Common, low-frequency, rare, and ultra-rare coding variants contribute to COVID-19 severity

Chiara Fallerini, Nicola Picchiotti, Margherita Baldassarri, Kristina Zguro, Sergio Daga, Francesca Fava, Elisa Benetti, Sara Amitrano, Mirella Bruttini, Maria Palmieri, Susanna Croci, Mirjam Lista, Giada Beligni, Floriana Valentino, Ilaria Meloni, Marco Tanfoni, Francesca Colombo, Enrico Cabri, Maddalena Fratelli, Chiara Gabbi, Stefania Mantovani, Elisa Frullanti, Marco Gori, Francis P. Crawley, Guillaume Butler‐Laporte, Brent Richards, Hugo Zeberg, Miklós Lipcsey, Michael Hultström, Kerstin U. Ludwig, Eva C. Schulte, Erola Pairo‐Castineira, J. Kenneth Baillie, Axel Schmidt, Robert Frithiof, Francesca Mari, Alessandra Renieri, Simone FurinimedRxiv 2021 · DOI

Abstract

The combined impact of common and rare exonic variants in COVID-19 host genetics is currently insufficiently understood. This study utilizes whole exome sequencing (WES) data from approximately 4,000 SARS-CoV-2-positive individuals to develop an interpretable machine learning model for predicting disease severity. By converting genetic variants into Boolean features and employing an ensemble of LASSO logistic regression models, we identified key genetic markers across the frequency spectrum—from common polymorphisms to ultra-rare mutations. These features were synthesized into an Integrated PolyGenic Score (IPGS), which offers a robust index for describing the host genetic contribution to COVID-19. Our findings reveal that roughly one-quarter of the selected genes are sex-specific and that the identified pathways reflect the multi-organ nature of the disease. The IPGS demonstrates consistent predictive power across multiple independent cohorts, suggesting significant potential for guiding clinical management and therapeutic development.

Introduction

One of the most perplexing aspects of the COVID-19 pandemic has been the extreme variability in clinical outcomes. While age, sex, and pre-existing comorbidities explain a significant portion of the risk, they do not fully account for why some young, healthy individuals develop life-threatening respiratory failure while others remain asymptomatic.

Traditional genetic research has largely focused on two extremes: Genome-Wide Association Studies (GWAS), which identify common variants with small individual effects, and Mendelian studies, which focus on rare, high-impact mutations. This research addresses the "missing middle" by arguing that COVID-19 severity is driven by the cumulative impact of variants across the entire frequency spectrum, including low-frequency and ultra-rare mutations occurring in less than 0.1% of the population.

Methodology

Booleanization and Frequency Tiering

To handle the complexity of whole exome sequencing data, the researchers moved away from traditional linear models toward an interpretable machine learning framework. The first step involved "Booleanization," where genetic data was converted into binary features (0 or 1) representing the presence or absence of variants within specific genes.

Variants were categorized into four distinct tiers based on their prevalence in the population:

  1. Ultra-rare: <0.1%
  2. Rare: 0.1–1%
  3. Low-frequency: 1–5%
  4. Common: >5%

Feature Selection and the IPGS

Using an ensemble of LASSO (Least Absolute Shrinkage and Selection Operator) logistic regression models, the team filtered through over 160,000 features to identify the approximately 4% that most strongly correlated with disease severity. These selected features were then combined into the Integrated PolyGenic Score (IPGS).

The IPGS employs a weighting system where rarer variants are assigned higher weights (e.g., an ultra-rare variant may be weighted five times more than a common one). This logic is based on the biological principle that rare mutations are more likely to significantly impair protein function and, consequently, have a larger impact on disease phenotype.

Datasets and Validation

The study was built upon a massive international collaboration involving approximately 4,000 SARS-CoV-2-positive individuals. The discovery and training phase utilized the Italian GEN-COVID Multicenter Study (n=1,780). To ensure the model's generalizability, it was validated against three independent European-ancestry cohorts: BQC-19 (Quebec, Canada), DeCOI (Germany), and GenOMICC (UK), as well as the SweCovid (Sweden) cohort. To minimize statistical noise from population stratification, the analysis focused on individuals of European ancestry.

