Communicating cosmology with multisensory metaphorical experiences

Roberto Trotta, Daniel Hajas, José Eliel Camargo-Molina, Robert Cobden, Emanuela Maggioni, Marianna ObristJournal of Science Communication 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel, multisensory approach to communicating abstract scientific concepts, specifically dark matter, by creating immersive, metaphorical experiences. By combining haptic, olfactory, auditory, and gustatory stimuli within a planetarium setting, the researchers aim to make complex physics more accessible and engaging for a general audience, particularly those who might be excluded by traditional, visually-dominated methods.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Communicating complex scientific concepts, especially in fields like cosmology and astrophysics, presents a significant challenge. These subjects often deal with abstract ideas and phenomena that are far removed from everyday human experience, requiring high levels of mathematical and technical understanding. This creates a barrier to public engagement, particularly for non-expert audiences. Traditional methods like lectures and visual aids can oversimplify or fail to convey the true wonder and complexity of these topics. The paper specifically targets the challenge of making "dark matter" – a fundamental component of the universe that is invisible and its nature unknown – comprehensible and relatable to the public.

Methods

The core of this research lies in the co-creation of a multisensory, metaphorical experience. Physicists and Human-Computer Interaction (HCI) experts collaborated to design an exhibit that leverages advanced haptic and olfactory technologies. The approach involves:

  • Metaphorical Narrative: Participants embark on a "journey through dark matter," transformed into "dark matter detectors" by a metaphorical pill. This narrative bypasses direct scientific explanation in favor of an embodied, imaginative experience.
  • Multisensory Stimulation: The experience integrates synchronized auditory, tactile, olfactory, and gustatory stimuli. This includes:
  • Audio: Specially engineered soundscapes to represent dark matter wind and density.
  • Haptics: Mid-air haptic technology to simulate tactile sensations.
  • Olfactory: Scent delivery to evoke emotions and memories, using black pepper essential oil for its cross-modal properties.
  • Gustatory: Popping candy to create a surprising, crackling sensation.
  • Immersive Environment: The experience takes place within an inflatable planetarium, designed for an intimate, two-person setting to maximize focus and minimize external distractions.
  • Iterative Design: The project involved a pilot event (2018) and an improved second event (2019), incorporating user feedback to refine the design and delivery.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Embodiment as a Bridge: The central idea is that grounding abstract concepts in bodily experience through multisensory input can create meaning and overcome traditional knowledge barriers. This "embodiment of ideas" fosters a deeper, more intuitive response than purely intellectual engagement.
  • Metaphorical Thinking for Abstract Concepts: Using metaphors (like the "dark matter detector pill") allows for the communication of otherwise imperceptible phenomena in a way that is engaging and memorable, even if not scientifically literal.
  • The Power of Sensory Deprivation: The study suggests that removing or reducing the visual modality can actually enhance the perceived importance and impact of other senses, leading to a stronger overall experience and potentially better understanding.
  • Cross-Disciplinary Collaboration is Key: The success of the project hinges on the synergy between physics expertise (for scientific accuracy) and HCI expertise (for designing engaging, multisensory interactions).
  • Logistics Matter for Engagement: The significant interest and long queues observed highlight the potential for engaging the public before the core experience, using pre-event activities like quizzes to manage flow and build anticipation.

Key Results

  • High Engagement and Liking: Both events at the London Science Museum were met with significant public interest, with long queues. Participants generally rated the overall experience, immersion, and individual sensory modalities highly (mean rates around 7.0 on a 9-point Likert scale for the 2018 event).
  • Mixed Confidence in Explanation: While participants enjoyed the experience, their self-reported confidence in explaining dark matter to others was relatively low (mean rates around 5.0 on a 9-point Likert scale).
  • Sensory Modality Influence: The multisensory matrix evaluation revealed interesting shifts. On Day 1, hearing and touch were perceived as most influential for understanding, with taste topping enjoyment. On Day 2, after the visual element was kept on throughout, vision became the dominant sensory mode for understanding, while taste remained popular for enjoyment.
  • Positive Feedback: The majority of feedback (61 out of 67 post-its) was positive, with common descriptors including "interesting," "fun," "cool," and "educational."

Limitations and Future Work

  • Cost and Complexity: The authors acknowledge that the current setup, with its specialized equipment (portable planetarium, mid-air haptic display, scent delivery device), presents a significant barrier to replication by other science communicators.
  • Communicating the "Why": For some participants, the scientific accuracy and the cutting-edge nature of the technology were not fully communicated, leading to a perception that was more "heavy on senses" than grounded in scientific rigor.
  • Fine-tuning Sensory Intensity: The popping candy, while creating a strong reaction, was perceived by some as more distracting than enhancing, indicating a need for further fine-tuning of individual sensory components.

Future work will focus on:

  • Developing a Portable Version: Creating a more accessible and affordable version of the experience using readily available technology, with blueprints and instructions made freely available online.
  • Refining the Design: Continuing to develop the experience based on feedback to better achieve embodiment and emotional response.
  • Emphasizing Scientific Rigor: Finding ways to better communicate the scientific accuracy and the innovative technology behind the experience to enhance its perceived value.

Summary updated

Abstract

We present a novel approach to communicating abstract concepts in cosmology and astrophysics in a more accessible and inclusive manner. We describe an exhibit aiming at creating an immersive, multisensory metaphorical experience of an otherwise imperceptible physical phenomenon — dark matter. Human-Computer Interaction experts and physicists co-created a multisensory journey through dark matter by exploiting the latest advances in haptic and olfactory technology. We present the concept design of a pilot and a second, improved event, both held at the London Science Museum, including the practical setup of the multisensory dark matter experience, the delivery of sensory stimulation and preliminary insights from users' feedback.
BibTeX
@article{trotta2020communicating,
  author = {Roberto Trotta and Daniel Hajas and José Eliel Camargo-Molina and Robert Cobden and Emanuela Maggioni and Marianna Obrist},
  title = {{Communicating cosmology with multisensory metaphorical experiences}},
  journal = {Journal of Science Communication},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.22323/2.19020801},
}
Figure