Combined Transcriptome Analysis Reveals the Ovule Abortion Regulatory Mechanisms in the Female Sterile Line of Pinus tabuliformis Carr.

Zaixin Gong, Rui Han, Li Xu, Hailin Hu, Min Zhang, Qianquan Yang, Zeng Ming, Yuanyuan Zhao, Caixia ZhengInternational Journal of Molecular Sciences 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates the molecular mechanisms behind ovule abortion in Pinus tabuliformis Carr., a common issue impacting seed production. By combining long-read (SMRT) and short-read (NGS) sequencing, researchers identified key differences in gene expression and alternative splicing between fertile and sterile ovules, highlighting the roles of auxin, energy metabolism, and cell division in this process.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Ovule abortion, the failure of an ovule to develop properly, is a significant problem in plant reproduction, directly affecting seed yield. While much research has focused on this phenomenon in model angiosperms like Arabidopsis thaliana, gymnosperms, which represent an earlier evolutionary branch, have been largely understudied. This is partly due to the difficulty in obtaining and analyzing ovule development in these species. Understanding ovule abortion in gymnosperms is crucial for improving breeding strategies and germplasm resources for economically important woody plants. This paper aims to shed light on the molecular basis of ovule abortion in Pinus tabuliformis Carr., a key conifer species, specifically during the free nuclear mitosis (FNM) stage.

Methods

The researchers employed a powerful combination of sequencing technologies:

  • Next-Generation Sequencing (NGS) (Illumina HiSeqTM 4000): This provided a high volume of short reads (961,064,004 paired-end reads) for quantitative analysis of gene expression.
  • Single-Molecule Real-Time (SMRT) Sequencing (PacBio RS II): This generated long reads (276,887 for FER and 307,741 for STE) which are crucial for accurately identifying full-length transcripts, alternative splicing (AS) events, and simple sequence repeats (SSRs).

This dual approach allowed for a more comprehensive and accurate transcriptome analysis than either method alone. They also used:

  • Quantitative Real-Time PCR (qRT-PCR): To validate the expression levels of selected differentially expressed genes (DEGs).
  • Bioinformatics Tools: For gene annotation (GO, KEGG), differential gene expression analysis (IDEG6), alternative splicing analysis (Cogent, SUPPA), and SSR prediction (MISA).

Datasets

The study utilized RNA samples from two lines of Pinus tabuliformis Carr.: a female fertile line (FER) and a naturally occurring female sterile line (STE). Samples were collected at three distinct developmental stages of ovule development during the free nuclear mitosis (FNM) process: early February (FNM1), early March (FNM2), and early April (FNM3). This resulted in 18 individual RNA-seq libraries and two pooled SMRT sequencing libraries (one for FER and one for STE). No new benchmark datasets were introduced; rather, existing sequencing platforms and analysis pipelines were leveraged.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Long-read sequencing is essential for complex transcriptomes: The study highlights how SMRT sequencing's long reads are critical for accurately capturing full-length transcripts and alternative splicing events, which short-read NGS can miss or misinterpret.
  • Alternative splicing is a major player in fertility: Significant differences in AS patterns were observed between fertile and sterile ovules, suggesting that AS plays a crucial role in regulating ovule development and fertility.
  • Auxin deficiency might be a root cause: Lower expression of auxin-related genes (like AUX/IAA, ARF2, TIR1) in sterile ovules points to a potential auxin insufficiency, which could hinder nuclear division and overall development.
  • Energy metabolism is critical for FNM: Genes involved in starch and sucrose metabolism and glycolysis showed differential expression, indicating that energy supply is vital for the rapid cell division occurring during FNM.
  • Apoptosis and stress response are implicated: Upregulation of apoptosis-related genes (like SOBIR1) and differential expression of stress response genes in sterile ovules suggest these processes are also involved in ovule abortion.

Key Results

  • Transcriptome complexity: The analysis revealed significant variability in the number of isoforms and alternative splicing patterns between FER and STE ovules.
  • Differentially expressed genes (DEGs): A substantial number of DEGs were identified, with many involved in auxin response, energy metabolism, signal transduction, cell division, and stress response.
  • Key gene expression differences: Genes like AUX/IAA, ARF2, SUS (sucrose synthase), and CYCB (cyclin B) showed significantly lower expression in STE ovules. Conversely, SOBIR1 (apoptosis-related) was upregulated in STE.
  • Alternative splicing variations: Seven AS modes were identified, with retained introns being the most common. Isoform diversity differed between FER and STE for genes like AGPL1, bHLH66, and TUBA.
  • SSR discovery: Over 40,000 potential SSRs were identified in each transcriptome, providing valuable resources for future genetic marker development in Pinus tabuliformis.
  • qRT-PCR validation: Expression profiles of nine candidate DEGs confirmed the transcriptomic analysis results, reinforcing the observed differences between FER and STE.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Focus on a single species: While Pinus tabuliformis is important, the findings may not be universally applicable to all gymnosperms.
  • Correlation vs. Causation: The study identifies genes and pathways associated with ovule abortion, but further functional studies (e.g., gene knockouts) are needed to establish direct causal relationships.
  • Complex interactions: The paper suggests multiple interacting pathways (auxin, energy, apoptosis, cell division) are involved. Future work could focus on dissecting these complex regulatory networks and their interplay.
  • SSR marker development: The identified SSRs provide a foundation for developing molecular markers, which can be used for marker-assisted breeding and genetic studies.
  • Functional validation of AS: While AS differences were observed, further investigation into the functional impact of specific isoforms on ovule development is warranted.

Summary updated

Abstract

Ovule abortion is a common phenomenon in plants that has an impact on seed production. Previous studies of ovule and female gametophyte (FG) development have mainly focused on angiosperms, especially in <i>Arabidopsis thaliana</i>. However, because it is difficult to acquire information about ovule development in gymnosperms, this remains unclear. Here, we investigated the transcriptomic data of natural ovule abortion mutants (female sterile line, STE) and the wild type (female fertile line, FER) of <i>Pinus tabuliformis</i> Carr. to evaluate the mechanism of ovule abortion during the process of free nuclear mitosis (FNM). Using single-molecule real-time (SMRT) sequencing and next-generation sequencing (NGS), 18 cDNA libraries via Illumina and two normalized libraries via PacBio, with a total of almost 400,000 reads, were obtained. Our analysis showed that the numbers of isoforms and alternative splicing (AS) patterns were significantly variable between FER and STE. The functional annotation results demonstrate that genes involved in the auxin response, energy metabolism, signal transduction, cell division, and stress response were differentially expressed in different lines. In particular, <i>AUX/IAA</i>, <i>ARF2</i>, <i>SUS</i>, and <i>CYCB</i> had significantly lower expression in STE, showing that auxin might be insufficient in STE, thus hindering nuclear division and influencing metabolism. Apoptosis in STE might also have affected the expression levels of these genes. To confirm the transcriptomic analysis results, nine pairs were confirmed by quantitative real-time PCR. Taken together, these results provide new insights into ovule abortion in gymnosperms and further reveal the regulatory mechanisms of ovule development.
BibTeX
@article{gong2021combined,
  author = {Zaixin Gong and Rui Han and Li Xu and Hailin Hu and Min Zhang and Qianquan Yang and Zeng Ming and Yuanyuan Zhao and Caixia Zheng},
  title = {{Combined Transcriptome Analysis Reveals the Ovule Abortion Regulatory Mechanisms in the Female Sterile Line of Pinus tabuliformis Carr.}},
  journal = {International Journal of Molecular Sciences},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.3390/ijms22063138},
}
Figure