Combustion and mechanical properties enhancement strategy based on stearic acid surface activated boron powders

Jiaxin Lu, Chong Chen, Bobo Zhang, Kang Niu, Fei Xiao, Taixin LiangScientific 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

Researchers have developed a "green" surface-activation strategy for boron powders using stearic acid (SA) to overcome the long-standing trade-off between energy density and structural integrity in solid rocket propellants. By applying a self-assembled SA coating, they achieved a 50% increase in combustion heat and significantly improved the mechanical compatibility of boron with polymer binders, even at high mass loadings.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Boron is a "holy grail" fuel for solid rocket propellants due to its massive theoretical calorific value (58 MJ/kg). However, in practice, it’s a difficult material to work with. Raw boron particles are almost always covered in impurities like boric acid ($H_3BO_3$) and boron trioxide ($B_2O_3$).

These impurities cause two major headaches:

  1. Mechanical Failure: They react with common polymer binders like hydroxyl-terminated polybutadiene (HTPB), causing the particles to clump together (agglomerate). This makes the propellant slurry too viscous to process and creates structural defects in the final rocket motor.
  2. Combustion Inefficiency: During ignition, these surface oxides melt into a liquid layer that acts as a thermal barrier, delaying ignition and preventing the boron core from burning completely.

While fluorine-based coatings can strip these oxides, they are often environmentally hazardous. This paper seeks a "green" alternative that fixes both the chemistry and the mechanics.

Methods

The authors utilized a solvent evaporation-induced self-assembly technique to create SA@B composite particles.

  • The Process: Boron particles were dispersed in an ethanol solution containing stearic acid. As the solvent evaporated, the SA molecules naturally organized themselves into a hydrophobic layer on the boron surface.
  • Characterization: The team used a suite of advanced tools—including XPS, FTIR, and solid-state NMR—to prove that the SA wasn't just mixed in, but was chemically adsorbed onto the boron surface.
  • Testing: They compared raw boron, a simple mechanical mixture (SA/B), and the self-assembled composite (SA@B). Testing included high-speed flame photography (5000 fps), oxygen bomb calorimetry for energy release, and tensile testing for mechanical strength.

Datasets

As an experimental materials science paper, this study does not use traditional computational datasets. Instead, it establishes a benchmark by comparing its results against existing literature on modified boron/HTPB composites (referenced as studies 8, 9, 26, 50, 54, and 55 in the paper). The experimental data includes thermal decomposition profiles (TG/DSC) and stress-strain curves for various mass loadings (20%, 35%, and 50 wt%).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Green" Advantage: Stearic acid is a non-toxic, saturated fatty acid. Using it as a functional coating avoids the environmental concerns associated with the fluorinated compounds typically used in propellant research.
  • The Hydrophobic Shield: The coating transformed the boron surface from hydrophilic (contact angle ~16°) to highly hydrophobic (~136°). This "lotus leaf" effect prevents the boron from reacting prematurely with moisture or the binder, ensuring stable storage.
  • Synergistic Combustion: The SA doesn't just sit there; it contributes. During heating, SA decomposes into combustible gases like methane and acetylene. These gases ignite early, releasing heat that helps "crack" the boron's oxide shell, leading to a much more efficient burn.
  • Overcoming the Viscosity Barrier: Raw boron makes HTPB slurry so thick that 50 wt% loading is nearly impossible to manufacture. The SA coating acts as a lubricant/compatibilizer, allowing for high-energy, high-loading composites that remain processable.

Key Results

  • Energy Boost: The combustion heat of the SA@B composite reached 30.29 MJ/g, a 50% increase over raw boron particles.
  • Oxidation Efficiency: The oxidation weight gain for SA@B was 119.82%, significantly higher than the ~85% seen in native boron, indicating much more complete fuel utilization.
  • Mechanical Strength: At a 50 wt% loading, the SA@B/HTPB composite achieved a tensile strength of 2.46 MPa. For context, this is roughly 16% higher than previously reported values for modified boron propellants in similar studies.
  • Ignition Stability: High-speed imaging showed that SA@B produced a stable, steady flame with far fewer "molten droplets" (unburnt fuel) being ejected from the combustion zone compared to raw boron.

Limitations and Future Work

While the results are promising, the paper focuses on ambient pressure or 3 MPa oxygen bomb environments. Real-world rocket motors operate under much more complex, high-pressure dynamic conditions.

Future research directions suggested by the work include:

  • Testing the long-term aging stability of the SA coating under varying humidity and temperature cycles.
  • Investigating the performance of these powders in actual motor firing tests to see how the SA coating affects the burning rate law ($r = ap^n$).
  • Exploring the combination of SA with other energetic additives (like nano-aluminum) to further tune the ignition delay.

Summary updated

Abstract

Boric acid and other impurities on the surface of boron (B) particles can interact with hydroxyl-terminated polybutadiene (HTPB), weakening the mechanical properties and energy release efficiency of boron-based solid rocket propellants. SA@B composite particles were created by coating stearic acid (SA) on the surface of B particles through solvent evaporation-induced self-assembly. The study investigated the impact of SA coating on the combustion performance of B particles and the mechanical properties of HTPB matrix composites. The results showed that the SA coating enhanced the oxidation efficiency of B particles in air. The combustion heat of SA@B composite particles is 30.29 MJ/g, about 50% higher than that of B particles. During the combustion of SA@B composite particles, fewer molten solid particles surround the flame, which enhances the stability of the combustion process of the B particles. Furthermore, the SA coating effectively enhanced the dispersion of B particles in HTPB. At a stretching speed of 100 mm/min, the tensile strength of the SA@B/HTPB composite materials is higher than that of the B/HTPB composite materials. Moreover, when the mass loading of the SA@B composite particles reaches 50 wt%, the tensile strength of SA@B/HTPB composite materials is 2.46 MPa. Activating the surface of boron particles with SA can significantly improve their compatibility with HTPB, which is crucial for the stable storage of boron-based solid rocket propellants.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{lu2024combustion,
  author = {Jiaxin Lu and Chong Chen and Bobo Zhang and Kang Niu and Fei Xiao and Taixin Liang},
  title = {{Combustion and mechanical properties enhancement strategy based on stearic acid surface activated boron powders}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1038/s41598-024-71246-0},
}
Figure