Combined mechanical ventilatory and mechanical circulatory support aids pulmonary vascular state in cardiogenic shock

Kimberly K. Lamberti, Elazer R. Edelman, Steven P. KellerIntensive 2025 · DOI

Abstract

These results demonstrate that combined used of cardiopulmonary support devices in cardiogenic shock can create variable responses compared to classic physiological understanding. In pVAD-supported cardiogenic shock, an increase in ventilatory PEEP increased unloading from the heart and improved right ventricular function, counter to traditional findings. This demonstrates that combined use of these technologies could be leveraged to optimize a patient's volume status in complex shock and provides promise for management of patients with cardiopulmonary failure requiring simultaneous use of mechanical circulatory support and mechanical ventilation.

Introduction

Managing cardiogenic shock—a state where the heart fails to meet the body's metabolic demands—requires a delicate balance of interventions. Patients often present with concomitant respiratory failure, necessitating the simultaneous use of mechanical ventilation and percutaneous ventricular assist devices (pVADs), such as the Impella pump.

Traditional physiological teaching suggests that increasing Positive End-Expiratory Pressure (PEEP) on a ventilator is a "double-edged sword." While beneficial for lung recruitment, it typically impairs cardiac function by increasing intrathoracic pressure, which reduces venous return and can strain the right ventricle (RV). However, the complex interactions between mechanical ventilation and mechanical circulatory support in the setting of acute shock are not fully understood. This study investigates whether these technologies can be combined to optimize, rather than compromise, a patient’s circulatory state.

Methods

The researchers employed a porcine model to simulate acute, titratable cardiogenic shock. Five intubated Yorkshire swine were studied across three distinct states: healthy baseline, healthy with pVAD support, and pVAD-supported cardiogenic shock (induced via coronary microembolization).

The experimental protocol involved "PEEP ramps," where ventilator pressure was systematically increased from 5 to 20 cmH2O. Hemodynamic responses were captured using invasive pressure-volume (PV) conductance catheters, allowing for real-time measurement of ventricular compliance, stroke work, and the recreation of Frank-Starling curves. The Impella CP served as the representative pVAD. Data were averaged over 30-second windows of hemodynamic stability for each PEEP interval.

Key Insights

The study revealed a surprising reversal of standard heart-lung interactions in the shock state. In a healthy heart, PEEP typically reduces cardiac output. However, in cardiogenic shock, the left ventricle (LV) is often severely congested and overfilled. In this context, the reduction in venous return caused by PEEP acts as a therapeutic "unloading" mechanism, preventing dangerous LV distension.

Furthermore, while PEEP is traditionally thought to stiffen pulmonary vasculature, the study found that in shock, if PEEP successfully lowers left ventricular end-diastolic pressure (LVEDP), it actually increases pulmonary vascular compliance. By clearing the "backlog" of blood in the lungs, the vessels become more flexible, which in turn can improve RV performance. This suggests that the pVAD and PEEP can work synergistically to reduce "backpressure" from the failing left heart.

Key Results

In the healthy state, increasing PEEP from 5 to 20 cmH2O led to a dramatic drop in LV stroke work (from 2593 to 740 mmHg*mL), confirming its inhibitory effect on normal cardiac output. In contrast, during shock, higher PEEP significantly reduced LVEDP, a key marker of congestion.

Hemodynamic responses across PEEP levels (5, 10, 15, 20 cmH2O) in pVAD-supported shock. Panels A and B show LV and RV pressure-volume loops. Panels C and D show the relationship between stroke volume (SV) and end-diastolic volume (EDV) for the LV and RV.

As shown in the pressure-volume loops, the cardiac loading conditions shift significantly with increasing PEEP. Notably, there was a strong correlation ($R^2 = 0.75$) between the improvement in pulmonary vascular compliance and the increase in RV stroke volume. When the lungs became more compliant due to LV unloading, the right heart's workload and efficiency improved. While PEEP increased the transpulmonary pressure gradient across all states, the underlying driver in shock was the beneficial drop in left-heart pressure rather than just increased airway pressure.

Discussion and Limitations

These findings challenge the traditional Frank-Starling paradigm by demonstrating that loading conditions can be manipulated via the ventilator to move a patient to a more favorable position on the cardiac performance curve.

However, several limitations apply. The small sample size (n=5) is typical for invasive physiological research but limits broader statistical generalization. The use of healthy lungs in the animal model may not perfectly replicate the pulmonary edema or ARDS often seen in human cardiogenic shock. Additionally, this acute model may not capture the vascular remodeling seen in chronic heart failure.

Future research should focus on models combining both cardiac and pulmonary injury. The authors advocate for clinical "ramp studies" to test whether adjusting PEEP and pVAD settings in tandem can provide patient-specific optimization in the ICU.

Summary updated

Abstract

These results demonstrate that combined used of cardiopulmonary support devices in cardiogenic shock can create variable responses compared to classic physiological understanding. In pVAD-supported cardiogenic shock, an increase in ventilatory PEEP increased unloading from the heart and improved right ventricular function, counter to traditional findings. This demonstrates that combined use of these technologies could be leveraged to optimize a patient's volume status in complex shock and provides promise for management of patients with cardiopulmonary failure requiring simultaneous use of mechanical circulatory support and mechanical ventilation.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{lamberti2025combined,
  author = {Kimberly K. Lamberti and Elazer R. Edelman and Steven P. Keller},
  title = {{Combined mechanical ventilatory and mechanical circulatory support aids pulmonary vascular state in cardiogenic shock}},
  booktitle = {Intensive},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1186/s40635-025-00811-2},
}
Figure