Combustion and mechanical property enhancement strategy based on SA surface activated boron powders

Jiaxin Lu, Chong Chen, Bobo Zhang, Kang Niu, Fei Xiao, Taixin LiangResearch Square 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

Researchers have developed a simple, one-step "self-assembly" method to coat boron particles with stearic acid (SA), creating a hydrophobic shield that solves two of the biggest headaches in rocket science. This coating prevents boron from clumping in the polymer binder—allowing for much higher fuel loading—while simultaneously lowering the ignition temperature and boosting the overall energy release during combustion.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Boron is a "superfuel" on paper, boasting a theoretical calorific value of 58 MJ/kg—nearly double that of traditional aluminum fuels. However, in practice, it is notoriously difficult to use.

Two main issues plague boron-based solid rocket propellants:

  1. Surface Chemistry: Boron particles naturally develop a layer of boron trioxide and boric acid. These impurities react poorly with common binders like hydroxyl-terminated polybutadiene (HTPB), causing the fuel to aggregate (clump) and making the propellant mixture too viscous to process.
  2. Combustion Efficiency: That same oxide layer acts as a barrier, creating a molten liquid shell during heating that delays ignition and prevents the boron core from burning completely.

The authors sought a "green" and scalable way to modify the boron surface to improve both its compatibility with the binder and its reactivity in the combustion chamber.

Methods

The team employed a technique called solvent evaporation-induced self-assembly.

  • The Process: Boron powders were dispersed in an ethanol solution containing stearic acid (SA). As the solvent evaporated during a spray-drying process, the SA molecules naturally organized themselves into a thin, functional coating around the boron particles (referred to as SA@B).
  • Characterization: The researchers used a suite of high-end tools to verify the coating, including Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM) for morphology, X-ray Photoelectron Spectroscopy (XPS) for surface chemistry, and contact angle measurements to test hydrophobicity.
  • Testing: Combustion performance was measured using oxygen bomb calorimetry and high-speed photography (5000 fps) to analyze flame stability. Mechanical properties were tested using a tensile testing machine on HTPB/boron composite "dumbbells."

Datasets

As an experimental materials science paper, this study does not use large-scale computational datasets. Instead, it generates original experimental data points across thermal analysis (TGA/DSC), mechanical stress-strain curves, and spectroscopic signatures (FTIR/XPS). These serve as a benchmark for comparing raw boron against surface-activated boron in energetic applications.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Mirror Effect": Raw boron is hydrophilic and sinks in water. The SA-coated boron becomes so hydrophobic (contact angle of 136.02°) that it floats, creating a "mirror-like" reflection on the water's surface. This hydrophobicity is the key to preventing the boron from reacting prematurely with the HTPB binder.
  • SA as a Combustion Catalyst: Stearic acid isn't just a passive coating. During heating, it decomposes into flammable gases like methane and acetylene. These gases release heat early, helping to "crack" the boron's oxide layer and lowering the ignition temperature from 760°C to 737°C.
  • Solving the Viscosity Paradox: Usually, adding more fuel to a propellant makes it too thick to pour into a rocket motor. The SA coating acts as a lubricant and dispersant, allowing the team to reach a 50 wt% loading of boron while maintaining excellent fluidity and mechanical strength.

Key Results

  • Energy Boost: The heat of combustion for the SA@B composite reached 30.29 MJ/g, a significant improvement over raw boron mixtures.
  • Mechanical Strength: At 50 wt% loading, the SA@B/HTPB composite achieved a tensile strength of 0.63 MPa. In contrast, raw boron at similar loadings created a "rough" and weak matrix due to poor dispersion.
  • Cleaner Burn: High-speed imaging showed that SA@B combustion produced fewer "molten solid particles" ejected from the flame compared to raw boron, indicating a more stable and efficient combustion process.
  • Oxidation Efficiency: The oxidation weight gain of the modified particles was 119.82%, suggesting that the SA coating helps the boron react more fully with oxygen.

Limitations and Future Work

While the stearic acid coating shows remarkable results, the authors note a few areas for further exploration:

  • Environmental Sensitivity: While SA is "green," the long-term storage stability of these coatings under extreme humidity or temperature cycling remains to be fully characterized.
  • Scaling Up: The spray-drying method is efficient, but transitioning from lab-scale "grams" to industrial-scale "tons" of propellant will require further engineering.
  • Alternative Coatings: Future work could investigate whether other long-chain fatty acids or bio-inspired molecules could provide even better interfacial bonding than stearic acid.

Summary updated

Abstract

<title>Abstract</title> Boric acid and other impurities on the surface of boron (B) particles can interact with hydroxyl-terminated polybutadiene (HTPB), which can weak the mechanical properties and energy release efficiency of boron-based solid rocket propellants. In this paper, solvent evaporation induced self-assembly was used to coat the surface of B particles with stearic acid (SA) and the SA@B composite particles were prepared. The effects of SA coating on the combustion performance of B particles and the mechanical properties of HTPB matrix composites were investigated. The results showed that the SA coating enhanced the oxidation efficiency of B particles in air. The heat of combustion value of the SA@B composite particles, reached up to 30.29 MJ/g. During the combustion of SA@B composite particles, there are fewer molten solid particles surrounding the flame, which enhances the stability of B particles combustion process. Furthermore, the SA coating effectively enhanced the dispersion of B particles in HTPB. At a stretching speed of 100 mm/min, the tensile strength of the SA@B/HTPB composite materials is higher than that of the B/HTPB composite materials. Moreover, when the mass loading of the SA@B composite particles reaches 50 wt%, the tensile strength of SA@B/HTPB composite materials achieves 0.63 MPa. The compatibility between B particles and HTPB can be effectively improved by surface-activated B particles with SA, which is of great significance for the storage stability of boron-based solid rocket propellants.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{lu2024combustion,
  author = {Jiaxin Lu and Chong Chen and Bobo Zhang and Kang Niu and Fei Xiao and Taixin Liang},
  title = {{Combustion and mechanical property enhancement strategy based on SA surface activated boron powders}},
  booktitle = {Research Square},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.21203/rs.3.rs-4487942/v1},
}
Figure