Combined Ultrasound Imaging and Biomechanical Modeling to Estimate Triceps Brachii Musculotendon Changes in Stroke Survivors

Le Li, Raymond Kai‐Yu TongBioMed 2016 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents a novel approach combining ultrasound imaging and biomechanical modeling to create subject-specific models of elbow extensor muscles in stroke survivors. This method reveals significant reductions in maximum isometric muscle stress in stroke survivors, offering a deeper understanding of motor deficits and potential avenues for rehabilitation.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Stroke survivors often experience significant motor impairments, including weakness and spasticity, which severely impact their ability to perform everyday activities. While the general mechanisms of these deficits are known, understanding the specific changes in muscle and tendon properties at an individual level is crucial for effective rehabilitation. Existing biomechanical models often rely on generic parameters, which may not accurately reflect the unique physiological adaptations in stroke survivors. This study aims to bridge this gap by developing a subject-specific modeling technique that incorporates in vivo ultrasound measurements to capture individual musculotendon characteristics, specifically focusing on the triceps brachii, a key elbow extensor.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-faceted approach:

  • Subject-Specific Biomechanical Modeling: They utilized a modified Hill-type muscle model to simulate the force-generating capabilities of the triceps brachii. This model incorporates force-length and force-velocity relationships, as well as tendon elasticity.
  • In Vivo Ultrasound Imaging: B-mode ultrasound was used to non-invasively measure key muscle architectural parameters, specifically the pennation angle and optimal fascicle length of the three heads of the triceps brachii (medial, lateral, and long). These measurements were taken at various joint angles during both resting and isometric contraction states.
  • Model Parameter Optimization: The ultrasound-derived parameters were integrated into the biomechanical model to reduce the number of unknown variables. An optimization algorithm was then used to minimize the difference between predicted and measured elbow extension torques, allowing for the estimation of parameters like maximum isometric muscle stress.
  • Experimental Setup: Subjects performed isometric elbow extension tasks while their torque output and surface EMG signals were recorded. The experimental setup included a custom dynamometer and an orthosis to ensure consistent positioning and movement.

What's novel here is the direct integration of subject-specific ultrasound data to constrain and refine the biomechanical model, moving beyond generic or cadaver-based parameters.

Datasets

The study recruited two groups of participants:

  • Five chronic stroke survivors (duration of stroke > 1 year).
  • Five age- and sex-matched healthy control subjects.

The paper does not introduce a new benchmark dataset but rather uses the collected data from these participants for model development and evaluation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Ultrasound as a Powerful Tool for Subject-Specific Modeling: The study demonstrates the feasibility and value of using in vivo ultrasound measurements to obtain crucial muscle architectural parameters that can significantly improve the accuracy of biomechanical models.
  • Triceps Brachii Architecture Varies with Joint Angle: Pennation angles of the triceps brachii were found to change with elbow joint position, highlighting the dynamic nature of muscle architecture during movement.
  • Stroke Survivors Exhibit Reduced Muscle Stress: A key finding is the significantly lower maximum isometric muscle stress observed in the triceps brachii of stroke survivors compared to healthy individuals. This suggests a fundamental deficit in the muscle's intrinsic force-generating capacity.
  • Model Accuracy Differs Between Groups: While the biomechanical model accurately predicted torque-angle relationships for healthy subjects, prediction errors were larger for stroke survivors. This points to the complexity of motor control and potential co-contraction issues in stroke.

Key Results

  • Pennation Angles: Pennation angles varied with joint angles. The long head of the triceps in stroke survivors showed a smaller pennation angle than reported literature values.
  • Maximum Isometric Muscle Stress ($\sigma_m$): The maximum isometric muscle stress in the triceps brachii of stroke survivors was significantly smaller (mean $\pm$ SD: 50.8 $\pm$ 18.6 N/cm²) than in the unimpaired group (89.3 $\pm$ 21.8 N/cm², p = 0.023).
  • Torque Prediction: The model's predicted joint torque closely matched measured data for control subjects. However, prediction errors were larger for stroke survivors, particularly at more extended joint positions.
  • Muscle Optimal Length and Tendon Slack Length: While muscle optimal lengths were similar between groups, tendon slack lengths showed significant differences, with the medial head of the triceps having a smaller tendon slack length in both groups.

Limitations and Future Work

  • PCSA Estimation: The study acknowledges that the calculation of Physiological Cross-Sectional Area (PCSA) relied on scaling from literature data, which may lead to an underestimation of muscle stress. Future work could involve more direct ultrasound measurements of PCSA.
  • Muscle Activation Assumption: The model assumed full muscle activation (a(t)=1) for maximum isometric contractions. This assumption may not hold true for stroke survivors due to potential deficits in neural drive and motor control, contributing to prediction errors.
  • Co-contraction and Motor Control: The increased prediction error in stroke survivors may be partly due to factors like co-contraction of antagonist muscles (e.g., elbow flexors) and impaired motor control, which were not fully accounted for in this specific model.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest that this subject-specific modeling approach can be valuable for evaluating functional improvements after interventions and for enhancing the understanding of how stroke affects muscle architecture and motor function. Further research could explore the impact of different rehabilitation strategies on these parameters and refine the model to better account for motor control deficits.

Summary updated

Abstract

The aim of this study was to investigate the changes of musculotendon parameters of triceps brachii in persons after stroke based on subject-specific biomechanical modeling technique combined with in vivo ultrasound measurement. Five chronic stroke survivors and five normal control subjects were recruited. B-mode ultrasound was applied to measure muscle pennation angle and the optimal length of three heads of triceps' brachii at different joint angle positions in resting and isometric contraction. Measured ultrasound data were used to reduce the unknown parameters during the modeling optimization process. The results showed that pennation angles varied with joint angles, and the longhead TRI pennation from stroke group was smaller than the literature value. The maximum isometric muscle stress from persons after stroke was significantly smaller than that found in the unimpaired subjects. The prediction of joint torque fits well with the measured data from the control group, whereas the prediction error is larger in results from persons after stroke. In vivo parameters from ultrasound data could help to build a subject-specific biomechanical model of elbow extensor for both unimpaired and hemiplegic subjects, and then the results driven from the model could enhance the understanding of motor function changes for persons after stroke.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{li2016combined,
  author = {Le Li and Raymond Kai‐Yu Tong},
  title = {{Combined Ultrasound Imaging and Biomechanical Modeling to Estimate Triceps Brachii Musculotendon Changes in Stroke Survivors}},
  booktitle = {BioMed},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.1155/2016/5275768},
}
Figure