TL;DR
This paper investigates the possibility of constructing realistic cosmological models within string/M-theory by compactifying extra dimensions onto negatively curved manifolds. The authors demonstrate that such compactifications, when aiming for maximally symmetric spacetimes (like de Sitter or anti-de Sitter), are severely constrained. They must inevitably involve significant warping of spacetime or substantial stringy corrections to avoid contradictions with fundamental energy conditions.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
The quest for a unified theory of fundamental forces, such as string/M-theory, often involves compactifying extra spatial dimensions to match our observed four-dimensional universe. A key challenge is to find compactification manifolds that lead to realistic four-dimensional spacetimes, particularly those with positive cosmological constant (de Sitter space), which is crucial for explaining cosmic acceleration. While positively or zero-curved manifolds have yielded many solutions, negatively curved manifolds have been less explored for this purpose. This paper addresses the question of whether negatively curved internal manifolds can be used to construct viable string/M-theory compactifications to maximally symmetric spacetimes, and what the implications are for such constructions.
Methods
The authors employ a "no-go" argument based on the Einstein equations in ten dimensions. They analyze the trace of the Einstein equations, relating the scalar curvature of the internal manifold ($R_6$) to the stress-energy tensor of matter and fields. The core of their argument relies on the "strong energy condition," which states that the right-hand side of the relevant equations must be non-positive for standard matter fields. They then explore how various components of string/M-theory, including fluxes, localized sources (branes and orientifolds), warp factors, and stringy corrections, affect this condition. They also consider the implications of "internal energy conditions" which are weaker than the strong energy condition.
Datasets
Not discussed in the paper.
Key Insights and Ideas
- The "No-Go" for Simple Negatively Curved Compactifications: The paper establishes a fundamental constraint: compactifying on a negatively curved manifold to a maximally symmetric spacetime (like de Sitter or anti-de Sitter) is impossible without additional physics, due to the violation of energy conditions.
- Warping and Stringy Corrections as Saviors: The authors identify spacetime warping (a non-constant metric in the extra dimensions) and higher-derivative stringy corrections as the primary mechanisms that can circumvent this "no-go" theorem. These effects can introduce terms that counteract the problematic negative curvature.
- Localized Sources vs. Global Curvature: While localized sources like branes and orientifolds can contribute negative energy, their effects are confined to specific regions. The "no-go" argument applies to the entire internal manifold, meaning these localized effects alone cannot resolve the global curvature issue.
- The Role of the Conformal Factor: The conformal factor of the internal metric can locally modify the scalar curvature, but its integrated effect tends to increase the total scalar curvature, potentially favoring de Sitter.
- Implications for de Sitter Vacua: The paper suggests that achieving de Sitter solutions, which are desirable for cosmology, might require a delicate balance between negative internal curvature and positive contributions from warping or stringy effects.
Key Results
The paper derives several key equations, including:
- The relation between the four-dimensional curvature scalar ($R_4$) and the six-dimensional curvature scalar ($R_6$) and the four-dimensional energy-momentum tensor trace ($T_4$): $R_4 = -T_4 - 2R_6$. This highlights how a negative $R_6$ could potentially lead to a positive $R_4$ (de Sitter).
- A generalized inequality for $k$-dimensional curvature ($R_k$) and stress-energy ($T_k, T_d$): $0 \le R_k \le \frac{d-2}{d+k-2} T_k - \frac{k}{d+k-2} T_d$. This inequality is shown to be violated by negatively curved manifolds under standard assumptions.
- The paper demonstrates that warping and conformal factors can introduce terms that can be negative, potentially allowing for solutions that would otherwise be forbidden.
Limitations and Future Work
The authors acknowledge that their analysis is primarily within the supergravity approximation. They note that for a complete understanding, especially concerning the behavior near localized sources like branes and orientifolds, one must go beyond supergravity and consider full string theory descriptions. They also point out that while their arguments suggest that warping and stringy corrections can circumvent the "no-go" theorem, finding explicit, realistic solutions remains a significant challenge. Future work should focus on finding such explicit higher-dimensional solutions and exploring the implications for constructing de Sitter cosmologies. The paper also mentions that the "no-go" theorem might be circumvented by incorporating additional stringy effects in the potential, but this requires careful consideration of potential pitfalls like tachyonic fields or broken symmetries.
Summary updated