Commitment Semantics for Sequential Decision Making under Reward Uncertainty.

Qi Zhang, Edmund H. Durfee, Satinder P. Singh, Anna Chen, Stefan J. WitwickiIJCAI 2016 · OpenReview

Abstract

In multi-agent systems, agents must often make commitments to coordinate effectively, yet real-world environments frequently involve stochastic outcomes and evolving reward functions. This paper addresses the tension between faithfulness to past commitments and flexibility in the face of new information. We introduce the Commitment Constrained Iterative Mean Reward (CCIMR) algorithm, which allows agents to maintain probabilistic commitments while navigating reward uncertainty. By modeling interactions as Transition-Decoupled POMDPs, CCIMR ensures that updated policies remain consistent with prior actions and commitment constraints. Experimental results in simulated environments demonstrate that CCIMR achieves near-optimal performance with significantly lower computational overhead compared to exact Bayesian methods, scaling effectively to larger state spaces.

Introduction

Effective coordination in multi-agent systems often hinges on the ability of agents to make and keep promises. For instance, a robot might commit to opening a gate for a user by a specific time. However, as the robot acts, it may discover new information that changes its understanding of the optimal path or even its own rewards. This creates a fundamental conflict: should the agent strictly adhere to its original plan, potentially ignoring more lucrative opportunities, or should it abandon its promise if a better option arises?

Traditional models of commitment are often either too rigid, forbidding any deviation, or too loose, allowing agents to break promises whenever they become "irrational." This research proposes a middle ground, defining "probabilistic commitments" that allow for flexibility while ensuring the agent remains faithful to the spirit of its original promise.

Methodology

The authors formalize this problem using a Transition-Decoupled POMDP (TD-POMDP). A probabilistic commitment is defined as a constraint: the agent must follow a policy that ensures a specific target state is reached with at least a certain probability $\rho$ by a deadline $\tau$.

To solve this, the paper introduces the Commitment Constrained Iterative Mean Reward (CCIMR) algorithm. CCIMR operates by iteratively re-planning as new information about rewards is revealed. Unlike static approaches that plan once and never adapt, CCIMR updates its belief about rewards at each step. If beliefs change significantly, it solves a new linear program to find an updated policy. Crucially, this new policy is constrained to be a valid continuation of the agent's previous choices, ensuring that the overall probability of meeting the commitment is preserved.

Experimental Evaluation

The framework was evaluated in two primary simulated environments:

  1. Gate Control: A robot must choose between two switches to open a gate. One switch is faster but carries the risk of reward drops if an "enemy" appears, while the other is safer but less reliable.
  2. Committed RockSample: A variation of the classic Mars rover benchmark where the agent must sample rocks and commit to exiting the region by a deadline.
The Gate Control task environment, illustrating the robot's starting position and the potential switch locations used to test commitment under reward uncertainty.

Results and Discussion

The performance of CCIMR was compared against two baselines: the Extended Belief State (EBS), which is theoretically optimal but computationally expensive, and the Mean Reward (MR) approach, which is fast but non-adaptive.

Quantitative comparison of Expected Value and Computation Time for EBS, CCIMR, and MR. CCIMR maintains high performance while scaling significantly better than EBS as the time horizon increases.

In the Gate Control task, CCIMR achieved expected rewards nearly identical to the optimal EBS while being significantly faster. As shown in the results, the computation time for EBS grows exponentially with the time horizon, becoming intractable beyond a horizon of 12. In contrast, CCIMR's computation time remains low, comparable to the simple MR baseline. In the larger RockSample domain, CCIMR successfully scaled to a $7 \times 8$ grid, providing nearly double the reward of the non-adaptive MR approach in certain scenarios where EBS was unusable.

Conclusion

This work demonstrates that treating commitments as hard constraints on policy space, rather than mere components of a reward function, provides a robust framework for agent faithfulness. CCIMR offers a practical balance between the optimality of full Bayesian planning and the efficiency of myopic methods. Future research may extend these semantics to multi-robot coordination and explore the role of active communication in renegotiating commitments as environments evolve.

Summary updated

Abstract

Author Summary The ever growing size of neural populations simultaneously recorded in electrophysiological experiments calls for urgent analytical progress in understanding how to compactly describe all sensory information present both in the spatial and temporal structure of single-trial neural population activity. Here we show the power of analytical methods, termed space-by-time tensor factorizations, which detect groups of simultaneously coactive neurons and the temporal profiles of their coactivation. By validation on simulated data and on retinal recordings, we show that the tensor decomposition performs competitively compared to other techniques both in terms of data robustness and ability to find informative patterns across diverse stimuli. We show that this method can determine the spatial and temporal resolution of neural population codes, and find which spatial or temporal components of neural responses carry information not available in other aspects of the population code. When applied to experimental data, the method demonstrates the importance of first-spike latencies in retinal population coding of visual images, particularly for decoding fine spatial details of natural images from population activity. This work shows that this methodology can improve our knowledge of population coding by allowing the discovery of informative spatial and temporal firing patterns in populations of simultaneously recorded neurons.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2016commitment,
  author = {Qi Zhang and Edmund H. Durfee and Satinder P. Singh and Anna Chen and Stefan J. Witwicki},
  title = {{Commitment Semantics for Sequential Decision Making under Reward Uncertainty.}},
  booktitle = {IJCAI},
  year = {2016},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=S8M8BscfZ56},
}

Loading related content...

Figure