Key Insights

The Post-Mendelian Paradigm

The results support an "oligogenic" model of COVID-19 severity. Rather than being caused by a single mutation or thousands of tiny-effect common variants, severity is often driven by a handful of impactful variants across different genes. This "post-Mendelian" view provides a more nuanced understanding of how individual genetic architectures contribute to disease.

Sex-Specific Genetic Risk

Notably, approximately 25% of the genes selected by the model were sex-specific. A primary example is TLR7, located on the X chromosome; variants in this gene were found to be critical for males. This genetic divergence helps explain the long-observed clinical trend of higher severity and mortality rates in men compared to women.

Multi-Organ Biological Pathways

Pathway analysis of the selected genes highlighted that COVID-19 is a systemic, multi-organ disease. The genetic risk factors were not confined to pulmonary function but involved:

  • Immune Signaling: Specifically interferon pathways.
  • Coagulation: Genes like ADAMTS13 (linked to blood clotting).
  • Ciliary Function: Genes affecting the tiny hairs in the airways that clear viral particles.

Results and Clinical Utility

The IPGS proved to be a robust independent predictor of severity. When added to a baseline model containing only age and sex, the IPGS increased the overall accuracy to 0.73 and precision to 0.78. The model yielded an Odds Ratio (OR) of 2.32, indicating that a significant increase in a patient’s genetic score more than doubles their risk of severe disease.

Crucially, the model demonstrated clinical utility by correctly identifying high-risk outcomes in younger patients who would have been classified as "low risk" by traditional demographic models. The consistency of these results across international cohorts suggests that the IPGS is a reliable tool for identifying vulnerable individuals.

Limitations and Future Directions

The primary limitation of the current study is ancestry bias, as the model was optimized for European populations. Future research must expand these datasets to include diverse global ancestries to ensure equitable clinical application. Additionally, the integration of non-coding regulatory regions and prospective clinical trials will be essential to transition the IPGS from a research tool to a bedside diagnostic that can guide personalized treatment strategies, such as the use of specific anti-thrombotic therapies for patients with identified clotting-related mutations.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract The combined impact of common and rare exonic variants in COVID-19 host genetics is currently insufficiently understood. Here, common and rare variants from whole exome sequencing data of about 4,000 SARS-CoV-2-positive individuals were used to define an interpretable machine learning model for predicting COVID-19 severity. Firstly, variants were converted into separate sets of Boolean features, depending on the absence or the presence of variants in each gene. An ensemble of LASSO logistic regression models was used to identify the most informative Boolean features with respect to the genetic bases of severity. The Boolean features selected by these logistic models were combined into an Integrated PolyGenic Score that offers a synthetic and interpretable index for describing the contribution of host genetics in COVID-19 severity, as demonstrated through testing in several independent cohorts. Selected features belong to ultra-rare, rare, low-frequency, and common variants, including those in linkage disequilibrium with known GWAS loci. Noteworthly, around one quarter of the selected genes are sex-specific. Pathway analysis of the selected genes associated with COVID-19 severity reflected the multi-organ nature of the disease. The proposed model might provide useful information for developing diagnostics and therapeutics, while also being able to guide bedside disease management.
BibTeX
@misc{fallerini2021common,
  author = {Chiara Fallerini and Nicola Picchiotti and Margherita Baldassarri and Kristina Zguro and Sergio Daga and Francesca Fava and Elisa Benetti and Sara Amitrano and Mirella Bruttini and Maria Palmieri and Susanna Croci and Mirjam Lista and Giada Beligni and Floriana Valentino and Ilaria Meloni and Marco Tanfoni and Francesca Colombo and Enrico Cabri and Maddalena Fratelli and Chiara Gabbi and Stefania Mantovani and Elisa Frullanti and Marco Gori and Francis P. Crawley and Guillaume Butler‐Laporte and Brent Richards and Hugo Zeberg and Miklós Lipcsey and Michael Hultström and Kerstin U. Ludwig and Eva C. Schulte and Erola Pairo‐Castineira and J. Kenneth Baillie and Axel Schmidt and Robert Frithiof and Francesca Mari and Alessandra Renieri and Simone Furini and Simone Furini},
  title = {{Common, low-frequency, rare, and ultra-rare coding variants contribute to COVID-19 severity}},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1101/2021.09.03.21262611},
  howpublished = {medRxiv},
}
Figure