomin Zhang and Xing Hu and Peishan Zou and Wei Wang and Guofeng Liu},
  title = {{Comparative Analyses of Chloroplast Genome Provide Effective Molecular Markers for Species and Cultivar Identification in Bougainvillea}},
  journal = {International Journal of Molecular Sciences},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/ijms242015138},
}
Figure