Combining Myopic Optimization and Tree Search: Application to MineSweeper

Michèle Sébag, Olivier Teytaud2013

TL;DR

This paper proposes a novel methodology for tackling complex reactive planning problems by combining a powerful tree search algorithm (UCT) with a specialized solver. This hybrid approach aims to overcome the limitations of traditional myopic methods, offering a path towards more optimal decision-making in challenging environments like the game of MineSweeper.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Many real-world problems, such as robotics or game playing, involve making decisions under uncertainty and with incomplete information. Traditional approaches often simplify these problems by focusing on immediate consequences (myopic optimization) using readily available solvers. While this is computationally efficient and can yield good results, it inherently sacrifices long-term optimality. The challenge is to leverage the strengths of both fast, myopic solvers and more powerful, but computationally expensive, search algorithms to achieve better performance without prohibitive computational costs. The authors specifically target the game of MineSweeper, a classic example of a partially observable problem where myopic strategies are common but suboptimal.

Methods

The core of the paper's contribution lies in a new methodology that embeds a solver within an Upper Confidence Tree (UCT) algorithm. UCT is a well-established Monte-Carlo Tree Search technique known for its ability to handle problems with little to no prior knowledge. The authors propose using a Constraint Satisfaction Problem (CSP) solver in two key ways:

  • Belief State Estimation: CSP is used to accurately estimate the "belief state," which is the probability distribution over all possible hidden states of the environment given the current observations. This transforms a Partially Observable Markov Decision Process (POMDP) into a standard Markov Decision Process (MDP), making it amenable to UCT.
  • Heuristic Move Suggestion: CSP also provides heuristic guidance for suggesting "good" moves, particularly those with a low probability of immediate failure. This complements UCT's exploration by providing informed initial steps.

The paper also explores other belief state estimation methods, including a simple rejection method and Markov-Chain Monte-Carlo (MCMC), but ultimately favors their proposed CSP-enhanced UCT approach for its consistency and effectiveness.

Datasets

The paper uses the game of MineSweeper as its primary testbed. They evaluate their approach on various configurations of the game, including:

  • A "Gnomine Custom mode" with a specific rule for the first move (no mines in the immediate neighborhood), applied to a 5x5 board with 15 mines.
  • The "Windows version" of MineSweeper with different board sizes and mine counts, comparing against existing CSP implementations.

No new datasets were introduced; the focus was on applying the methodology to a well-known benchmark.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Bridging the Gap: The paper demonstrates that combining a fast, specialized solver (CSP) with a powerful search algorithm (UCT) can effectively bridge the gap between myopic and optimal decision-making.
  • CSP as a Belief State Estimator: CSP, traditionally used for myopic play, is repurposed as a crucial component for accurately estimating the belief state in POMDPs, enabling UCT to operate on a fully observable MDP representation.
  • Asymptotic Optimality: The proposed approach, termed BSSUCT (Belief State Solver + Upper Confidence Trees), is shown to be asymptotically consistent, meaning it will find the optimal strategy given sufficient computational time.
  • Suboptimality of Pure CSP: The paper highlights that even sophisticated CSP-based approaches can be suboptimal, particularly in their handling of initial moves and long-term consequences, as demonstrated in a simple 3x3 MineSweeper scenario.
  • Heuristics Enhance Search: The integration of CSP-derived heuristics within UCT not only improves the belief state estimation but also guides the search more effectively, leading to better performance.

Key Results

  • Improved Winning Rates: The BSSUCT approach consistently outperforms the CSP-PGMS implementation in various MineSweeper configurations. For example, on a 5x5 board with 15 mines (Gnomine rules), their algorithm finds the optimal winning strategy in 5 seconds, whereas CSP does not inherently provide guidance on the initial move.
  • Quantitative Improvements: Table 2 shows winning rates for different MineSweeper formats. For instance, on a 15 mines on a 5x5 board, BSSUCT achieves a 0.9% winning rate compared to CSP-PGMS's 0.63%. While these percentages might seem small, they represent significant improvements in a challenging game where winning rates are generally low.
  • Scalability: The paper suggests that while CSP's performance plateaus with increased computation time, their UCT-based approach continues to improve, demonstrating its potential for more complex scenarios.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Computational Cost: The authors acknowledge that their CSP module is slower than existing CSP implementations like CSP-PGMS. This limits the speed of their current approach, especially for expert-level MineSweeper configurations.
  • Future Work: The authors plan to focus on optimizing the CSP module for faster performance, enabling them to tackle expert modes more effectively and compare with other state-of-the-art results. They also intend to explore other variants of MineSweeper and potentially apply their methodology to other challenging decision-making problems.

Summary updated

Abstract

Many reactive planning tasks are tackled by optimization combined with shrinking horizon at each time step: the problem is simplified to a non-reactive (myopic) optimization problem, based on the available information at the current time step and an estimate of future behavior, then it is solved; and the simplified problem is updated at each time step thanks to new information. This is in particular suitable when fast off-the-shelf components are available for the simplified problem-optimality stricto sensu is not possible, but good results are obtained at a reasonnable computational cost for highly untractable problems. As machines get more powerful, it makes sense however to go beyond the inherent limitations of this approach. Yet, a brute-force solving of the complete problem is often impossible; we here propose a methodology for embedding a solver inside a consistent reactive planning solver. Our methodology consists in embedding the solver in an Upper-Confidence-Tree algorithm, both in the nodes and as a Monte-Carlo simulator. We show the mathematical consistency of the approach, and then we apply it to a classical success of the myopic approach: the MineSweeper game. 1
BibTeX
@misc{sebag2013combining,
  author = {Michèle Sébag and Olivier Teytaud},
  title = {{Combining Myopic Optimization and Tree Search: Application to MineSweeper}},
  year = {2013},
}

Loading related content...

Figure