Combining Numerical Simulation and Deep Learning for Landslide Displacement Prediction: An Attempt to Expand the Deep Learning Dataset

Wenhan Xu, Hong Xu, Jie Chen, Yanfei Kang, Yuanyuan Pu, Yabo Ye, Jue TongSustainability 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper tackles the challenge of limited landslide monitoring data for deep learning by proposing a novel approach: using numerical simulations to generate synthetic data. By combining simulated and real-world data to train a deep learning model, they achieved more accurate landslide displacement predictions with lower errors compared to using only real data.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Accurate landslide prediction is crucial for disaster prevention, and deep learning models have shown great promise in this area. However, a major bottleneck is the scarcity of high-quality, long-term landslide monitoring data. Traditional data-driven methods often suffer from insufficient training datasets, leading to poor generalization and unreliable predictions. While numerical simulations can capture the physical mechanisms of landslides, they are often complex and time-consuming. This paper aims to bridge this gap by demonstrating how numerical simulations can effectively augment limited real-world monitoring data to create a more robust dataset for training deep learning models, thereby improving landslide displacement prediction accuracy.

Methods

The core of this research lies in a two-pronged approach:

  • Numerical Simulation for Data Augmentation: The authors established a 2D finite element numerical model of the Jiuxianping landslide using GeoStudio. This model incorporated coupled stress and pore water pressure simulations, driven by historical reservoir water level changes and precipitation data. The simulation generated synthetic landslide displacement time series data.
  • Deep Learning for Prediction: A deep learning model, specifically a CNN-BiGRU-AM architecture (1D Convolutional Neural Network, Bidirectional Gated Recurrent Unit, and Attention Mechanism), was employed for displacement prediction. This model was trained using two scenarios:
  • Training solely on the limited real monitored data.
  • Training on an expanded dataset combining both the real monitored data and the synthetically generated data from numerical simulations.

Before training, the similarity between the simulated and monitored displacement time series was rigorously evaluated using Euclidean distance, cosine similarity, and Dynamic Time Warping (DTW) distance.

Datasets

  • Monitored Data: Displacement data from five GNSS monitoring stations (YY206, YY207, YY208, YY209, YY210) at the Jiuxianping landslide, collected monthly from June 2016 to June 2021. Daily reservoir levels and precipitation data for the same period were also used.
  • Simulated Data: Synthetic landslide displacement time series data generated by the finite element numerical model for the Jiuxianping landslide, covering a period of 1800 days.

The study divided the monitored data into a training set (June 2016 - June 2020) and a testing set (July 2020 - June 2021). The simulated data was used to create a larger training set.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Numerical Simulation as a Viable Data Augmentation Tool: The study strongly suggests that numerical simulations can effectively generate realistic landslide displacement data, overcoming the limitations of sparse real-world monitoring. This is a significant step towards making deep learning more applicable in geohazard prediction.
  • Time Series Similarity is Crucial: Rigorous validation of the similarity between simulated and real data using metrics like Euclidean distance, cosine similarity, and DTW is essential before using simulated data for training. The paper demonstrates high similarity, justifying its use.
  • Combined Data Leads to Superior Performance: Training deep learning models with a combination of simulated and real data significantly improves prediction accuracy and reduces errors compared to using only real data. This highlights the synergistic benefit of integrating physics-based simulations with data-driven approaches.
  • Physical Mechanism Interpretation: The numerical simulation approach not only provides data but also offers insights into the physical mechanisms driving landslide displacement, which can help interpret data gaps and improve model understanding.

Key Results

  • High Time Series Similarity: The simulated and monitored displacement time series at point YY210 showed high similarity, with a mean Euclidean distance of 14.39 mm (approx. 9% error), cosine similarity of 0.989, and a DTW distance of 633.47 mm.
  • Improved Prediction Accuracy: The CNN-BiGRU-AM model trained on the combined simulated and monitored dataset achieved significantly lower prediction errors on the testing set compared to the model trained solely on monitored data.
  • Monitored Training: MAE = 3.99 mm, RMSE = 4.17 mm, MAPE = 2.68%
    • Simulated Training: MAE = 1.23 mm, RMSE = 1.50 mm, MAPE = 0.85%
  • More Concentrated Error Distribution: Predictions made using the simulated dataset resulted in a more concentrated distribution of errors, with most errors being less than 2 mm, indicating greater reliability.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited Geological Section: The numerical model was based on a single geological section, which might not fully capture the global landslide trend.
  • Deviation in Simulation: There was a slight deviation between the simulated and actual displacements, and the model did not account for changes in landslide material strength over time.
  • Environmental Triggers Not Fully Integrated: Environmental triggers were not explicitly included as inputs to the deep learning model, which could further enhance prediction accuracy.
  • Hyperparameter Optimization: The authors acknowledge that not much effort was spent on hyperparameter optimization, suggesting that further tuning could lead to even more satisfactory results.
  • Integration of More Data: The paper suggests that integrating more geological observation data into the model training could lead to more accurate displacement predictions.
  • Future Work: The authors propose exploring the integration of more geological observation data and further optimizing hyperparameters for improved prediction.

Summary updated

Abstract

Effective landslide hazard prevention requires accurate landslide prediction models, and the data-driven approaches based on deep learning models are gradually becoming a hot research topic. When training deep learning models, it is always preferable to have a large dataset, while most available landslide monitoring data are limited. For data missing or data sparseness problems, conventional interpolation methods based on mathematical knowledge lack mechanism interpretability. This paper proposes that numerical simulations can be used to expand the deep learning dataset we need. Taking the Jiuxianping landslide in the Three Gorges Reservoir Area (TGRA) as the geological background, a finite element numerical model was established, and the landslide displacement time series data were solved considering the boundary conditions of reservoir water level change and precipitation. Next, based on three metrics: Euclidean distance, cosine similarity, and dynamic time warping (DTW) distance, the time series similarity between the displacement data obtained from simulation and data obtained from actual monitoring were verified. Finally, the combined deep learning model was built to predict the displacement of the Jiuxianping landslide. The model was trained on both the simulated and monitored datasets and tested by the last 12 monitored data points. Prediction results with the testing set showed that the models trained using the expanded training set from numerical simulations exhibited lower prediction errors, and the errors had a more concentrated distribution. The results suggest that this landslide displacement prediction method combining numerical simulation and deep learning can solve the problem of inadequate datasets due to low monitoring frequency, as well as provide an interpretation of the physical mechanism for data vacancy filling.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{xu2022combining,
  author = {Wenhan Xu and Hong Xu and Jie Chen and Yanfei Kang and Yuanyuan Pu and Yabo Ye and Jue Tong},
  title = {{Combining Numerical Simulation and Deep Learning for Landslide Displacement Prediction: An Attempt to Expand the Deep Learning Dataset}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/su14116908},
}
Figure