Combining experiments and simulations to examine the temperature-dependent behaviour of a disordered protein

Francesco Pesce, Kresten Lindorff‐LarsenbioRxiv 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper uses molecular dynamics simulations and experimental data to investigate how temperature affects the structure and behavior of Histatin 5, a disordered protein. By combining different experimental techniques and advanced simulation methods, the researchers aim to bridge the gap between atomistic simulations and real-world protein behavior, highlighting the challenges and importance of integrating diverse data for a comprehensive understanding.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Intrinsically disordered proteins (IDPs) are a fascinating class of proteins that lack a stable, fixed 3D structure. Instead, they exist as a dynamic ensemble of conformations, which is crucial for their function. Understanding how these proteins behave, especially how their structure changes with environmental factors like temperature, is a significant challenge. Previous studies have shown that temperature can influence the compactness and secondary structure of IDPs, but the precise mechanisms and the interplay between different structural features remain unclear. This paper specifically tackles the question of how temperature affects the conformational ensemble of Histatin 5, a small, well-studied IDP, and aims to reconcile discrepancies observed between different experimental techniques and computational models.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach:

  • Molecular Dynamics (MD) Simulations: They used all-atom MD simulations with the Amber ff99SB-disp force field to generate conformational ensembles of Histatin 5 at various temperatures (283 K, 293 K, 310 K, and 323 K).
  • Enhanced Sampling (Parallel Bias Metadynamics - PBMetaD): To improve the sampling of the complex conformational landscape of Histatin 5, they utilized PBMetaD. This technique employs history-dependent bias potentials to guide the simulations through relevant conformational states, accelerating the exploration of the free-energy surface.
  • Ensemble Reweighting (Bayesian/Maximum Entropy - BME): To reconcile discrepancies between simulations and experimental data, they applied BME reweighting. This method adjusts the weights of simulation frames to better match experimental observables, allowing for a more accurate representation of the protein's behavior under specific conditions. They applied this independently to SAXS and PFG NMR data, and then simultaneously to both.
  • Calculation of Experimental Observables: They calculated SAXS intensities, hydrodynamic radii (Rh), and per-residue secondary structure propensities from their simulations to compare with experimental data.

Datasets

The study utilized previously published experimental data for Histatin 5, specifically:

  • Small-Angle X-ray Scattering (SAXS) data: Used to probe the overall chain dimension (radius of gyration, Rg).
  • Pulsed-Field Gradient Nuclear Magnetic Resonance (PFG NMR) spectroscopy data: Used to determine the hydrodynamic radius (Rh).
  • Circular Dichroism (CD) spectroscopy data: Used to infer information about secondary structure content, particularly Polyproline II (PPII) structure.

The paper does not introduce new benchmark datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The challenge of integrating diverse experimental data: The study highlights the difficulty in achieving a single computational model that perfectly matches multiple experimental techniques simultaneously. Different experiments probe different aspects of protein structure and dynamics, and their inherent limitations and sensitivities can lead to apparent discrepancies.
  • Reweighting as a powerful reconciliation tool: BME reweighting proved crucial in improving the agreement between simulations and experimental data, particularly for the hydrodynamic radius. This demonstrates its utility in refining conformational ensembles to better reflect experimental observations.
  • The link between Rh and PPII structure: Reweighting against Rh data revealed a correlation between increased Rh and a higher propensity for PPII structure. This provides a molecular-level explanation for the observed temperature-dependent decrease in Rh and the associated changes in PPII content suggested by CD data.
  • Force field limitations: The study suggests that while the ff99SB-disp force field provides a reasonable description of SAXS data, it may underestimate the hydrodynamic radius (Rh) of Histatin 5 and might not fully capture the temperature-dependent changes in PPII structure.

Key Results

  • SAXS agreement: The initial MD simulations showed good agreement with SAXS data (χ² close to 1), indicating that the conformational ensembles captured the overall chain dimensions as measured by SAXS. However, the Rg derived from simulations was consistently smaller than that from Guinier fitting of SAXS data, likely due to the inclusion of hydration layers in the experimental Rg.
  • Rh discrepancies: The calculated Rh values from simulations were consistently lower than experimental values from PFG NMR.
  • PPII structure: Initial simulations showed minimal temperature-dependent changes in PPII structure content.
  • Reweighting against Rh: Reweighting the simulations against PFG NMR data significantly improved the agreement for Rh. This reweighting also led to an observed increase in PPII structure content, aligning qualitatively with CD data.
  • Reweighting against SAXS: Reweighting against SAXS data improved the fit to SAXS profiles but did not substantially alter Rh or PPII structure propensity.
  • Simultaneous reweighting: Attempting to reweight against both SAXS and Rh simultaneously resulted in a compromise, with the SAXS data dominating the refinement due to its larger number of data points.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Force field accuracy: The authors acknowledge that the force field used might underestimate Rh and not fully capture temperature-dependent changes in PPII structure. This is a common challenge in simulating IDPs.
  • Experimental conditions: Minor differences in experimental conditions (pH, ionic strength) between SAXS and NMR experiments could contribute to observed discrepancies.
  • Rh calculation uncertainties: There are inherent complexities and uncertainties in calculating Rh from conformational ensembles and in experimental determination of Rh.
  • CD spectrum calculation: The lack of accurate methods to calculate CD spectra from disordered protein ensembles limits direct comparison and validation of secondary structure predictions.

Future Work:

  • Development of improved forward models: Particularly for CD spectroscopy, to enable more direct quantitative comparisons.
  • Study of more IDPs: Investigating other IDPs with similar features to see if the observed behavior is generalizable.
  • Exploration of alternative force fields: To better capture Rh and temperature-dependent secondary structure changes.
  • More detailed investigation of experimental conditions: To understand the impact of pH and ionic strength on Histatin 5's behavior.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Intrinsically disordered proteins are a class of proteins that lack stable folded conformations and instead adopt a range of conformations that determine their biochemical functions. The temperature-dependent behaviour of such disordered proteins is complex and can vary depending on the specific protein and environment. Here, we have used molecular dynamics simulations and previously published experimental data to investigate the temperature-dependent behaviour of Histatin 5, a 24-residue-long polypeptide. We examined the hypothesis that Histatin 5 undergoes a loss of polyproline II structure with increasing temperature, leading to more compact conformations. We found that the conformational ensembles generated by the simulations generally agree with small-angle X-ray scattering data for Histatin 5, but show some discrepancies with the hydrodynamic radius as probed by pulsed-field gradient nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy, and with the secondary structure information derived from circular dichroism. We attempted to reconcile these differences by reweighting the conformational ensembles against the scattering and NMR data. By doing so, we were in part able to capture the temperature-dependent behaviour of Histatin 5 and to link the observed decrease in hydrodynamic radius with increasing temperature to a loss of polyproline II structure. We were, however, unable to achieve agreement with both the scattering and NMR data within experimental errors. We discuss different possibilities for this outcome including inaccuracies in the force field, differences in conditions of the NMR and scattering experiments, and issues related to the calculation of the hydrodynamic radius from conformational ensembles. Our study highlights the importance of integrating multiple types of experimental data when modelling conformational ensembles of disordered proteins and how environmental factors such as the temperature influence them.
BibTeX
@misc{pesce2023combining,
  author = {Francesco Pesce and Kresten Lindorff‐Larsen},
  title = {{Combining experiments and simulations to examine the temperature-dependent behaviour of a disordered protein}},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1101/2023.03.04.531094},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure