Communicating Climate Change: A Comparison Between Tweets and Speeches by German Members of Parliament

Robin Schaefer, Christoph Abels, Stephan Lewandowsky, Manfred StedeACL 2023

TL;DR

This paper compares how German Members of Parliament (MPs) discuss climate change on Twitter versus in parliamentary speeches. It finds that while the communication channels differ, the core messages and framing largely align with political party ideologies, with left-leaning parties emphasizing crisis and urgency, and right-leaning parties focusing on technology and denial.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Climate change is a pressing global issue, and understanding how political leaders communicate about it is crucial for public discourse and policy. While politicians use various platforms, it's unclear if their communication strategies differ significantly between the informal, public-facing realm of Twitter and the formal, deliberative setting of parliamentary speeches. This study aims to bridge this gap by analyzing the content and framing of climate change discussions by German MPs across these two distinct communication arenas, exploring how these messages vary by political party.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-faceted approach to analyze the climate change discourse:

  • Keyword and Hashtag Analysis: They identified frequently used terms and hashtags related to climate change to understand the specific vocabulary and framing employed by different parties and across platforms.
  • Topic Modeling: Using BERTopic, a transformer-based technique, they automatically identified latent topics within the tweet and speech corpora. This allowed for a data-driven discovery of the main themes and subjects discussed.
  • Stance-Marked Noun Compounds: They utilized a pre-existing glossary of German noun compounds related to climate change to analyze how MPs express their stance or attitude towards the issue.

The analysis focused on a six-year period (starting in 2016) and compared communication from six major German political parties.

Datasets

  • Twitter Data: A dataset of tweet IDs from German MPs was obtained from a previous study (Lasser et al., 2022), covering January 1, 2016, to March 15, 2022. After filtering and cleaning, this resulted in a corpus of 30,242 tweets from 635 MPs.
  • Parliamentary Speeches: Transcripts of speeches in the German parliament were sourced from the Open Discourse dataset (Richter et al., 2020), covering September 1949 to May 2021. For the study's timeframe, relevant speech transcripts from missing months were manually collected. Speeches were analyzed at the paragraph level, resulting in 13,794 documents.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Political Spectrum Dominates: The most significant differences in climate change communication emerge not from the platform (Twitter vs. speeches) but from the political orientation of the parties.
  • Left-Leaning Parties: Crisis and Justice: Parties like "The Left" and "The Greens" consistently frame climate change as a crisis, emphasizing urgency and social justice, often aligning with activist movements.
  • Centrist/Liberal Parties: Technology and Balance: Parties like the SPD, FDP, and CDU/CSU tend to focus on climate-friendly technologies, economic transformation, and practical solutions, aiming for a more balanced approach that considers economic interests.
  • AfD: Denial and Dismissal: The AfD stands out by largely denying the need for climate action, framing concerned individuals as part of a "climate cult" or "fanatics" and using terms like "climate hysteria."
  • Remarkable Consistency Across Platforms: Despite the inherent differences between Twitter's brevity and speeches' depth, the core messages and framing used by parties show surprising consistency across both communication channels.

Key Results

  • Hashtag Trends: Left-leaning parties frequently use hashtags like #fridaysforfuture and #climatejustice, while the AfD is unique in using terms like #climatehysteria.
  • Compound Usage: The "climate crisis" compound is widely used, but more so by left-leaning parties. The AfD exclusively uses compounds that convey negative judgment on the climate movement (e.g., "climate hysteria," "climate delusion").
  • Topic Modeling Insights:
    • Tweets: Prominent topics across parties include emissions, transport, energy transition, and climate protection. However, specific nuances emerge, such as the AfD's focus on nuclear energy and wind energy.
  • Speeches: Similar themes appear, with transport infrastructure being more prominent in left-leaning parties' speeches, while the AfD continues to discuss "climate religion" and "dogma."
  • Quantitative Differences: While the overall themes are similar, the frequency and specific terms used vary. For instance, the Greens are the largest contributors of climate-related tweets, while the CDU/CSU and SPD deliver the most speeches.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations: The study acknowledges that the analysis of speeches was done at the paragraph level, which might miss broader contextual nuances of full speeches. The reliance on a pre-existing glossary for stance-marked compounds, while useful, might not capture all emergent or novel expressions.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest future research could investigate the climate communication behavior of individual MPs based on their committee roles. Additionally, a time-sensitive analysis using dynamic topic modeling could reveal how communication strategies evolve over time.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{schaefer2023communicating,
  author = {Robin Schaefer and Christoph Abels and Stephan Lewandowsky and Manfred Stede},
  title = {{Communicating Climate Change: A Comparison Between Tweets and Speeches by German Members of Parliament}},
  booktitle = {Annual Meeting of the Association for Computational Linguistics},
  year = {2023},
}
Figure