Combined Prediction of Wind Power with Chaotic Time Series Analysis

Qiang Wang, Yang YangThe Open Automation and Control Systems Journal 2014 · DOI

Abstract

Wind power prediction is a critical technology for enhancing the stability and efficiency of power systems integrating renewable energy. This paper presents a combined forecasting model designed to mitigate the sensitivities of reconstructed parameters in chaotic time series analysis. By utilizing Phase Space Reconstruction (PSR) and an ensemble of neural networks, the model integrates information across different embedding dimensions. Experimental results from the Meijia wind farm demonstrate that a neural network-based combination of sub-models achieves a prediction error of less than 7%, significantly outperforming single-parameter and linear weighted models.

Introduction

As global energy systems transition toward sustainability, wind power has become a cornerstone of renewable energy portfolios. However, the inherent intermittency and randomness of wind speed present significant challenges for grid operators. Inaccurate forecasts can lead to grid instability or the costly maintenance of "spinning reserves"—backup power plants kept idling to compensate for sudden drops in wind output.

Traditional linear models often struggle to capture the complex, non-linear dynamics of wind. While chaos theory provides a framework for understanding such systems, its application is highly sensitive to the selection of reconstruction parameters, specifically the delay time ($\tau$) and the embedding dimension ($m$). This research addresses the limitations of single-parameter models by proposing a combined approach that leverages multiple perspectives of the system's chaotic structure.

Methodology: Chaos Verification and Reconstruction

The core of the proposed approach lies in Phase Space Reconstruction (PSR), based on Takens’ Theorem. This theorem posits that a single observed variable, such as wind power over time, contains sufficient information to reconstruct the multi-dimensional state of the entire underlying system.

Parameter Estimation

To reconstruct the phase space effectively, two parameters must be determined:

  1. Delay Time ($\tau$): Using the Mutual Information method, the researchers identified an optimal delay time of $\tau = 6$.
  2. Embedding Dimension ($m$): The Correlation Dimension method was employed to find the ideal dimension. By plotting the correlation integral against the scaling radius for various dimensions, the researchers determined that the system stabilizes at $m = 8$.
The correlation dimension method used to determine the optimal embedding dimension (m) for the chaotic system.

Proving Chaos

Before applying predictive models, it is essential to verify that the time series is indeed chaotic rather than purely random. The researchers calculated the Largest Lyapunov Exponent, which measures the rate of separation of infinitesimally close trajectories. A positive value (0.2548 in this study) mathematically confirms that the wind power series is chaotic, implying it is deterministic and predictable in the short term despite its apparent randomness.

The Combined Neural Network Model

Recognizing that any single embedding dimension might have "blind spots," the authors developed an ensemble approach. They constructed three separate Back-Propagation Neural Networks (BPNN), each using a different embedding dimension ($m=7, 8,$ and $9$). This allows the system to capture a broader range of the hidden dynamics.

Two methods of integration were tested:

  • Linear Weighted Combination: This method uses quadratic programming to assign fixed weights to each sub-model based on their historical performance.
  • Neural Network Combination: A second-tier "master" neural network is trained to synthesize the outputs of the three sub-models. This approach is superior because it can learn the non-linear relationships between the errors of the individual models.

Results and Discussion

The study utilized real-world data from a 3.0 MW turbine at the Meijia wind farm, sampled at 30-minute intervals. The data was filtered to the turbine's operational range (3 m/s to 15 m/s) to ensure relevance.

The proposed Neural Network Combination model emerged as the most accurate:

  • Single Model ($m=8$): 6.90% Absolute Average Error.
  • Linear Combination: 6.86% Absolute Average Error.
  • Neural Network Combination: 6.70% Absolute Average Error.
Comparison of actual wind power values versus the values predicted by the combined neural network model.

As shown in the performance plot, the prediction values closely track the actual fluctuations of the wind power series. While the 0.16% improvement over the linear model may seem marginal, in large-scale power grid management, such gains translate into substantial cost savings and significantly reduced risks of grid instability.

Conclusion

By treating wind power as a chaotic time series and employing a multi-model ensemble, this research provides a robust solution to the sensitivity issues inherent in phase space reconstruction. The neural network combination effectively integrates information from different embedding dimensions, leading to higher forecast accuracy. Future work may involve integrating Numerical Weather Prediction (NWP) data to extend the reliable forecasting horizon beyond the short-term window addressed here.

Summary updated

Abstract

Wind power prediction is one of the most significant technologies to promote the capability of the whole power system that takes in wind electricity. A combined model for wind power forecasting is presented to decrease the influence of reconstructed parameters by chaotic time series analysis and the neural networks (NNs) in this work. The combined model respectively makes use of linear weighted model and NNs method to achieve combination of several neural networks models through phase space reconstruction after wind power series chaotic characteristics acquisition, which can integrate information and reduce prediction error in different embedding dimension, leading to higher forecast accuracy. Simulation is performed to the real power time series from Meijia wind farm. The results show that the proposed model is more effective than single embedding dimension model and linear weighted combination model, and the prediction error of neural network combination is less than 7%.
BibTeX
@article{wang2014combined,
  author = {Qiang Wang and Yang Yang},
  title = {{Combined Prediction of Wind Power with Chaotic Time Series Analysis}},
  journal = {The Open Automation and Control Systems Journal},
  year = {2014},
  doi = {10.2174/1874444301406010117},
}
Figure