Commensurability of Surface Automorphisms \\and surface bundles over $S^1$

Hongbin Sun, Shicheng WangarXiv 2009 · DOI · arXiv

TL;DR

This paper introduces new invariants to distinguish surface automorphisms, which are crucial for understanding the structure of 3-manifolds built from surface bundles. The authors demonstrate that these invariants can reveal when different surface bundle structures on the same 3-manifold are "rationally commensurable," meaning they are related by a specific type of transformation.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper tackles the problem of classifying and distinguishing automorphisms of surfaces, particularly when these surfaces are used as fibers in 3-dimensional manifolds (surface bundles). When two surface bundles over a circle ($S^1$) are constructed using different surfaces or different "gluing maps" (automorphisms), it's important to know if these constructions are fundamentally the same or distinct. The concept of "commensurability" and "rational commensurability" provides a way to relate these automorphisms. However, existing methods for distinguishing them, especially for surfaces with negative Euler characteristic (complex surfaces), are limited. This paper aims to develop new tools (invariants) to better understand when two surface automorphisms are commensurable or rationally commensurable, and how this relates to the resulting 3-manifolds.

Methods

The core of the paper lies in defining and utilizing new numerical and polynomial invariants to characterize surface automorphisms. For reducible automorphisms (those that can be decomposed into simpler pieces), the authors define:

  • Polynomial Invariants ($P(x,y)$): These are pairs of polynomials that capture information about the structure of the automorphism.
  • Numerical Invariants ($A(\phi)$ and $\Pi(\phi)$): These are simpler numerical quantities derived from the polynomial invariants, making them easier to compute and compare.

The paper then proves that if two reducible automorphisms are commensurable, their polynomial invariants are identical. If they are rationally commensurable, their polynomial invariants are related by a scaling factor. This establishes these invariants as powerful tools for distinguishing automorphisms. The latter half of the paper applies these invariants to construct examples of 3-manifolds with multiple distinct surface bundle structures that are not rationally commensurable, showcasing the practical utility of the developed theory.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical constructions and invariants rather than empirical evaluation on datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • New Invariants for Surface Automorphisms: The introduction of polynomial and numerical invariants provides a more refined way to classify and distinguish surface automorphisms, especially for complex surfaces.
  • Distinguishing Rational Commensurability: The paper establishes a clear link between rational commensurability of automorphisms and a specific scaling relationship between their polynomial invariants. This is a significant step in understanding when different surface bundle constructions are fundamentally related.
  • Constructing Manifolds with Multiple Bundle Structures: The paper demonstrates how to build 3-manifolds that admit infinitely many distinct surface bundle structures (up to rational commensurability), and also manifolds with two distinct structures of the same fiber genus. This highlights the complexity and richness of 3-manifold topology.
  • Reducible Automorphisms as the Focus: The paper primarily focuses on reducible automorphisms, which are a key class of surface automorphisms, and develops tools specifically for them.

Key Results

  • Theorem 1.5: Establishes that commensurable reducible automorphisms have identical polynomial invariants ($P_1(x,y) = P_2(x,y)$), and rationally commensurable ones have invariants related by a scaling factor ($P_1(x,y) = sP_2(x,y)$ for some $s \in \mathbb{Q}^+$).
  • Corollaries 1.6 & 1.7: Provide simpler numerical conditions based on the $A(\phi)$ and $\Pi(\phi)$ invariants for commensurability and rational commensurability.
  • Examples in Section 3: The paper constructs explicit examples of 3-manifolds that have:
  • Infinitely many surface bundle structures that are not rationally commensurable.
  • Two distinct surface bundle structures of the same genus that are not rationally commensurable.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Focus on Reducible Automorphisms: The developed invariants are primarily for reducible automorphisms. Extending these to other classes, such as pseudo-Anosov maps, would be a natural next step.
  • Generalization to Other Manifolds: The paper focuses on surface bundles over $S^1$. Investigating commensurability in the context of more general 3-manifolds or higher-dimensional bundles could be a fruitful direction.
  • Open Questions: The paper poses open questions about the rational commensurability of pseudo-Anosov automorphisms and the number of rational commensurable classes of automorphisms for a given 3-manifold, indicating areas for future research.

Summary updated

Abstract

This note will become part of a new paper with more authors.
BibTeX
@misc{sun2009commensurability,
  author = {Hongbin Sun and Shicheng Wang},
  title = {{Commensurability of Surface Automorphisms \textbackslash\{\}\textbackslash\{\}and surface bundles over $S^1$}},
  year = {2009},
  eprint = {0907.1132},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/0907.1132},
}

Loading related content...

Figure