Combined Experimental and Computational Efforts to Establish Ion Mobility, Solubility and Stability of Functional Liquids for Electrochemical Energy Storage

Avni Singhal, Shi Jun Ang, Livia Giordano, Rafael Gómez‐Bombarelli, Yang Shao‐Horn2023 · DOI

Introduction

Lithium-air (Li-air) batteries represent a potential "holy grail" for electric vehicle energy storage due to a theoretical energy density comparable to gasoline. However, practical implementation is hindered by electrolyte instability. During discharge, these batteries produce superoxide radicals ($O_2^{\bullet-}$), aggressive nucleophiles that decompose organic electrolytes. This study, conducted by researchers at MIT and PNNL, addresses the challenge of identifying kinetically stable electrolytes through a combination of high-level quantum chemistry and automated computational screening.

Methodology

The research team utilized a two-pronged approach to evaluate electrolyte stability:

  1. User-Driven Benchmarking: High-accuracy manual calculations were performed on cyclic carbonates and sulfones using Density Functional Theory (DFT) for geometry optimization and DLPNO-CCSD(T) for final energy barriers.
  2. Automated Pipeline: An end-to-end computational pipeline was developed to scale the search for transition states (TS). This pipeline integrates SMILES/SMARTS reaction encoding, relaxed potential energy scans (PES), and nudged elastic band (NEB) calculations.
  3. Machine Learning Integration: A polarizable atom interaction neural network (PaiNN) was trained on over 1,000 generated geometries to evaluate the potential for ML-driven reaction path identification.

Kinetic Stability: Carbonates vs. Sulfones

The study reveals a stark contrast in the kinetic stability of different electrolyte classes against superoxide attack. Carbonates were found to be highly susceptible to nucleophilic attack, with reaction barriers typically $\le 26$ kcal/mol, translating to half-lives of only hours or days at room temperature.

Mechanism of superoxide attack on a cyclic carbonate, leading to ring opening.

In contrast, sulfones exhibited significantly higher activation barriers, generally ranging from 32 to 38 kcal/mol. These higher barriers suggest a kinetic half-life exceeding 5,500 years, marking sulfones as promising candidates for stable Li-air battery electrolytes.

Mechanism of superoxide attack on a cyclic sulfone, illustrating the ring-opening process.

Interestingly, the research debunked the assumption that increasing substitution always improves stability. In tetrasubstituted carbonates, steric strain from "eclipsed" substituents actually lowered the reaction barrier, making the molecules more reactive than their less-substituted counterparts.

Automation and Machine Learning Results

Automating the search for transition states remains a significant hurdle. The pipeline faced challenges with small, flexible radicals like superoxide, which often rotated into unintended "superoxide-catalyzed" orientations rather than the target $S_N2$ pathways. Despite these difficulties, the PaiNN potential showed promise, achieving a Mean Absolute Error (MAE) of 1.88 kcal/mol/Å for energy gradients.

Conclusion

This work establishes a framework for the high-throughput screening of electrolyte stability. While sulfones demonstrate superior kinetic resistance to superoxide attack, the path toward fully automated discovery requires further refinement of transition state search algorithms and the development of more robust interatomic neural network potentials. Future efforts will focus on reactive molecular dynamics to simulate real-time degradation across vast chemical spaces.

Summary updated

Abstract

This work provides a computation-driven investigation of the stability of organic electrolytes for lithium-air batteries. Electrolyte instability is currently a key challenge that limits practical use of aprotic Li-air batteries, and the chemical processes that cause this instability are often kinetically-driven. Computational screening for kinetic stability involves the determination of reaction barriers for the numerous potential reaction mechanisms, barriers that are challenging to calculate due to the difficulty of locating transition state structures. Here we screen a broad set of substituted electrolytes for susceptibility to nucleophilic attack by superoxide. We find that carbonates are not typically expected to be stable and that sulfones are generally stable, validating literature trends. We study the effects of chemical functionalization with electron-donating and withdrawing groups and their interplay with steric factors, identifying functional groups and other chemical modifications that increase stability in these groups. User-input driven transition state identification is used for these initial calculations, and an automated computational pipeline is subsequently presented and validated as a means to perform further high-throughput searches across mechanisms and chemistries. The pipeline integrates cheminformatics-based reaction encoding, relaxed potential energy scans, and nudged elastic band calculations for an end-to-end approach to barrier calculations. We review this automated search approach and its current limitations, and discuss challenges and further work.
BibTeX
@misc{singhal2023combined,
  author = {Avni Singhal and Shi Jun Ang and Livia Giordano and Rafael Gómez‐Bombarelli and Yang Shao‐Horn},
  title = {{Combined Experimental and Computational Efforts to Establish Ion Mobility, Solubility and Stability of Functional Liquids for Electrochemical Energy Storage}},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.2172/2403096},
}
Figure