Combining GRA with a Fuzzy QFD Model for the New Product Design and Development of Wickerwork Lamps

Tianxiong Wang, Yang LiuSustainability 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel framework combining Grey Relational Analysis (GRA) and Fuzzy Quality Function Deployment (QFD) to bridge the gap between customer emotional needs and concrete product design parameters for wickerwork lamps. By systematically translating subjective user preferences into actionable design specifications, the method aims to improve product development efficiency and customer satisfaction in the growing market for sustainable, culturally rich products.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In today's competitive market, understanding and meeting rapidly evolving customer requirements is crucial for product success. For products like wickerwork lamps, which blend sustainability with cultural heritage, customer perception and emotional satisfaction (Kansei) are paramount. However, translating these subjective, often vague, emotional preferences into specific, quantifiable design parameters is a significant challenge for designers. Traditional methods often struggle with the ambiguity and uncertainty inherent in user feedback, leading to design decisions that may not fully resonate with customers. This paper aims to address this by providing a structured approach to capture and translate these emotional demands into effective design solutions.

Methods

The study proposes a three-phase framework:

  1. Evaluation Grid Method (EGM) for Attractiveness Factors: Leveraging Miryoku Engineering, the researchers used EGM to conduct interviews with subject groups. This method helps to identify and categorize user perceptions into three levels: abstract emotional phrases (upper level), original evaluation items (middle level), and specific design conditions (lower level). This process aims to uncover the "charm factors" of wickerwork lamps.
  2. Grey Relational Analysis (GRA) for Prioritization: GRA is employed to objectively determine the relative importance and weight of the identified emotional needs (upper-level Kansei words). This helps in prioritizing key user needs and understanding the underlying abstract feelings associated with product styles. GRA is particularly useful for analyzing systems with limited data and unclear relationships.
  3. Fuzzy Quality Function Deployment (QFD) for Mapping: Fuzzy QFD is used to establish a "quality house" that maps emotional needs (customer requirements) to specific design parameters (engineering characteristics). This method effectively handles the inherent ambiguity and uncertainty in user feedback by using fuzzy logic, allowing for a more accurate translation of subjective preferences into concrete design specifications. This helps in deriving optimal design parameters.

Datasets

The study utilized two main sources of data:

  • Image Samples: 80 images of wickerwork lamp products were collected, from which 35 representative samples were selected after filtering. These were then cropped into 10 cm x 10 cm cards for subject evaluation.
  • Expert Interviews:
    • EGM Phase: 12 subjects (6 male, 6 female, aged 22-49, with industrial design experience) participated in experimental interviews to identify attractiveness factors.
  • GRA Phase: 146 experts (60 male, 86 female, aged 23-45, with industrial design experience) were invited to conduct perceptual assessments.
  • Fuzzy QFD Phase: 22 experts (11 male, 11 female, aged 20-29, with university degrees or higher) formed a focus group to determine the strength of correlations between customer requirements and engineering features.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Bridging the Subjective-Objective Divide: The core innovation lies in systematically translating fuzzy, emotional customer preferences (like "bright," "smooth") into quantifiable design parameters (like specific textures, materials, colors, shapes, and styles).
  • Prioritizing Emotional Needs: GRA effectively identifies and ranks the most influential emotional factors, ensuring that design efforts are focused on what truly matters to customers.
  • Handling Uncertainty: Fuzzy QFD is crucial for managing the inherent ambiguity in user feedback, leading to more robust and reliable design parameter selection.
  • Cultural Heritage Meets Modern Design: The study specifically targets wickerwork lamps, a traditional craft, demonstrating how modern design methodologies can be applied to revitalize and enhance cultural heritage products for contemporary markets.

Key Results

The study identified the following as the most preferred design elements for wickerwork lamps:

  • Texture: Pattern 1 type (likely referring to a specific texture identified in the study, e.g., "Light transmittance").
  • Material: Material 1 type (e.g., "Simple wickerwork").
  • Color: Colour 5 type (e.g., "Wicker primary colours").
  • Shape: Shape 3 type (e.g., "Cascaded type").
  • Design Style: Design Style 2 type (e.g., "Pastoral style").

The research suggests that a combination of these elements leads to the most attractive product design, effectively reducing ambiguity and uncertainty in the design process.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations and suggest future research directions:

  • Data Collection: The study relied on traditional interviews for demand acquisition, which captures a static view of customer needs. Future work could incorporate dynamic methods like text mining and natural language processing to capture evolving customer preferences.
  • Cultural Scope: The study focused on Chinese consumers. Expanding the research to include participants from other countries would provide a more global perspective on attractiveness factors.
  • Design Detail: While the study identified key design elements, future research could explore more imaginative and inspired designs using advanced digital technology, moving beyond traditional forms and shapes.
  • Scope of Analysis: The current study focused on the morphological changes of luminaire design. Future work could extend to size, structure, and brand, potentially analyzing specific brands to guide new product development more effectively.
  • Subjectivity of Adjectives: While EGM provides detailed hierarchies, the use of adjectives to capture expert opinions might not fully encompass the semantic space of products, and future research could explore more nuanced ways to represent subjective emotions.

Summary updated

Abstract

With the popularization of the concept of sustainability in traditional wickerwork, wickerwork lamps have become the most popular production. When customers purchase wickerwork lamp products, the Kansei consensus has become a key factor influencing the communication between manufacturers and customers. Therefore, the purpose of this paper is to explore the product design solutions for wickerwork lamps that meet the emotional satisfaction of users. Firstly, a three-level evaluation grid diagram driven by user attractiveness through Miryoku Engineering is established. Secondly, this paper uses grey relational analysis (GRA) to extract the priority order and its weight values in the perceptual vocabulary to identify the key user needs in product design. In order to effectively deal with the uncertain product evaluation information, the fuzzy quality function deployment (QFD) is used to construct the “emotional demand-design parameter” transformation model and derive the optimal design parameters in the mapping process, thus effectively reducing the ambiguity and uncertainty in the demand transformation process. Based on the experimental results, it is found that the best combination of Texture light transmittance, Simple wickerwork material, Wickerwork primary colours, Cascaded type and Pastoral style could be preferred by customers, thus this proposed method can effectively reduce the ambiguity and uncertainty in the design process. The results of study enable designers to accurately grasp customers’ perceptions of wickerwork lamp products and obtain the best design parameters for wickerwork lamp products.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wang2023combining,
  author = {Tianxiong Wang and Yang Liu},
  title = {{Combining GRA with a Fuzzy QFD Model for the New Product Design and Development of Wickerwork Lamps}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/su15054208},
}
Figure