Commonwealth v. Joseph O'Dell? Truth and Justice or Confuse the Courts? The DNA Controversy
Lists
Only you see this
Abstract
This opinion examines the DNA aspect of the Joseph O'Dell case and how DNA was used to confuse and complicate an otherwise wholly circumstantial case in the courts. DNA testing was just evolving as a tool to convict the guilty when O'Dell requested to utilize it to prove his innocence. At the time, wrongful convictions were not so prevalent in the courts, or reported in the media, making this case an historic one for the argument advancing the use of DNA testing to prove innocence, or confirm guilt, before an execution. O'Dell's case is a compelling example of a multitude of constitutional errors and the failure to examine a colorable claim of innocence. The right to be free from wrongful execution is inherent in our criminal justice system, our Constitution and the notion that it is cruel and unusual punishment under the Eighth Amendment. The U.S. Supreme Courts' denial of the review of O'Dell's substantive claims resulted in large part due to the manipulation of facts and procedural failures in this case. This case study reveals the importance of integrity and high ethical standards in the prosecution and litigation of death penalty cases. It is a prime example of the need for accountability to ensure justice at all levels of the criminal justice system.
BibTeX
@misc{john1999commonwealth,
author = {St. John and Adriana Lori},
title = {{Commonwealth v. Joseph O'Dell? Truth and Justice or Confuse the Courts? The DNA Controversy}},
year = {1999},
howpublished = {SSRN},
}Loading related content...