Combining Multiple Remediation Techniques Is Effective for the Remediation of Eutrophic Flowing Water

Ran Luo, Wei Li, Jiayou Zhong, Taotao Dai, Jinfu Liu, Xiaoliang Zhang, Yuwei Chen, Guiqing GaoWater 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This study demonstrates that combining dredging, a novel calcium-loaded clay granular adsorbent (CRB), and phytoremediation is highly effective for restoring eutrophic flowing water, outperforming single treatments. The synergistic approach significantly reduced phosphorus, turbidity, and CODMn, while also enhancing nutrient removal and stabilizing water quality, offering a promising strategy for managing disturbed aquatic ecosystems.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Eutrophication, driven by excessive nitrogen (N) and phosphorus (P) enrichment, is a major threat to aquatic ecosystems, leading to algal blooms and oxygen depletion. While dredging, adsorbent inactivation, and phytoremediation are established techniques for controlling internal nutrient loads in still waters, their effectiveness in dynamic, disturbed environments like rivers and lakes with significant water flow remains less understood. Existing adsorbents, like lanthanum-modified bentonite, also raise concerns about resource scarcity and potential toxicity. This paper addresses the need to evaluate combined remediation strategies in flowing water systems and introduces a more eco-friendly adsorbent.

Methods

The researchers designed an experimental setup using 12 flumes to simulate hydrodynamic circulation in flowing water. They tested four treatment groups: a control (CK), dredging (removing 2 cm of surface sediment), CRB inactivation (adding a calcium-loaded clay granular adsorbent), and a combined Dredge + CRB treatment. The CRB was applied multiple times throughout the experiment. Following these physical and chemical treatments, three submerged plant species (Vallisneria natans, Hydrilla verticillata, and Potamogeton maackianus) were introduced for phytoremediation. Water quality parameters (TP, SRP, TN, NH4+-N, CODMn, pH, EC, turbidity) were monitored regularly. Sediment and plant samples were analyzed for nutrient content and phosphorus speciation at the experiment's conclusion.

Datasets

The study utilized experimental data collected from the flume system. Sediments and water were sourced from Nanhu, a sub-lake of Poyang Lake, China. No pre-existing datasets were used for training or evaluation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Synergy is Key: Combining dredging and CRB treatment significantly enhanced nutrient removal and turbidity reduction compared to either method alone, highlighting the power of integrated approaches.
  • CRB's Efficacy: The novel CRB adsorbent proved effective in reducing phosphorus and turbidity, and while it initially increased N and CODMn, its long-term impact was beneficial, especially when combined with dredging.
  • Phytoremediation as a Booster: Introducing submerged plants after physical and chemical treatments further improved water quality, demonstrating phytoremediation's crucial role in stabilizing and enhancing restoration outcomes.
  • Plant Species Matter: Different submerged plant species exhibited distinct growth rates and phosphorus uptake patterns, suggesting that careful selection of species is vital for successful phytoremediation.
  • Flowing Water Challenges: The study acknowledges that water flow can complicate the effectiveness of dredging, potentially counteracting some benefits by increasing nutrient resuspension.

Key Results

  • Phosphorus and Turbidity Reduction: CRB treatment alone reduced water phosphorus by 63% and turbidity by 80%. The combined Dredge + CRB treatment showed even greater improvements.
  • Nutrient Dynamics: While CRB initially increased TN and CODMn, the combined Dredge + CRB treatment led to a 13% and 15% decrease in TN and CODMn, respectively, compared to CRB alone.
  • Sediment Nutrient Impact: Dredging alone did not significantly alter sediment nutrient indexes compared to the control, but it enhanced the CRB treatment's effectiveness.
  • Plant Growth Variation: Hydrilla verticillata showed the highest growth rate, followed by Vallisneria natans, while Potamogeton maackianus had the slowest growth.
  • Phosphorus Speciation in Plants: Significant interspecific differences were observed in the phosphorus speciation within the submerged plants, with implications for nutrient cycling and potential P release upon plant death.

Limitations and Future Work

The study was conducted under simulated hydrodynamic conditions, and the long-term effectiveness and potential risks of CRB in real-world flowing water systems require further investigation. The authors also highlight the need for further research into the risk of P re-release from submerged plant tissues upon degradation, particularly for species like V. natans and H. vericillata which accumulate reactive P. Future work should focus on optimizing the selection of submerged plant species for specific environmental conditions and remediation goals.

Summary updated

Abstract

Dredging, adsorbent inactivation, and phytoremediation are commonly used to control internal nitrogen and phosphorus sediment loads in eutrophic still-water ecosystems, such as lakes and ponds. However, the effectiveness of these remediation techniques has not been verified for rivers, lakes, and reservoirs with large disturbances. In this study, a calcium-loaded clay granular adsorbent (CRB) was prepared as an alternative to commercial adsorbents, and an experiment was conducted on the ecological restoration effects of both dredging and adsorbent single treatments as well as combined treatments on eutrophic flowing water. The enhancement effect of phytoremediation on the above restoration techniques was investigated. The results indicated that CRB inactivation treatment reduced the phosphorus and turbidity of the water by 63% and 80%, respectively and increased the total nitrogen and permanganate index (CODMn) by 25% and 101% before phytoremediation, respectively compared to the control group. There were no significant differences in the nutrient indexes of the sediment and water between the dredging treatment and the control group, but dredging enhanced the effect of the CRB treatment. Compared with the CRB treatment, the total nitrogen and CODMn of water in the dredging and combined CRB treatments decreased by 13% and 15%, respectively. Phytoremediation significantly improved the effectiveness of the dredging and adsorbent treatments, both individually and in combination. Additionally, there were notable differences in the growth rates of the submerged plants and the contents of different phosphorus speciation among the plant species. Selecting suitable plant species is recommended when implementing phytoremediation methods. This study highlights that the combination of multiple restoration techniques is effective for eutrophic flowing water. The results provide a guide for the ecological restoration of flowing water.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{luo2024combining,
  author = {Ran Luo and Wei Li and Jiayou Zhong and Taotao Dai and Jinfu Liu and Xiaoliang Zhang and Yuwei Chen and Guiqing Gao},
  title = {{Combining Multiple Remediation Techniques Is Effective for the Remediation of Eutrophic Flowing Water}},
  booktitle = {Water},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3390/w16060858},
}
Figure