Comissioning Results for a Subharmonic Buncher at REA

Daniel Alt, John Brandon, Shannon Krause, A. Lapierre, Dan Morris, Samuel Nash, M. Syphers, Nathan Usher, A. C. C. Villari, Scott Williams, Shen ZhaoJACOW 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

Researchers at MSU's ReAccelerator (ReA) facility have successfully designed, built, and commissioned a new 16.1 MHz subharmonic buncher. This device is crucial for improving time-of-flight measurements in rare isotope experiments by creating longer time gaps between particle bunches, enhancing experimental precision.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The ReAccelerator (ReA) facility at Michigan State University is designed to study rare isotope reactions using low-energy beams. A key component of ReA is a superconducting linear accelerator (LINAC) that operates at a radio frequency (RF) of 80.5 MHz. This high frequency results in very short time intervals between particle bunches (12.4 ns). For experiments relying on time-of-flight (TOF) measurements, this short interval can lead to ambiguity, as it's difficult to distinguish between particles arriving at slightly different times within the same 12.4 ns window. To overcome this, the ReA facility needs a way to create longer time gaps between bunches without simply discarding a large fraction of the beam. This paper addresses the challenge of bunching particles at a lower frequency, specifically a subharmonic of the LINAC's operating frequency, to enable more precise TOF measurements.

Methods

The core of the solution is a "subharmonic buncher" that manipulates the longitudinal motion of the particle beam. The principle relies on applying a voltage that ramps linearly from decelerating at the head of a bunch to accelerating at the tail. This "time-of-flight compression" aims to bring all particles within a bunch to a focal point simultaneously. Since a perfect linear ramp is difficult to achieve, the buncher synthesizes an approximation using a truncated Fourier series of sinusoidal components. Specifically, the 16.1 MHz buncher uses the first three sinusoidal components to generate the desired waveform. This waveform is applied via a pair of conical electrodes. To achieve precise control and stability, the resonant structures exciting these sine waves are driven by a closed-loop Low Level Radio Frequency (LLRF) controller with active feedback. The buncher is designed with a focal length of 2 meters upstream of the RFQ entrance, and the required peak voltage is approximately 1700 V for the highest rigidity beam (Q/A = 1/5).

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Subharmonic Bunching for TOF Precision: The paper demonstrates a practical method for creating longer time gaps between particle bunches (62.1 ns) by using a subharmonic frequency (16.1 MHz) of the main accelerator. This is a crucial step for improving the precision of time-of-flight measurements in rare isotope experiments.
  • Approximating a Linear Ramp: The use of a truncated Fourier series to approximate a linear voltage ramp is a clever engineering solution to the practical limitations of generating complex waveforms. This approach balances performance with achievable hardware complexity.
  • LLRF Control for Stability: The implementation of a closed-loop LLRF controller with active feedback is vital for maintaining the amplitude and phase stability of the bunching waveform, ensuring consistent performance.
  • Understanding Satellite Bunches: The paper acknowledges and explains the origin of "satellite" bunches – unintended smaller bunches that arise from the imperfect linear ramp. This understanding is key to future optimization efforts.
  • Energy Spread as a Limiting Factor: The simulations and measurements highlight that the initial energy spread of the beam is a fundamental limit on how tightly particles can be bunched. This insight is important for optimizing beam preparation before bunching.

Key Results

  • The 16.1 MHz subharmonic buncher was successfully designed, constructed, and commissioned.
  • The buncher creates a final bunch separation of 62.1 ns, which is 5 times the original period.
  • Measurements show that approximately 50% of the initial beam current from the EBIT was preserved after acceleration through the LINAC with the new buncher. This is an improvement compared to the 30% preserved with no bunching.
  • Satellite bunches account for approximately 13% of the particles after the LINAC.
  • The comparison between simulation and measurement allowed for the calibration of the control system readout to the actual on-axis voltage and provided an estimate of the initial beam energy spread (around 0.15%).

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that the bunching waveform is an approximation, leading to the presence of satellite bunches. While these are reduced compared to no bunching, further improvements are planned. Future work includes:

  • Physical and Software Improvements: Enhancements to the hardware and LLRF module are planned to enable the use of the third buncher mode.
  • Extending the Linear Portion: The addition of the third mode is expected to extend the linear portion of the bunching waveform, increasing buncher efficiency.
  • Improved Calibration: More thorough calibration of the buncher controls is anticipated.
  • Satellite Bunch Cleaning: Various options are being explored to more completely clean up the satellite bunches.

With these improvements, the authors predict the buncher should be able to capture around 95% of the beam in the main bunch.

Summary updated

Abstract

The reaccelerator facility (ReA) at the National Superconducting Cyclotron Laboratory (NSCL) at Michigan State University (MSU) offers a unique capability to study reactions with low-energy beams of rare isotopes. A beam from the coupled cyclotron facility is stopped in a gas stopping system, charge bred in an Electron Beam Ion Trap (EBIT), and then reaccelerated in a compact superconducting LINAC. The original beam repetition rate at the ReA targets was the same as the LINAC RF frequency of 80.5 MHz. In order to add the capability to bunch at a lower frequency (desirable for many types of experiments using time of flight data acquisitions) a 16.1 MHz buncher has been designed, constructed, and commissioned. This paper reports the results of the commissioning of the device, and outlines some future avenues for further improvement of the properties of the bunched beam.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{alt2017comissioning,
  author = {Daniel Alt and John Brandon and Shannon Krause and A. Lapierre and Dan Morris and Samuel Nash and M. Syphers and Nathan Usher and A. C. C. Villari and Scott Williams and Shen Zhao},
  title = {{Comissioning Results for a Subharmonic Buncher at REA}},
  booktitle = {JACOW},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.18429/jacow-linac2016-thprc029},
}
Figure